REVIEWS
“Making the News sets forth the deceptively simple-sounding argument that the news agenda is not random but 'skewed' so that few issues reach and remain on the front page. By applying new methods to explain these patterns irrefutably and on a broad scale, Amber E. Boydstun makes a valuable contribution to the literature on political communication.”
— Regina Lawrence, University of Texas at Austin
"This is a seminal contribution about how the media work and influence democracy. Anyone interested in communication and democracy must read this book.”
— James N. Druckman, Northwestern University
“Amber E. Boydstun’s observation that the mass media processes information disproportionately is important enough, but she gives us much, much more: a theory of the causes of the lack of proportion and extensive empirical analyses of the dynamics of disproportionality based on a decade of stories on the front page of the New York Times. The result is a book that fully integrates the media with emerging theories of policy change. It will be widely read among media scholars as well as students of public policy, along with anyone who wants to understand the dynamics of media coverage.”
— Bryan D. Jones, University of Texas at Austin
“In Making the News, Amber Boydstun offers a detailed, empirical account of how news is made and, while celebrating the ongoing spirit of the fifth estate, questions the apparently reactive basis on which editorial decisions are made. . . . Boydstun’s extensive research is collected in pages of data and case studies, including analyses of the ongoing coverage of the ‘War on Terror’ and why, by contrast, smaller news items become front-page stories.”
— Times Literary Supplement
“[Boydstun’s] thoughtful approach, grounded largely in political science scholarship, will clearly be of interest to scholars working on media coverage of politics. . . . Recommended.”
— Choice
“[An] important book. . . . Boydstun has successfully imported and recalibrated a robust policy-attention model for media coverage; rigorously tested it across a number of issues, timespans, and sources; and, using computer simulation, estimated the precise skew of media attention. . . . [Making the News] is very likely to inspire further research, signaling its importance for political communication scholars, especially for those interested in agenda-setting and framing research.”
— Political Communication
“Boydstun demonstrates convincingly that existing theories on their own are inadequate to explain the familiar patterns in news coverage, and her book sets out to pull together these various perspectives to create and test a more complete theory of news generation that can account for the periods of explosive change and relative stability. . . . [Making the News] is an important contribution to political communication and a must-read for scholars and others who want to understand the impact of news media on the political system.”
— Public Opinion Quarterly
“Boydstun’s research provides fresh insight into the role of the media as a political institution, especially in the book’s treatment of news attention as a dynamic concept for analyzing coverage over time. As a result, this book holds significance for scholars interested in journalism, media, public policy, political science, and the societal effects of news coverage. Ultimately, Boydstun provides important analysis that helps concisely explain how familiar and perpetual cycles of current events and news coverage shape democratic governance.”
— Journalism
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Chapter 1. Patterns in the News and Why They Matter
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0001
[Media explosions, Skew, Explosiveness, Terri Schiavo, Public opinion, Public policy]
This chapter invites readers to recall ready examples of media explosions. These examples point to a media system that is prone to changing in fits and starts over time and, as a result, to producing skewed attention to events and their related policy problems, such that a few issues receive the lion's share of attention. The chapter focuses on one example in particular, the Terri Schiavo case of 2005, which illustrates the dramatic influence media explosions can have on public opinion and public policy application. The chapter outlines the basic arguments of the book and the political and social implications of endemic explosiveness and skew in the news. In instances like the Schiavo case, media explosions can shine light on string of events and underlying policy problems that have gone unattended for years. At the same time, while media explosions occupy the media agenda, there is a dearth of attention paid to other important issues. (pages 1 - 24)
Chapter 2. The Forces That Drive the News
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0002
[News generation, Political science, Communications, Organizational process, Marketplace, Competition, Institution, Disproportionate information processing, Dynamics, Momentum]
This chapter builds a unifying model of the news-generation process within three overlapping frameworks from past studies in political science and communications. (1) The media operates through an organizational process, in which journalists and news outlets assemble the news from each day's events based in part on news values and other institutional incentives. (2) The media is a marketplace, in which competition creates additional incentives that shape the operations of news outlets. (3) Political institutions (including the media) process information disproportionately, meaning that they do not attend to real-world events in real time or in proportion to the "size" of those events; instead, they lurch from one hot issue to the next at the exclusion of many other important issues. Overarching these three approaches, this chapter stresses the importance of dynamics and, in particular, momentum. Several of the variables that shape the news-generation process serve to reinforce coverage of issues already in the news during periods of fixation, but these same variables also fuel instances of explosive change when the news lurches to a new hot item. Momentum is thus key in driving the news-generation process and the patterns of skew and explosiveness that result. (pages 25 - 57)
Chapter 3. The Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model of News Generation
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0003
[News-generation, Watchdog press, Patrol system, Alarm system, Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model, Explosive, skew, momentum]
At stake in understanding the news-generation process is the idealized notion of a watchdog press. As scholars have long noted, the news media does not--indeed, cannot--operate as an ideal watchdog, using a "patrol" system to survey the landscape, constantly, for all information to convey to society. Instead, past research suggests that the media operates on an "alarm" system, attending only to those events/issues that trigger the social or political equivalent of an alarm. This chapter explains how news outlets do not operate strictly as patrol watchdogs, but neither do they operate strictly under an alarm system of news generation. The Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model details how and why news outlets lurch attention (selectively) to alarms that are sounded in key policy or geographic "neighborhoods," but then shift into patrol mode, staying locked on the hot news item. This unifying model thus integrates several variables identified by past research as shaping the news. These variables do not operate in isolation at each point in time--nor in isolation from one another. Rather, these variables tend to operate in self-reinforcing and mutually-reinforcing ways. The resulting momentum is what fuels explosive changes in media attention and, thus, skewed news coverage across issues. (pages 58 - 77)
Chapter 4. Content and Change on the New York Times Front Page
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0004
[Front page, New York Times, Skew, Explosiveness, Media explosions, News production]
This chapter presents an original dataset comprised of all New York Times front-page stories between 1996 and 2006 (over 31,000 stories in all), with each story coded by the primary issue addressed. As such, this dataset offers an unprecedented opportunity to examine a major media agenda in its entirety. Simple graphs provide a clear view of what the front-page agenda looks like. In the big picture, the front-page agenda is patterned by skew and explosiveness. While a few issues receive the vast majority of coverage, most receive hardly any attention. Looking over time, the front-page agenda tends to change hardly at all or all at once. The chapter unpacks these dynamics by offering a categorization by which we can think of different types of media explosions (timed, momentary, and sustained) driven by different modes of news production, as well as how these types of media explosions tend to play out in different types of issues (bread and butter, seasonal, and provisional). All together, these findings tell us that while the news may seem chaotic, it is in fact strongly governed by systemic forces and the resulting patterns of skew and explosive change. (pages 78 - 108)
Chapter 5. Explaining Front-Page Attention
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0005
[Front page, New York Times, Policy topics, Domestic policy, International policy, Statistical]
Chapter 5 presents a statistical model predicting monthly front-page attention from 1996 to 2006 across all major policy topics: health care, education, foreign trade, agriculture, etc. This model is estimated in three forms: across all policy topics, across domestic policy topics only, and across international policy topics only. Each model predicts the total number of front-page New York Times stories on each policy topic each month as a function of five key institutional variables: prior attention, policymaker attention, public concern, agenda congestion, and diversity of discussion. The findings show how each of these variables influences the content of the front page. While the news is impossible to predict from one day to the next, aggregate patterns in the news can be explained statistically. (pages 109 - 131)
Chapter 6. The Rise and Fall of the War on Terror and the Death Penalty in the News
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0006
[Statistical, Policy issues, War on terror, Capital punishment, Diversity of discussion, frame]
This chapter further demonstrates the ability to explain variance in news coverage statistically, this time in the context of two important policy issues: the U.S.-led military conflicts in Afghanistan and Iraq (a.k.a., the "war on terror") and capital punishment. This war and the death penalty represent very different kinds of policy debates. Yet the Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model helps to explain the rise and fall of both issues on the media agenda over time. In each case, statistical modeling shows that media attention to the issue is strongly driven by six key variables: events, prior attention, policymaker attention, public concern, agenda congestion, and diversity of discussion. The results broadly support the Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model of news-generation. More specifically, the results highlight the influence of diversity of discussion about an issue--measured as the diversity of the frames used in the news--on the attention the issue receives. How an issue gets talked about directly affects how much it gets talked about. (pages 132 - 151)
Chapter 7. How Institutional Mechanisms Lead to Media Skew and Explosiveness
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0007
[Skew, Explosiveness, Negative feedback, Positive feedback, Simulations, Institution, News generation]
This chapter demonstrates empirically the strong degrees of skew and explosiveness in the news. The theoretical discussion explains how skewed media attention across issues is due, in part, to variance in the political and social importance of the issues. But skew of the degree to which it occurs in the news--much stronger, for example, than the skew found on many other institutional agendas--is also the result of institutional forces. Specifically, this chapter points to negative feedback forces (which serve to mute change, fixating the news on current hot issues) and positive feedback forces (which serve to fuel change, lurching the news to new hot issues). It is the give-and-take between forces of negative and positive feedback that structures the Alarm/Patrol Hybrid Model. Positive feedback is especially important, taking the form of news outlets, policymakers, and citizens alike clamoring for more attention to hot issues that are already in the news. Simulation evidence shows that, in fact, the type of skew observed in the news can only be produced in the presence of significant positive feedback. Above and beyond the role of events in shaping the news, institutional positive feedback is one linchpin of the news-generation process. (pages 152 - 173)
Chapter 8. Skew and Explosiveness in the Shifting Media Landscape
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0008
[Media-wide, Television, Online, Explosiveness, Skew, Competition]
The New York Times front page exhibits strong patterns of skew and explosiveness, but do these patterns generalize to other media types? This chapter tests the idea that skew and explosiveness are media-wide phenomena. The chapter presents an original dataset of news coverage across newspaper, television, and online news outlets (nearly two million stories in all). Tests on this dataset confirm that strong patterns of skewed attention across issues and explosive change in attention over time exist across media types. Moreover, television and online news agendas exhibit even stronger skew and explosiveness than do newspapers, which makes sense given the heightened marketplace competition and scarcer resources of television and online news outlets. And in the case of online news, these patterns are further exacerbated by the fact that consumers interact with the medium, selecting which stories to read and which to ignore. Thus, while skew and explosiveness in the news may be normatively troubling, these patterns result not only from the media's institutional forces, but also from citizens themselves. (pages 174 - 194)
Chapter 9. Implications for Politics and Society
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226065601.003.0009
[Implications, Watchdog, Democracy, Explosiveness, Skew, Political]
The final chapter discusses the book's theoretical and practical implications. For the political system as a whole, the book reinvigorates the notion of the media functioning, at least sometimes, as a watchdog press--this is good news for democracy. Yet, paradoxically, periods of media watchdog surveillance serve to exacerbate explosiveness and skew in the news by lurching from one hot issue to the next (often before the first issue has been addressed) and, thus, by "over"-representing some policy issues at the neglect of others. For citizens, this system of news generation yields a troubling information diet, with disproportionate signals about the diversity of problems in the world and the tempo of problem resolution. Citizens can balance these signals by proactively consuming news from diverse sources, including traditional newspapers. For policymakers, explosiveness and skew in the news means that when government tries to respond proportionately to a policy problem, it will likely be doing so against the grain of media attention. At the same time, the explosive nature of the news acts as an antidote against political efforts to control the news for extended periods. (pages 195 - 210)
Appendix
Notes
References
Index