REVIEWS
“Sympathetic and wide-ranging. . . . The world she finds is terrifying and topsy-turvy. . . . When an old boys’ network becomes a young boys’ network, as Gershon so nicely puts it, there will be new kinds of exclusion at work.”
— Times Higher Education
"A fascinating, hands-on account of what's really required to get hired today."
— Peter Cappelli, author of Why Good People Can't Get Jobs
"Once upon a time, corporations were business enterprises which we were supposed to pretend, through a quaint legal fiction, were people. Nowadays it's rapidly becoming the other way around; people are being pressured to imagine themselves as business enterprises. In this beautifully written volume, Ilana Gershon explores the subtle violence that ensues when, in order to get a job, you have to apply branding and marketing techniques to your own personality, and reconfigure your very sense of being in the world as a result. In doing so, she reminds us, more than any other book I've read in recent years, of the power of anthropology not only to expose the hidden workings of our everyday common sense, but also to show how strange and arbitrary they really are, in a way that can make us rethink almost everything we take for granted."
— David Graeber, author of Debt: The First 5,000 Years
"Ilana Gershon vividly illuminates how workers have become 'brands' or 'businesses' in the new economy. Sounds liberating, but beware. As Gershon shows with numerous examples, the gain of the 'personal brand' may entail the loss of the person. And the gain of the 'personal business' may entail the loss of loyalty, security, and connection. This is a cautionary tale for all job seekers and the people who hire them."
— Barry Schwartz, author of Why We Work
"Gershon's unique insights redefine employees as a personal business with their own brand. Her work offers incredible tips for those being hired, including personal branding, preparing a unique (and generic) social media (e.g., LinkedIn) presence, demonstrating value to the employer, building a personal network of informed colleagues, working with recruiters and technology sites, and knowing when and how to move on. It also offers insights on how to do the recruiting as a line or HR manager. This is a creative, well researched, and useful book for those who want to be hired and for those doing the hiring."
— Dave Ulrich, author of HR from the Outside In
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction: The Company You Keep 1
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0001
[hiring;neoliberalism;employment contract]
The introduction lays out the overarching argument of the book: the basic metaphor people use to understand what it means to be a worker has changed. People used to think that they owned themselves as though they were rentable property. Now they think that they own themselves as though they are a business. Under the rentable property metaphor, as a worker, they brought capacities and skills to the workplace for a bounded period of time. The metaphor has changed, today people now think they own themselves as though they are a business – a bundle of skills, assets, qualities, experiences, and relationships, a bundle that must be consciously managed and constantly enhanced. A lot of the popular business literature now encourages people to think of themselves in business terms: as the “CEO of Me, Inc.” From this perspective, hiring resembles a business-to-business contract, a short-term connection for solving market-specific problems. To be employable you must represent yourself as a business of one, willing to temporarily assist other, larger businesses. This has not been an easy transition for many looking for jobs. The introduction lays the groundwork for understanding the problems people face when hiring follows the self-as-business model.
1 You Are Just like Coca-Cola: Selling Your Self through Personal Branding
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0002
[personal branding;authenticity;online presence]
Job seekers are increasingly encouraged to fashion a personal brand to get a job. Yet employers don’t seem to care about applicants’ personal brand. This chapter explores why personal branding might be such appealing advice for career counselors to offer and job seekers to hear as they try to manage their online presence regardless of its effectiveness. Personal branding is based on techniques originally developed to endow objects with personalities, now people are expected to evince personalities by deciding on the three or four phrases that best capture their authentic self. Seeing yourself as a brand means learning new ways of presenting yourself as having a predictable and reductive personality, an object-like personality. This creates new tensions in practice. Being consistent across all online platforms and contexts is challenging, as is demonstrating that you are unique in proscribed and standardized ways. In addition, people have to decide how “authentic” they want their personal brand to be, the chapter offers detailed cases in which this has been a complicated question to answer.
2 Being Generic—and Not—in the Right Way
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0003
[genre;genre repertoire;resume;LinkedIn profile;standardization]
To apply for a job, you create a genre repertoire to prove employability, a task accomplished by producing resumes, interview answers, business cards, and so on. In recent years, this genre repertoire has expanded to include new digital forms such as LinkedIn profile. Each of these different genres have their own requirements which need to be learned – and experts who are often there to teach you. All these standardized genres are a problem precisely because they are standardized and formulaic. These genres reduce all the complexities of a person’s experiences into the most telegraphic of glimpses into what a person has done in the past and could do in the future. But this isn’t actually the information employers need to make a good decision about who to hire. Each workplace is complex and rich in its own right, filled with its own social dynamics. As anyone involved in hiring knows, selecting a person to hire involves coordinating a group of people, each with their own strategies for interpreting the documents and selecting likely job candidates. In short, this is a chapter about the problems created by using such standardized formulaic genres for selecting who to hire.
3 Getting Off the Screen and Into Networks
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0004
[networking;weak ties;workplace ties;weak links;media ecologies]
Applicant tracking systems and too many applicants for each job have created an urgent problem for job applicants – how can you get a human being to notice your application? Career counselors and job seekers believe that effective networking is the solution. But what kind of networking? Mark Granovetter famously found in the early 1970’s that you tend to get a job through weak ties, largely because the problem at the time was finding out that the job existed in the first place. Yet the media ecology has changed substantially since Mark Granovetter’s study. Nowadays, the problem is not learning that the job exists, it is getting an employer to actually look at your resume. The people who can vouch for you most effectively are the people you have worked with in the past, and who can speak concretely to what you are like as a worker – workplace ties. In addition to discussing the growing importance of workplace ties, this chapter analyzes two different models of networking, one based on cultivating weak links and one based on researching target companies, and explains how this distinction is class-based.
4 Didn’t We Meet on LinkedIn?
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0005
[standardization;new media;LinkedIn;etiquette;adopting new technologies]
When a new medium is introduced, a widespread etiquette doesn’t spring up to accompany it out of the blue. It takes time and work. This chapter argues that how this widespread etiquette emerges has changed since the days that the telephone was first introduced, when companies, schools, and government offices all were heavily involved in creating explicit generic rules for media use. Nowadays, companies often expect communities of practice to decide together what proper use should be. This means that users are surrounded by technologies with different histories of standardization. This chapter describes some of the reasons why it is so complicated to have a widespread etiquette around LinkedIn use, a medium that many users desperately want to be accompanied by a clearly defined and generally agreed upon etiquette. Because LinkedIn is so central to contemporary job searches, there is careful image preening in a world were the most minor symbolic slip up might mean you are overlooked. It also addresses some of the moments with LinkedIn use in which users are often confused about what they should do.
5 Changing the Technological Infrastructure of Hiring
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0006
[startups;hiring;new technologies;participant structure;implied user]
Because the self-as-business model is a new take on hiring, not all the genres used to demonstrate employability developed earlier can adequately reflect what it now means to be a desirable worker. A number of companies are trying to address this gap by developing more appropriate technology. This chapter analyzes how these companies design platforms that presume users operate as a self-as-business. For example, if the self-as-business is a bundle of skills, experiences, and qualities, it turns out that not all the current documents used in hiring showcase these components effectively. Personal qualities are not easily gleaned from resumes or LinkedIn profiles. This lack inspired the founder of Knack, a start-up company, to design cognitive tests in the guise of video games that supposedly measure an individual’s qualities -- how imaginative, inquisitive, or adaptable one is. Job-seekers playing Knack’s games will be able to provide future employers with metrics of their personal qualities to supplement their resumes. Knack is but one of a number of companies this chapter analyzes that are designing technologies to implement this new model of the self.
6 The Decision Makers: What It Means to Be a Hiring Manager, Recruiter, or HR Person
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0007
[HR;hiring manager;recruiter;workplace conflict;work role;institutional role]
This chapter addresses how people’s institutional roles affect how the hiring process unfolds. Workplaces can sometimes be places with predictable conflicts, because there are so many moments in which doing your job well will get in the way of how someone else does their job. Certain tensions predictably emerge during the hiring process between recruiters, hiring managers, and HR professionals. Much of the time people within a firm are more concerned with keeping other people involved happy than finding the perfect candidate. Often managers who are hiring are focused on other issues and just want to fill a gap. Human resource officers want to ensure all the correct procedures are followed. Recruitment consultants just want to fill the position, collect their finder’s fee and keep the client primed for repeat business. Typically there are conflicts between these different groups in the process of hiring. Often the candidate themselves fades into the background – they become an after-thought in this game.
7 When Moving On Is the New Normal
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0008
[temporary jobs;quitting;emotional labor;passion;company loyalty]
If every job is temporary, than quitting or getting laid off is always just around the corner. This chapter argues that quitting, or getting fired, is now the engine that makes contemporary hiring what it is today. It discusses all the social labor involved in quitting. In the context of quitting, passion for one's work has come to replace company loyalty as the most desirable emotion for workers to feel. This chapter explores how this shift contributes to a career comprised of a string of relatively short term jobs.
Conclusion: We Wanted a Labor Force but Human Beings Came Instead
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226452289.003.0009
[neoliberalism;employment contract;workers;hiring]
The conclusion discusses the larger structural consequences of living by the self-as-business model. It also suggests some possible arguments people could use to improve workers' lots under the framing of self-as-business. The overall assessment is not optimistic, however, and the conclusion points out more of the limitations of the model, stressing how it all too often privileges the employer instead of the employee. The final section summarizes what insights an anthropologist has on the hiring process, discussing how to analyze what jobs you might want or what networking ties you might want to focus upon.