The Democratic Surround Multimedia and American Liberalism from World War II to the Psychedelic Sixties
by Fred Turner
University of Chicago Press, 2013
Cloth: 978-0-226-81746-0 | Paper: 978-0-226-32589-7 | Electronic: 978-0-226-06414-7
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

We commonly think of the psychedelic sixties as an explosion of creative energy and freedom that arose in direct revolt against the social restraint and authoritarian hierarchy of the early Cold War years. Yet, as Fred Turner reveals in The Democratic Surround, the decades that brought us the Korean War and communist witch hunts also witnessed an extraordinary turn toward explicitly democratic, open, and inclusive ideas of communication and with them new, flexible models of social order. Surprisingly, he shows that it was this turn that brought us the revolutionary multimedia and wild-eyed individualism of the 1960s counterculture.

In this prequel to his celebrated book From Counterculture to Cyberculture, Turner rewrites the history of postwar America, showing how in the 1940s and ’50s American liberalism offered a far more radical social vision than we now remember. Turner tracks the influential mid-century entwining of Bauhaus aesthetics with American social science and psychology. From the Museum of Modern Art in New York to the New Bauhaus in Chicago and Black Mountain College in North Carolina, Turner shows how some of the most well-known artists and intellectuals of the forties developed new models of media, new theories of interpersonal and international collaboration, and new visions of an open, tolerant, and democratic self in direct contrast to the repression and conformity associated with the fascist and communist movements. He then shows how their work shaped some of the most significant media events of the Cold War, including Edward Steichen’s Family of Man exhibition, the multimedia performances of John Cage, and, ultimately, the psychedelic Be-Ins of the sixties. Turner demonstrates that by the end of the 1950s this vision of the democratic self and the media built to promote it would actually become part of the mainstream, even shaping American propaganda efforts in Europe.

Overturning common misconceptions of these transformational years, The Democratic Surround shows just how much the artistic and social radicalism of the sixties owed to the liberal ideals of Cold War America, a democratic vision that still underlies our hopes for digital media today.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Fred Turner is associate professor of communication at Stanford University. He is the author of Echoes of Combat: The Vietnam War in American Memory and From Counterculture to Cyberculture: Stewart Brand, the Whole Earth Network, and the Rise of Digital Utopianism, also published by the University of Chicago Press. He lives in California.
 

REVIEWS

“Turner’s book offers an important look at how our technologies might, or might not, resonate with the democratic politics many of us hope to better exercise.”
— Los Angeles Review of Books

“The Democratic Surround is a dazzling cultural history that demonstrates how American intellectuals, artists, and designers from the 1930s to the 1960s imagined new kinds of collective events—different from fascism’s crowds—that were intended to promote a powerful experience of American democracy in action. Drawing parallels across a wide set of venues—from MoMA’s Road to Victory and Family of Man shows of the mid-century period to the 1959 National Exhibition in Moscow to the Happenings of the sixties counterculture, Turner challenges us to think about the lines between information, entertainment, art, and propaganda. Along the way he shows how important the media have become to the design of collective experiences and forms of democratic citizenship. A brilliant argument from a gifted writer, this book not only informs but also surprises!”
— Lynn Spigel, author of TV by Design: Modern Art and the Rise of Network Television

“This is the true story of how a small group of artists and anthropologists set out to create an alternative to fascism during World War II—and ended up setting the stage for the consumer-driven, media-saturated world we inhabit today. A gripping, well-balanced, and surprising history.”

— Douglas Rushkoff, author of Present Shock: When Everything Happens Now.

“The photographic wartime propaganda of Road to Victory or the post-war humanism of The Family of Man usually don't come to mind when accounting for Happenings, Be-Ins, expanded cinema, or Andy Warhol’s Exploding Plastic Inevitable, but they are tightly woven in the social fabric of Fred Turner’s The Democratic Surround. In what will surely be a controversial revision, Turner maps the attempts of social scientists, industrial designers, European expats, and others to mold democratic personalities as a bulwark against authoritarianism, forming a civil foundation upon which arose spatial media experiments of the arts and counterculture of the 1960s. From an Americana more associated with Aaron Copland comes the radical surround sound of John Cage; from image management of psyches, psychedelic media environments.”
— Douglas Kahn, author of Noise, Water, Meat: A History of Sound in the Arts

“The history of ideas is intellectual archeology, and Stanford professor Turner is a man with a well-whetted pickaxe and an arsenal of delicate brushes.”
— Arts Fuse

“The creators of 1960s happenings claimed that they were using sights and music to undermine the fascist American state. However, as Turner demonstrates here, the legacy of happenings dates back to WWII, and they enjoyed significant governmental support. Looking at American concerns with the abuse of media by fascist leaders like Adolf Hitler, the author makes a convincing argument that leftist artists and social scientist developed a theory of multimedia installations what would use mass communication techniques to further the cause of democracy rather than undermine it. . . . This book represents a significant contribution to literature on mass media and its uses in the 20th century. Highly recommended.”
— Choice

“What makes the book so fascinating as both an intellectual and cultural history is Turner’s ability to juggle multiple disciplines and schools of thought, all the while showing how a diverse lot of thinkers were grappling with the same questions about democracy, personality, and technology.  . . . [An] excellent and thought-provoking book.”
— Tropics of Meta

“The Democratic Surround is the book Alexis de Tocqueville would have written if, instead of spending his time with the respectable menfolk of New England in the 1830s, he had been lucky enough to hang out with the psychedelic pioneers of the California of the 1960s. Once he got over the initial shock (and it should not have taken him long: Tocqueville had seen his share of radical enthusiasts), he would have realized that in a prosperous and populous America at the peak of its Cold War glory, the experience of participation in a democratic polity was increasingly dependent on the immersion of its citizens in all—enveloping media environments, tightly composed communicative architectures where they could receive a vivid impression of life in a diverse and egalitarian society. . . .The achievement of Turner’s book is to reveal the technical and aesthetic mediations—a heady combination of social-scientific ideas, multi-media formats, and new styles of artistic installation and performance—that enabled this phenomenological recalibration of the American democratic experience.”
— Journal of Cultural Economy

TABLE OF CONTENTS


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0000
[Democratic surround, intellectual network, social network, Marshall McLuhan, psychedelia, counterculture, Cyberculture, 1960s, From Counterculture to Cyberculture]
The introduction summarizes the book’s account of the rise of the democratic surround and its impact on cold war America. It examines key intellectual networks and social networks and argues that the democratic surrounds they designed became prototypes for a more liberal American society. It shows how the search for a democratic mode of propaganda during World War II helped bring to life the media theories of Marshall McLuhan and the psychedelia of the 1960s. It also shows how this book is a prequel to my last, From Counterculture to Cyberculture. (pages 1 - 12)

Part One: World War II and the Making of the Democratic Surround


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0001
[Gustave Le Bon, mass society, mass media, Orson Welles, War of the Worlds, Theodor Adorno, communication, intellectuals, artists]
This chapter shows that many Americans believed that mass media created the psychological conditions for fascism at the start of World War II. These ideas came from two sources: first, from European and European-refugee theories of mass society and mass media created by writers such as Gustave Le Bon and Theodor Adorno, and second, from American experiences of mass media such as Orson Welles’s “War of the Worlds” radio broadcast of 1938. By the time combat in Europe began, the chapter shows that American intellectuals tended to agree: the one-to-many dynamics of mass media produced authoritarian psychological tendencies. If they hoped to promote democratic unity, it concludes, intellectuals and artists agreed that they would need to find a new and more democratic mode of communication. (pages 15 - 38)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0002
[Committee for National Morale, democratic personality, Erich Fromm, Karen Horney, Harry Stack Sullivan, Margaret Mead, Gregory Bateson, media environment, multi-screen, attention]
This chapter follows the formation of the Committee for National Morale and the formulation of the following concepts: the democratic personality, democratic morale, and the democratic surround. It tracks the interaction of Freudian psychologists such as Erich Fromm, Karen Horney and Harry Stack Sullivan with anthropologists such as Margaret Mead and Gregory Bateson in New York in the early 1940s. It shows how together they modeled the democratic personality in opposition to their understanding of the fascist personality. It also shows how they dreamed of creating multi-screen, multi-sound-source media environments that might solicit democratic modes of attention based on choice, the integration of variety, and the celebration of individual perspective. These characteristics, it concludes, were the keys to the democratic personality and to democratic morale in the view of the social scientists discussed here. (pages 39 - 76)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0003
[Herbert Bayer, László Moholy-Nagy, multi-screen media, New Man, New Bauhaus, Road to Victory, Museum of Modern Art, Edward Steichen, immersive media]
This chapter shows how Bauhaus refugee artists such as Herbert Bayer and László Moholy-Nagy transformed Bauhaus aesthetics into tools for producing democratic Americans. In Germany, Bauhaus artists had developed immersive multi-screen media techniques. They hoped these techniques would help produce what they called the “New Man” – a person who could withstand the psychologically fragmenting assault of life in industrial society. The chapter first follows Moholy-Nagy to the New Bauhaus in Chicago where he sought to train a new generation of artists in Bauhaus techniques for purposes of creating a new “New Man” – the American democrat. It then tracks Bayer to The Museum of Modern Art in New York, where he worked with Edward Steichen to develop the blockbuster propaganda exhibition “Road to Victory” in 1942. In both cases, it shows how Bauhaus aesthetics became the basis of the visual elements of the democratic surround. (pages 77 - 114)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0004
[John Cage, aleatory aesthetics, Black Mountain College, 4’33”, Eastern philosophy, Bauhaus aesthetics, propaganda]
At the same time that Herbert Bayer and Edward Steichen were reconfiguring the visual landscape of propaganda with “Road to Victory,” the fusion of Bauhaus aesthetics and democratic idealism that drove their installations was also helping to create a parallel transformation in the structure and performance of music. This chapter tracks that transformation by following composer John Cage from his early encounters with Bauhaus artists, to Black Mountain College in the late 1940s, to the performance of his most infamous piece, 4’33”, in 1952. Scholars have traditionally argued that Cage’s aleatory aesthetics emerged after his encounter with Eastern philosophy in the early 1950s. This chapter shows that his urge to democratize sounds and the performance process grew as much if not more out of his search for democratic modes of communication – a search he shared with many others during World War II. (pages 115 - 148)

Part Two: The Deomocratic Surround in the Cold War


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0005
[Lyman Bryson, Norbert Wiener, Harold Lasswell, Charles Morris, UNESCO, Tensions Project, social psychology, cold war, democratic personality, authoritarian personality]
After World War II, communism replaced fascism as the key totalitarian threat for many Americans. But as this chapter shows, the fear that mass media promoted authoritarian personalities and totalitarian societies persisted. This chapter first explores theories of democratic personality and democratic society promoted by intellectuals such as Lyman Bryson, Norbert Wiener, Harold Lasswell and Charles Morris. The chapter then examines UNESCO’s 1948 “Tensions Project,” a much-heralded conference at which social scientists gathered from across America and Europe to rethink international relations in terms of interpersonal social psychology. The chapter thus shows that the theories of the democratic personality and democratic morale developed at the start of World War Two and the intellectual networks that created them outlasted the war. Together they set the stage for the deployment of the democratic surround in the cold war era. (pages 151 - 180)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0006
[Victor D’Amico, War Veterans Art Center, People’s Art Center, Bauhaus pedagogy, Family of Man, mass communication, managerial control, Museum of Modern Art, Edward Steichen]
After World War II, The Museum of Modern Art in New York built multimedia environments designed to help democratize American families and through them, the post-war world. This chapter focuses on Victor D’Amico’s work at the Museum’s War Veterans Art Center, later called the People’s Art Center. It shows how D’Amico deployed Bauhaus pedagogy to help his pupils practice integrating diverse experiences into their psyches and hopefully thereby, diverse people into their society. The chapter then studies the 1955 Museum exhibition The Family of Man. The chapter shows how Edward Steichen designed the exhibition in terms set by “Road to Victory” in 1942. It also shows how those ideals now promoted the egalitarian diversity taught by Victor D’Amico. Finally, it argues that even as these events at the Museum challenged the top-down hierarchies of mass communication and fascist society, they also introduced visitors to a new mode of managerial control. (pages 181 - 212)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0007
[United States Information Agency, pavilion, Brussels World’s Fair, American National Exhibition, Black Mountain College, Bauhaus, democratic surround, propaganda, cold war, 1950s]
This chapter shows how the democratic surround became a tool for the United States Information Agency’s overseas propaganda. In the late 1950s, American officials deployed multi-image, multi-sound-source environments as pavilions at commercial exhibitions across Europe, at the Brussels World’s Fair, and at the American National Exhibition in Moscow. As they did, they repurposed the work of Bauhaus designers and Black Mountain College artists, and of Edward Steichen and Victor D’Amico. Like these earlier figures, cold war propagandists designed their surrounds to turn the psyches of their visitors in more democratic and so pro-American directions. But this time, their visitors were citizens of foreign states. Thus, they developed new tools for monitoring the psychological effects of their work, transforming the surround into an ever-more-closely controlled environment. The chapter concludes that these environments thus modeled not only democratic freedoms, but a world governed by the distant, benevolent technocrats of the American state. (pages 213 - 258)


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226064147.003.0008
[Surround aesthetics, John Cage, Allan Kaprow, Happenings, Human Be-In, Sumer of Love, counterculture]
This chapter shows how the surround aesthetics and pro-democratic vision that drove cold war American propaganda overseas in the late 1950s became key building blocks of the 1960s counterculture. It follows John Cage from his performance at the Brussels World’s Fair to the downtown New York art world. There Cage brought the egalitarian social theories and environmental aesthetics of the surround to Allan Kaprow and the first Happenings. The Happenings in turn became the basis of performances by the USCO art troupe and through them, of the 1967 Human Be-In in San Francisco’s Golden Gate Park that helped spark that year’s “Summer of Love.” The chapter thus shows how the modes of democratic personality, democratic society, and democratic media called for at the start of World War II and celebrated by American propagandists throughout the cold war also helped give rise to the counterculture. (pages 259 - 294)

Acknowledgments

Notes

Bibliography

Index