This book is so far ahead of the curve in this field of study that it is in a different time zone…a vigorous, excoriating rebuttal of current ideological myths about the era and the land, and the impact of the Europeans on central Asia and the Indian subcontinent…an intelligent, courageous, and important work, rooted in common sense and sturdy research.
-- Abdullah Drury Muslim World Book Review
Brilliant…An outstanding book, which makes a significant contribution to our understanding of Sufism, modern Islamic thought, and the social and political history of the Persianate world.
-- Fitzroy Morrissey Asian Affairs
Ziad does an exceptional job of demonstrating how the Persianate zone was intrinsically bound by dynamic Sufi networks in the eighteenth to twentieth centuries and how these networks provided a place for the exchange of various forms of knowledge and the establishment of institutional structures that continue to be influential until this day.
-- Lulie El-Ashry Religious Studies Review
An important work…Ziad provides a riveting account of how history has buffeted the fortunes of the Mujadidi Sufis, from Punjab to the Peshawar valley, Kabul, Bukhara and Turkey.
-- Farrukh Husain Friday Times
Hidden Caliphate announces the arrival of a major new scholar. By focusing on the more recent past of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, Ziad recenters the study of the Sufi tradition, which all too often has been relegated to the realm of metaphysics and poetry. He brings a contested period to light with encyclopedic insight. I heartily recommend this book.
-- Omid Safi, author of The Politics of Knowledge in Premodern Islam: Negotiating Ideology and Religious Inquiry
A major achievement. In this innovative, well-written book Ziad shows us a region knit together by the networks of the Naqshbandi-Mujaddidi Sufis. He is the first to set out their massive influence across Central Asia, Afghanistan, and northwest South Asia, and in the process reveals how limited was the understanding of the colonial powers in the Great Game.
-- Francis Robinson, author of The Mughal Emperors: And the Islamic Dynasties of India, Iran and Central Asia, 1206–1925
Equipped with an impressive array of primary sources, Ziad skillfully dismantles restrictive notions of region and sovereignty and casts aside binaries such as that of Sufis and ulama. He then offers us a breathtaking view of a Persian cosmopolis held together by vibrant networks of Naqshbandi Sufis in the politically turbulent eighteenth century. This hugely important book should be read across a range of disciplines.
-- Supriya Gandhi, author of The Emperor Who Never Was: Dara Shukoh in Mughal India
A pioneering study of the Mujaddidi Sufi networks that spanned the eastern Islamic world, from Siberia to India, in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Grounded in a prodigious range of sources, Hidden Caliphate shows how the order’s doctrinal, ritual, and institutional dimensions offered intellectual and social cohesion for Muslims across this vast region before and after the advent of colonial domination.
-- Devin DeWeese, author of Studies on Sufism in Central Asia
Refreshingly original, Hidden Caliphate shows how the Mujaddidi Sufis combined high textual tradition with ecstatic Sufism and local rituals and thus built a seminal authority to unite diverse communities across Central Asia, Afghanistan, and South Asia. Ziad brings a vital new perspective on a region long understood only through the narrow lens of European imperial histories.
-- Muzaffar Alam, author of The Mughals and the Sufis: Islam and Political Imagination in India, 1500–1750
A brilliant transregional study of the Naqshbandi-Mujaddidi scholastic–religious networks (the batini khilafat) in Khurasan, Hindustan, and Transoxiana that significantly advances the field of Persianate studies. Ziad traces sacred networks of cultural and economic exchange as well as the leadership structure that helped maintain a degree of stability during a time of political decentralization. A must-read for all interested in Sufism, the Persianate sphere in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and the history of the Afghan empire.
-- Jo-Ann Gross, Professor of History, Emeritus, The College of New Jersey