The British critic and scholar Christopher Ricks said of Ellmann’s biography that it ‘engages every aspect of Joyce’s life and interests,’ from the amatory to the political to the domestic…‘Ellmann’s Joyce’ does the same for its likable subject.
-- James Campbell Wall Street Journal
[An] evenhanded, well-written and sometimes provocative biography.
-- Michael Dirda Washington Post
Leader explores in detail topics involved in the book’s creation—sleuthing methods, rivals, reviewers—as well as its afterlife…Running in the background of this meta-biography is a history of literature as a discipline in America.
-- Eric Bulson The Atlantic
An unusual and engaging book, half an account of Ellmann’s life leading up to the Joyce biography, and half a detailed history of the book’s composition and its subsequent place within Joycean scholarship.
-- Seamus Perry London Review of Books
I have always been grateful to Ellmann for taking such a democratizing approach to this most despotic of authors, just as I am now to Leader for following suit…what Zachary Leader gives us is a richly researched, nuanced portrait of the earlier life and working processes of a writer who not only shone light into one of the great literary minds of the twentieth century, but, in the process, became one in his own right.
-- Eimear McBride Times Literary Supplement
Leader’s meta-biographical approach offers a case study, in effect, for the stakes of thinking about biography as an art…Leader has written an engaging and, moreover, fair account of what was probably the most important literary biography of the 20th century.
-- Michelle Taylor The Nation
The way in which Ellmann’s remarkable biography came into being is the subject of an unusual and eminently humane new book by Zachary Leader, himself a distinguished practitioner of the erudite yet highly readable doorstopper school of biography that Ellmann pioneered, via his lives of Kingsley Amis and Saul Bellow…[offers] a lucid account of what makes Ellmann such a consummate practitioner of an art of writing that, Leader clearly feels, does not always receive the respect that it deserves.
-- Joe Moshenska The Observer
A wise, balanced and utterly compelling biography.
-- Frances Wilson The Spectator
An admirable feat of literary excavation, Leader goes behind the scenes and reveals not just how the biography came to be but what Ellmann himself was like, as both a family man and as a Northwestern University scholar…You don’t need to love Joyce to enjoy Ellmann’s Joyce.
-- Jim Kelly Airmail
A fascinating account of how the biographer came to write his magnum opus.
-- Marjorie Brennan Irish Examiner
Takes readers on a dazzling intellectual tour…A singular achievement worthy of notice, both in its exploration of character and as a defense of the biographer’s art.
-- Michael O'Donnell American Scholar
[Leader] writes not only with great respect for the labour involved, but with a sense of its understated drama… makes a compelling case for the validity and critical value of the often maligned genre of literary biography.
-- James Ley Australian Book Review
The fullest account yet available of the writing of the great James Joyce biography.... more than just a biography. It is an exploration of the making of the very craft it exemplifies, a fascinating study of the creation of two legends: that of the writer with whom Ellmann's work deals and that of the biography itself.
-- Terence Killeen Irish Times
Leader is himself a distinguished biographer…[in this book] he offers an extended homage to a master in his field.
-- Rhodri Lewis Literary Review
A fascinating account of the sleuthing, diplomacy, energy, patience, curiosity, luck and — perhaps most of all — the sheer unadorned time necessary to write a good biography…Perhaps it is a peculiar kind, but to read an expansive account of how scholarship is done, how new work builds on old work, and how one of the monumental biographies of the twentieth centuries came to be is…exhilarating.
-- Patrick Mullins Inside Story
Leader‘s book, superbly written, is itself a marvel of the biographer‘s art. From start to finish I was pleasurably absorbed by the wealth of detail so deftly handled, and the sharp literary and cultural insights on display.
-- Ian Thomson The Tablet
Leader deserves our thanks for this fascinating tribute.
-- David Herman Jewish Chronicle
A riveting glimpse inside the biography writing process, this scintillates.
-- Publishers Weekly (starred review)
Ellmann is fortunate to have Leader to take up his cause…a fine and unusual book.
-- Jonathan Clarke City Journal
[A] fascinating book…Leader brilliantly conveys the life-writer’s exciting pursuit of Joyce’s family and friends, and his frequent discovery of vital information.
-- Jeffrey Meyers The Article
An engaging and interesting double biography, of man and work.
-- M. A. Orthofer Complete Review
An ingeniously conceived and beautifully executed book by a preeminent literary biographer. It is compulsively readable as well as profoundly sympathetic, drawing a memorable portrait of a fascinating man and his intellectual milieu, and making an important statement about literary biography, its form, uses, and implications. A remarkable achievement.
-- R. F. Foster, author of W. B. Yeats: A Life
A biography of a biographer by a biographer is, for a biographer like myself, a welcome, exciting, and above all rare event. Though the story is hardly ever told, Zachary Leader knows that what goes into the making of a great biography is often as much of a story as the story itself. With Ellmann’s Joyce, Leader shows how biographers think and work, and how their thinking and working shapes the posthumous destinies of those they write about.
-- Benjamin Moser, author of the Pulitzer Prize–winning Sontag: Her Life and Work
Zachary Leader's biography of Richard Ellmann uncovers the struggles and secrets of Ellmann's life with great empathy and inimitable panache. Objective and affectionate, gossipy and grand, this book is a great read.
-- Elaine Showalter, author of The Civil Wars of Julia Ward Howe: A Biography
Zachary Leader has given us the gift of explanation without simplification. This is a masterpiece of insight and dignified audacity, sure to immortalize its subject—the art of literary biography and one of its greatest practitioners, Richard Ellmann.
-- Declan Kiberd, author of Ulysses and Us