Questioning Secularism Islam, Sovereignty, and the Rule of Law in Modern Egypt
by Hussein Ali Agrama
University of Chicago Press, 2012
Cloth: 978-0-226-01068-7 | Paper: 978-0-226-01069-4 | Electronic: 978-0-226-01070-0
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The central question of the Arab Spring—what democracies should look like in the deeply religious countries of the Middle East—has developed into a vigorous debate over these nations’ secular identities. But what, exactly, is secularism? What has the West’s long familiarity with it inevitably obscured? In Questioning Secularism, Hussein Ali Agrama tackles these questions. Focusing on the fatwa councils and family law courts of Egypt just prior to the revolution, he delves deeply into the meaning of secularism itself and the ambiguities that lie at its heart.
 
Drawing on a precedent-setting case arising from the family law courts —the last courts in Egypt to use Shari‘a law—Agrama shows that secularism is a historical phenomenon that works through a series of paradoxes that it creates. Digging beneath the perceived differences between the West and Middle East, he highlights secularism’s dependence on the law and the problems that arise from it: the necessary involvement of state sovereign power in managing the private spiritual lives of citizens and the irreducible set of legal ambiguities such a relationship creates. Navigating a complex landscape between private and public domains, Questioning Secularism lays important groundwork for understanding the real meaning of secularism as it affects the real freedoms of a citizenry, an understanding of the utmost importance for so many countries that are now urgently facing new political possibilities.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Hussein Ali Agrama is assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Chicago. 

REVIEWS

“At a time when Egypt is consumed with debates about the role of Islam in the constitution and the role of the courts, Agrama’s book offers unique and fascinating insight into the actual operation of Islamic laws in Egyptian society. . . . Simply fascinating.” 
— Marc Lynch, Foreign Policy

“This highly innovative book is a real feast for the mind. A tour de force in the anthropology of Islam, it will be of great value to students of religion and secularism as well as to legal studies beyond Egypt and even beyond the Middle East.”
— Abdelmajid Hannoum, American Ethnologist

“Questioning Secularism is an important book. The discussions of the fatwa court alone would warrant praise, but there is much more: the exploration of how the secular state produces its own ambiguities is very engaging; the idea that different fora might employ related sources of legitimacy is handled with considerable deftness; the argument that the fatwa is a different sort of journey than the court proceeding is pursued with great care and insight. The overall result, then, is a work one can get one’s teeth into in the best sense of the word.”

— Lawrence Rosen, Princeton University

“Questioning Secularism is a mind-widening book. It is not simply a contestation or reconstruction of the doctrines of secularism but an enquiry into the ways in which it continually generates questions—about necessary limitations to public expression, about the dangers of religious politics, about the place of the Shari‘a in a liberal state, and so forth. At the center of these questions, says Agrama, is the concern to determine the line between politics and religion. Agrama explores this theme brilliantly in the context of contemporary Egypt by drawing on a rich body of ethnographic and historical data, and presents the reader with valuable insights into the ways sovereignty, public order, and state of exception are implicated (often in contradictory ways) in the question of secularism in that country. The most innovative part of this impressive work is the comparison between the Egyptian family court and the Fatwa Council, both based on understandings of the Shari‘a but each very different in its conditions of existence and its orientation. This book is essential reading for anyone interested in secularism today.”

— Talal Asad, City University of New York

“This is one of the most exciting and original books I have read on the issue of secularism, law, Islam, and the Middle East. Agrama handles some of the toughest questions at the center of the current debate on secularism: What is the relationship between political secularism and sovereign power? What are the affects and sensibilities that underlie the secular state’s claim to religious neutrality? How are the ethical claims of secularism tied to its political and legal restructuring of religion? This is intellectual thinking at its best. No one interested in the much touted confrontation between religion and secularism, between Islam and liberalism, can afford to ignore this book.”
— Saba Mahmood, author of Politics of Piety

“Questioning Secularism is one of the most innovative, pathbreaking interventions into contemporary debates on the secular to date. Based on extensive ethnographic research in Egypt, the book provides a theoretically sophisticated and highly original analysis of the conceptual and practical ambivalences and contradictions at the core of Egypt’s legal and religious institutions. The implications of Hussein Ali Agrama’s argument for our understanding of the modern career of religion and secularity are vast, extending well beyond Egypt and the Middle East. Scholars concerned with these twin concepts cannot afford to ignore the challenge Agrama’s work poses to the field.”
— Charles Hirschkind, author of The Ethical Soundscape

TABLE OF CONTENTS

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0001
[Egypt, secularism, religion]
This introductory first chapter sets out the book's purpose, which is to address the question of whether Egypt is a secular or a religious state. The aim, however, is not to provide an answer either way, secular or religious. Rather, the goal is to elicit a different understanding of this question, its presuppositions, the forms it takes, the affects that infuse it, its conditions of felicity, and its resilient force. The chapter then describes how the book's chapters came together, the motivations of the initial project, the assumptions that had to be dropped or revised, and how all of this led to an exploration and rethinking of secularism. These lay the groundwork for the arguments of the chapters and articulate some of the critical conceptual orientations that implicitly guide them. (pages 1 - 41)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0002
[legal transformation, Islam, apostasy, court judgments, Egypt, Islamic Shari'a]
This chapter examines how legal transformations have affected the Shari'a and how the construction of new legal conditions has altered the significance of specific Islamic concepts and practices in Egypt. It does so through a contemporary, controversial, set of court judgments about Islam and apostasy, concerning a former university professor by the name of Nasr Abu Zayd. The chapter highlights some of the modern concepts and spaces reflected by the court judgments, and how the Islamic Shari'a has become configured through them. In the process, it looks at some of the specific historical changes that put those modern concepts and spaces in place. The principles invoked in the Abu Zayd judgments are particularly important for understanding how the Islamic Shari'a has become configured under Egypt's modernizing project. (pages 42 - 68)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0003
[Egypt, secularity, religiosity, religious state, secularism, questioning power]
This chapter argues that the question of whether Egypt is a secular or religious state is neither an answerable nor a false one. Rather, it is a question whose persistence, force, and inability to be resolved reflects the peculiar intractability of contemporary secularity. The question of Egypt's secularity or religiosity is an expression of secularism's characteristic tensions and its distinctive modes of power, sensibility, and instability. Secularism must be crucially understood as a questioning power, as a modality of power that operates through the activity of questioning and contestation that it animates. (pages 69 - 106)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0004
[Islam, paradoxical authority, rule of law, questioning power]
This chapter discusses some of the paradoxes of Islamic authority encountered in Egypt. It begins with some observations on the paradoxical authority of the rule of law more generally. That paradoxical authority is key to understanding secularism as a questioning power. (pages 107 - 129)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0005
[suspicion, courts, legislation, rule of law, secularism, legal authority]
This chapter examines the forms that suspicion takes in the courts and through legislation, and its broader consequences for the authority of the rule of law as well as those religious concepts and practices that have been subsumed under it. Modern legal conditions are indispensable to secularism as a problem-space, and thus as a power that works through the activity of critical questioning that it facilitates. The chapter highlights two findings: (i) that critical questioning goes hand in hand with the assertion of sovereign capacity into broader and more intimate domains of everyday life; and (ii) it becomes impossible to determine whether that sovereign power is secular or religious in character. (pages 130 - 159)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0006
[muftis, fatwas, Fatwa Council]
This chapter describes the style and manner of the muftis in dispensing their fatwas, in connection with the concepts and understood goals of the Fatwa Council. It offers a better understanding of the nature of the Fatwa Council's authority, and the general lack of suspicion within it. (pages 160 - 187)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0007
[Islamist lawyers, Egypt, legal practice, state of emergency, rights, rule of law, zulm]
This chapter examines how Islamist lawyers engaged the Egyptian emergency state through their legal practices. It highlights four dimensions of the author's fieldwork with Islamist lawyers: their notion of the human as essentially situated; their concept of zulm as a motivation and as associated with perversions of the law; their invocations of Islamic narratives to frame their work and the experiences of detainees; and the tactical but reverent uses of Qur'anic verses in their legal briefs in order to highlight and challenge zulm. It argues that an ongoing state of emergency in Egypt had enabled Islamist lawyers to express and employ a language of justice, rooted in Islamic traditions and resonant with the foundational narratives of the state, in order to set the law back in motion. That language, while it exhibits a critical dimension concerning “the human” as essentially a subject of rights, works to animate a discourse that reduces “the human” to essentially a subject of rights. (pages 188 - 223)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Hussein Ali Agrama
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226010700.003.0008
[Egypt, secularity, religion, current events]
On January 25, 2011, protests that began on that afternoon grew into a massive wave that overtook the entire country and brought down Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak's thirty-year rule in just eighteen days. Since then Egypt has embarked upon a precarious process of removing and transforming many of the entrenched elements that defined the former regime. This chapter asks whether anything can be learned from these events that go beyond Egypt. That is, beyond the typically narrow analytical frameworks (i.e., “Middle Eastern,” “Islamic,” “authoritarian” states) within which Egypt is usually framed. The book's central arguments are also summarized and their applications to current events are discussed. (pages 224 - 236)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...