Cloth: 978-0-226-04117-9 | Paper: 978-0-226-04118-6 | Electronic: 978-0-226-04105-6
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOK
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Introduction - Michal M. McCall, Howard S. Becker
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0002
[symbolic interaction, cultural studies, religion, arts, science, sociology, discourse analysis, life histories, feminist ethic, social organization]
The chapters in this volume deal with symbolic interaction and cultural studies. Most of the chapters tell symbolic interactionists, in one way or another, what their colleagues in related areas are up to. One paper, for instance, describes a body of work on religion which other interactionists should see as crucially related to the problems of identity and personal change they study in other milieus. Other chapters describe the symbolic interactionist tradition of research on the arts and in science studies, bring news from other areas of sociology, and speak to symbolic interactionists from the flourishing specialty of discourse analysis. The book also examines the gathering of life histories, the social nature of the human body, the feminist ethic versus the “traditional” (patriarchal) ethic of “rights” (property), the interactionist approach to social organization, social interaction, culture, and historical studies. (pages 1 - 15)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Social Interaction, Culture, and Historical Studies - John R. Hall
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0003
[social interaction, culture, historiography, sociology, cultural history, sociological explanation, historical explanation, symbolic interactionism, historical object]
Interpretive sociology, symbolic interactionism, phenomenology, hermeneutics, and ethnomethodology taken together represent the social interaction perspective. The social interaction perspective brings to the fore problems that might be sidestepped in a more objectivist framework. In order to sketch a consistent approach to cultural history, this chapter consolidates the insights of the social interaction perspective around key problems of historiography. It considers four central problems of cultural history that need to be addressed. First, definitions of culture, series, and sequence as key concepts offer an initial basis for specifying an interactionist model of cultural history. Second, there is a need to clarify the nature of the historical object (sometimes called the “historical individual”) and how it is constituted in historical analysis. Finally, the chapter examines the nature both of sociological explanation and of historical explanation, and the roles they might play in the study of cultural history. The chapter thus uses the social interaction perspective as a tool for clarifying analysis of culture, as well as the boundaries and working relationships between history and sociology. (pages 16 - 45)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
The Good News about Life History - Michal M. McCall, Judith Wittner
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0004
[life histories, life history research, symbolic interaction, postmodernism, meaning, storytelling, positivism]
Life history research is enjoying a revival. Life histories interest scholars engaged in “post-positivist cultural studies” because of their commitment to “lived experience” and to “developing insights and deepening understanding of the complexities and constructedness of culture through participation in forms of life where observer and observed become interlocutors.” Because they are stories, life histories also interest narrative theorists and those social scientists who are using the insights of narrative theorists to create post-positivist methodologies and epistemologies. At one level, the renewed interest in life history research is a product of scholarship that conceptualizes knowledge as inherently ideological. At another level, the renewed interest in life history research represents a loss of faith in positivism. This chapter discusses the relationship between life history research and symbolic interaction, postmodernism and symbolic interaction, storytelling, and some of the questions feminist, radical, critical, and experimental life historians are asking (for example, questions about meaning) as well as some of the answers symbolic interactionists can and do give. (pages 46 - 89)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Studying Religion in the Eighties - Mary Jo Neitz
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0005
[religion, symbolic interaction, cultural studies, sociology, meaning, conversion, power, movements]
In attempting to understand recent changes in religious phenomena, sociology of religion has adopted approaches that bring it very close to the traditional concerns of symbolic interactionists. This chapter argues that symbolic interaction is well suited to helping us understand the fluid relationships that today often obtain between religions and social structures and between religions and cultural change, as well as the personal transformations experienced by individuals moving between religious systems of meaning. It shows how recent research in the sociology of religion is using approaches similar to those traditionally used by symbolic interactionists. The new research looks at how meanings are socially constructed through interaction: it sees conversion as a process, power as a product of negotiation, and movements as fluid. The chapter also explores the impact of cultural studies. (pages 90 - 118)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Why Philosophers Should Become Sociologists (and Vice Versa) - Kathiyn Pyne Addelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0006
[philosophy, sociology, enlightenment, morality, narrative, ethics]
Today, philosophy and sociology are in a ferment of new concepts and theories, new methods, even newly opened fields of research. The ferment is the consequence of many historical changes, but intellectually, within the disciplines, it owes a great deal to the collapse of what has been dubbed “the enlightenment orientation.” Under the enlightenment orientation, objective knowledge is the goal of sociology and philosophy — one world, one truth, a unity of science and a unity of morality for all mankind. After taking a look at the state of philosophy today, this chapter makes links between philosophy and sociology. It draws its cases from ethics and the study of morality, in part because morality is central to sociological work. Because the chapter is seriously recommending that philosophers become sociologists (and vice versa), it describes some of the new work on narrative to make links between philosophy and sociology. (pages 119 - 147)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Art Worlds: Developing the Interactionist Approach to Social Organization - Samuel Gilmore
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0007
[symbolic interaction, arts, social organization, art world, production, distribution, consumption, culture]
Writing about symbolic interaction and the arts, one becomes immersed in issues of social organization. The development of an interactionist approach to social structure has greatly benefited from research in the arts, particularly the effort to construct a macro-level interactionist conception of society. An emphasis on an integrated micro-macro analysis is the distinguishing feature of the interactionist approach to social organization. Social worlds are useful as an interactionist unit of social organization because of the dual emphasis on structural and cultural elements. This dual emphasis is illustrated by artistic participants' group construct of an “art world.” This chapter reviews studies in the arts, clustered into production, distribution, and consumption stages, that are of interest to interactionists if not actually done by interactionist researchers. It treats these stages as a technical separation of activities, often not so clearly differentiated socially. It prefers to define the “production” of culture in a generic sense, applicable to all three technical stages including “processes of creation, manufacture, marketing, distribution, exhibiting, inculcation, evaluation, and consumption.” (pages 148 - 178)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Symbolic Interactionism in Social Studies of Science - Adele E. Clarke, Elihu M. Gerson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0008
[science, sociology, symbolic interactionism, scientific work organization, science studies]
Before the 1930s, questions about the nature of science were usually linked to the development of the sociology of knowledge and to philosophical debates. Many philosophical perspectives were used to frame and argue about the social nature of the sciences, and echoes of these debates can still be heard. The pragmatist philosophers who laid the basis for symbolic interactionism were particularly interested in the nature of scientific inquiry, methodologies, and approaches. However, these concerns were largely ignored in the interactionist sociological tradition. Over the past decade, both the sociology of science and the interdisciplinary field of science studies have grown rapidly. Scholars from many traditions have entered the fray. This chapter provides an overview of recent symbolic interactionist and related contributions focused largely on scientific work organization. It also draws attention to efforts of historians and philosophers in ways traditional to science studies. (pages 179 - 214)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Fit for Postmodern Selfhood - Barry Glassner
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0009
[fitness, selfhood, symbolic interaction, modernity, postmodernity, health]
A widespread interest in the pursuit of fitness has been documented among the middle and upper classes in national surveys and in the market success of magazines such as American Health, New Body, Prevention, and Self. Yet the popular explanations for this interest prove rather anemic. Those who market fitness programs and products, for instance, along with commentators in the media, often put forward a biosocial realist account. They maintain that Americans are merely accepting the well-confirmed scientific evidence for the adaptive and aesthetic superiority of a strong, fat-free body. In actuality, reviews of the research literature raise serious doubts as to whether exercise, weight control, or changes in diet do improve longevity or afford significant protection against disease and psychological distress. Although some fitness enthusiasts distinguish between “fitness” and “health,” the two have become generally synonymous in everyday usage. This chapter discusses fitness, selfhood, postmodernity, and the link between symbolic interaction and modernity. (pages 215 - 243)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
People Are Talking: Conversation Analysis and Symbolic Interaction - Deirdre Boden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041056.003.0015
[conversation analysis, symbolic interaction, language, meaning, language-in-action, storytelling, history, talk]
When people come together, they talk. Not always, nor everywhere, but most of the time that is what they do. They talk in bed, on the phone, in the classroom, in the judge's chambers, in the physician's office, in jury deliberations and counseling sessions, on tea breaks and on airplanes, around the dinner table and across the boardroom, in crisis and in comfort. Talk is the stuff, the very sinew, of social interaction. The mundane or momentous talk of people in their everyday world is what conversation analysis studies. One way of characterizing talk is as language-in-action, and it is here, as thought becomes action through language, that conversation analysis meets symbolic interaction (and vice versa). Symbolic interactionists have long been concerned with language, thought, meaning, shared symbols, and social acts. This chapter examines conversation analysis and symbolic interaction, language and meaning, language-in-action, storytelling, and history as talk. (pages 244 - 274)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Contributors
Index