The Birth of Territory
by Stuart Elden
University of Chicago Press, 2013
Cloth: 978-0-226-20256-3 | Paper: 978-0-226-20257-0 | Electronic: 978-0-226-04128-5
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

Territory is one of the central political concepts of the modern world and, indeed, functions as the primary way the world is divided and controlled politically. Yet territory has not received the critical attention afforded to other crucial concepts such as sovereignty, rights, and justice. While territory continues to matter politically, and territorial disputes and arrangements are studied in detail, the concept of territory itself is often neglected today. Where did the idea of exclusive ownership of a portion of the earth’s surface come from, and what kinds of complexities are hidden behind that seemingly straightforward definition?
           
The Birth of Territory provides a detailed account of the emergence of territory within Western political thought. Looking at ancient, medieval, Renaissance, and early modern thought, Stuart Elden examines the evolution of the concept of territory from ancient Greece to the seventeenth century to determine how we arrived at our contemporary understanding. Elden addresses a range of historical, political, and literary texts and practices, as well as a number of key players—historians, poets, philosophers, theologians, and secular political theorists—and in doing so sheds new light on the way the world came to be ordered and how the earth’s surface is divided, controlled, and administered.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Stuart Elden is professor of political theory and geography at the University of Warwick. He is the author of four books, including, most recently, Terror and Territory: The Spatial Extent of Sovereignty.

REVIEWS

“Elden’s analysis of territory is based on a close reading of a range of writings from key scholars and thinkers, as well as poets, playwrights, and religious writers where we find Shakespeare and Beowulf resting alongside Aristotle and Plato. Starting with Greek mythology and ranging through the middle ages and renaissance periods through to the early modern era, Elden draws on original writings, translations of works, and commentaries on those works. In doing so, he appears to have read just about everything! . . . This is a work of history, political science, law, and philosophy as well as a work of geography. In telling the story of territory, Elden also touches usefully on a range of other issues such as the periodization of history and the retrospective application of terms such as ‘middle ages’ and ‘renaissance.’. . . The breadth of sources and the range of ideas mean that Elden is, in many respects, following on in a similar vein to many of the writers whose work he deals with here.”
— David Storey, University of Worcester, Journal of Historical Geography

“Stuart Elden discusses, both copiously and elegantly, writings from Homer to Rousseau bearing witness to how place and power can be understood. From the Iliad to the Social Contract, territory, he concludes, is best defined in terms of political technology, the latter a lens through which the term resembles a mosaic of modes of measure and control. . . . The stunning virtue of The Birth of Territory is found in its sweep and intellectual panache.”
— Tom Conley, Harvard University, Imago Mundi

“A masterful and useful book.”
— Gerry Kearns, Society and Space

“Stuart Elden has written a pathbreaking book on a foundational concept in modern political and geographical thought. Drawing together deep philosophical knowledge, historical understanding, and philological expertise, Elden’s pioneering investigation compels us fundamentally to rethink some of the basic assumptions regarding state space that have long underpinned modern political theory and social research. In so doing, Elden also opens up new horizons for understanding the transformed geographies of political life that are being produced under early twenty-first century conditions. A brilliant, provocative intervention.”—Neil Brenner, Harvard University
— Neil Brenner, Harvard University

“This is a brilliant intellectual exegesis of the concept of territory that will be of wide interest in a range of academic fields, from international relations to historical sociology and the history of political thought.”
— John Agnew, University of California, Los Angeles

“Stuart Elden’s The Birth of Territory is a wonderful achievement unmatched in previous writing on place, power, and politics. For it does nothing less than elucidate in remarkable detail a two-thousand-year history of the conditions for the very possibility of its own subject—the idea of territory itself. That is what makes it transcendental history of the first order.”

— David N. Livingstone, Queen’s University Belfast

“Elden is to be commended for his keen analysis that tackles rather complex issues of meaning and translation while remaining eminently readable.”
— Geographical Review

“Elden deserves every accolade he receives for a remarkable book.  That phrase might suffice for a review, but it would hide the erudition that sets his book apart. . . . This powerful book is about words used as a political technology of power.  In the discipline of geoscience itself, it is as much about the work of labels in cartography as about that of figures in political theory. . . . In addition to all the compelling analyses, Elden’s work teaches us a lesson that even now we are at a watershed of  needing a new vocabulary to address the fluid and liquid and transient movement of politics, administration, economics, and war.”
— Theory, Culture & Society

“The Birth of Territory is an outstanding scholarly achievement . . . a book that already promises to become a ‘classic’ in geography, together with very few others published in the past decades. But Elden’s book is also a difficult one to position within mainstream human geography. Its genealogical engagement with multiple sources/texts in various historical and linguistic contexts is far reaching, and it has very few precedents in the discipline.”
— Political Geography

“Elden’s The Birth of Territory, like his other works, is an impressive feat of erudition.”
— American Historical Review

TABLE OF CONTENTS

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0001
[Jean-Jacques Rousseau, land, terrain, territory, conceptual history, Begriffsgeschichte, Quentin Skinner, Michel Foucault, Genealogy, political technology]
This introductory chapter first discusses why territory matters today, and then provides some conceptual clarity. It suggests that work on a related but distinct term of territoriality, in either the biological or the social uses of this term, are not particularly profitable ways to approach the historically more specific category of ‘territory’. Instead, ideas of ‘land’ and ‘terrain’ are examined, suggesting that these political-economic and political-strategic relations are essential to understanding ‘territory’, yet ultimately insufficient. Territory needs to be understood in terms of its relation to space, a calculative category that is dependent on the existence of a range of techniques and legal practices. Territory can be thought as a political technology. The chapter also discusses the relation between the word, concept and practice of territory, and outlines the methodological concerns of the inquiry in relation to genealogy, conceptual history and the history of political thought. (pages 1 - 18)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0002
[Ancient Greece, Plato, Aristotle, polis, khora, Antigone, community, Kleisthenes, autochthony, Greek tragedy]
This chapter analyses the Ancient Greek relation between place and power in a number of texts. It begins with Greek myths of autochthony, the idea that founders of cities were born from the very soil they are situated upon. It provides readings of a range of historians and poets, including Homer, Euripides and Aeschylus, but particularly concentrates on what Sophocles’ Antigone can tell us about the relation between place and the polis. The chapter then moves to a detailed discussion of Kleisthenes’ urban reforms of Athens, and readings of Plato’s Laws and Aristotle’s Politics for their determination of political rule and its geographical basis. While Plato was concerned with outlining a design for the polis, Aristotle’s intent was much more to catalogue its manifestations and to derive some more general rules. The chapter concludes with a discussion of how we should understand the polis as simultaneously a site and a community, in the Greek sense of a koinon, a place and the people who inhabit it. (pages 21 - 52)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0003
[Roman Republic, Roman Empire, Julius Caesar, Cicero, Tacitus, imperium, limes, Augustus, Corpus Agrimensorum Romanorum, territorium]
This chapter discusses Ancient Rome. It provides detailed readings of the writings of Julius Caesar and Cicero; the former treating the question of terrain and the military-geography terms he uses, and the latter the res publica. These are followed by a discussion of the Latin historians, with a specific focus on Tacitus. The chapter then proceeds with substantial analyses of two key terms: imperium and limes - boundaries or frontiers. It shows how the question of how we should translate territorium is not straight-forward: it means lands surrounding a place, usually a city. The lands so described are outside the city walls, predominantly agricultural lands. Yet on the other hand, the Romans had plenty of ways to describe lands belonging to people or towns: terra, ager, or the area within fines, boundaries. The discussion of the limes, the edges or limits of the empire, raises the question of how Rome saw the rest of the world. The chapter discusses the civil war, practices of land reform, the founding myth of Rome, the names of Octavian/Augustus, and ends with a discussion of practices of land surveying that are outlined in the Corpus Agrimensorum Romanorum and of the later historian Ammianus Marcellinus. (pages 53 - 96)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0004
[Middle Ages, Roman Empire, Saint Augustine, Boethius, Isidore of Seville, Gregory of Tours, Beowulf]
This chapter discusses the early Middle Ages. It begins with a reading of Saint Augustine’s two cities, and reads him, along with Jerome and Paulus Orosius, in the context of the barbarian invasions. It moves to an analysis of the work of Boethius and Isidore of Seville and their attempts to preserve the classical heritage. The political context of the time is the fracturing of the West following the collapse of the Roman Empire. Yet this time is unfairly characterised as the ‘dark ages’. Christianity was in the ascendant, and there was a flowering of national histories of various Germanic tribes including Gregory of Tours on the Franks; Bede on the English; Isidore on the Goths; and Saxo Grammaticus on the Danes. These texts are not merely accounts of these people, but actively shape their sense of identity and consequent political practice. The chapter also provides an analysis of the land politics inherent in the Beowulf poem, both in terms of the economics of exchange, gifting and inheritance, but also a more ’geopolitical’ sense of conflict over land. (pages 99 - 128)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0005
[Donation of Constantine, Lorenzo Valla, Charlemagne, Holy Roman Empire, cartography, feudalism]
This chapter looks at the establishment of the Carolingian Empire. It begins with a discussion of the Donation of Constantine: which claimed to be a text from the fourth century, was forged in the late eighth century, and finally exposed as such in the fifteenth century by Nicholas of Cusa and Lorenzo Valla. The chapter then moves to a discussion of the crowning of Charlemagne, and the practices of political ritual and naming that accompanied it. A range of works are analysed to show what precisely was being established: a new Roman Empire, a political form of Christendom, or more simply a Frankish kingdom. The position of Europe, particularly in relation to the rise of Islam, is discussed. The chapter moves to a discussion of cartography from Rome to the Medieval period. Cartography is a key political practice that both represents and produces political space. Jerusalem is often centrally located on maps of this time, providing a context in which to understand the crusades undertaken to recapture it. The chapter ends with a discussion of feudalism, stressing the political-economic importance of property in land and practices that went alongside it. (pages 129 - 156)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0006
[two swords, John of Salisbury, body politic, temporal power, spiritual power, Aristotle, Aquinas, Ptolemy of Lucca, political writings]
This chapter looks at the later Middle Ages. It provides a reading of the organic idea of the body politic in the work of John of Salisbury. It examines the idea of the ‘two swords’, where the Pope claimed both temporal power—over the span of human life on the earth—and spiritual power—over sin, salvation and their eternal souls. The Pope laid claim to supremacy in the latter by right, and appointed or anointed secular rulers such as Kings or Emperors to act on his behalf in the former. However, this split, originally proposed by papal theorists, began to articulate a scope and purpose of a separate kind of power, which secular rulers and theorists began to develop. The chapter also discusses in detail the rediscovery of Aristotle’s political writings and their translation into Latin, initially through the Arabic. Translation is not simply a textual question, but one of practice, because the availability of these texts changed both the language and the substance of political thought. In this chapter there is a particular focus on the work of Thomas Aquinas and Ptolemy of Lucca, and in particular their guidance on how to act politically. (pages 157 - 179)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0007
[Boniface VIII, Philip the Fair, Giles of Rome, John of Paris, Dante, Marsilius of Padua, William of Ockham, poverty, temporal power, spiritual power]
This chapter looks at challenges to the power of the Papacy in the late Middle Ages. It begins with a discussion of the dispute between Pope Boniface VIII and King Philip the Fair of France. This was concerned with whether the King could tax clergy within his kingdom, and who had jurisdiction if they committed a crime. The dispute was also directly productive of some extremely important political theory, notably the writings of Giles of Rome and John of Paris. These took opposing views over the respective competencies of the spiritual and temporal rulers. The chapter then moves to detailed readings of three theorists of temporal power: Dante, Marsilius of Padua and William of Ockham. Dante, better known as the poet of the Commedia, was author of the important Monarchia which argued for a resurgent empire free from papal control. Marsilius offered a defence of the smaller political unit of the city. Ockham, who became a political theorist late in life, was an advocate of the Franciscan vow of poverty, and believed that the church should be poor. Yet this was not simply a view about property, but a view that the church should absent itself from all worldly concerns. (pages 180 - 210)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0008
[Justinian, Roman law, glossators, territorium, Bartolus of Sassoferrato, Baldus de Ubaldis, river boundaries, Holy Roman Empire, Francisco de Vitoria, Hugo Grotius]
This chapter discusses the importance of Roman law, and in particular its codification under the Byzantine Emperor Justinian, to the question of territory. The main focus is on the two most important post-glossators or commentators: Bartolus of Sassoferrato and Baldus de Ubaldis. They put the law to work in fourteenth century Italian cities, and crucially made the argument that territorium and jurisdiction went together. Crucially territorium becomes not simply a property of a ruler, but the object of rule itself. These are practical arguments - Bartolus’s work on river boundary law, for instance, is a combination of legal argument and practical techniques. The final part of the chapter looks at how this work provided a missing basis for assertions of temporal power: in distinction to the universal aspirations of the papacy, temporal power was geographically determined. Within his kingdom, the king had the same power as the Emperor in the Empire. The legacy of this work is found in the reform of church law of Nicholas of Cusa and in secular legal theorists such as Francisco de Vitoria’s writing on colonisation and Hugo Grotius’s work on the law of the sea and the rights of war and peace. (pages 213 - 241)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0009
[Jean Bodin, Giovanni Botero, King Lear, Erasmus, Thomas More, King Lear, Niccolò Machiavelli, Renaissance, Reformation, Holy Roman Empire]
This chapter looks at the relation between the renaissance and the conquest and mapping of the new world in terms of their impact on the theory and practice of territory. Despite how Machiavelli is often read, and translated, he did not have a concept of territory and did not see political power as pre-eminently related to land but instead we need to make sense of his ambiguous notion of lo stato. The second part of the chapter looks at the Reformation, and in particular the political writings of Erasmus, Thomas More and Martin Luther. The establishment of polities with different confessions to Catholicism produced a political as well as religious fracturing within the Holy Roman Empire. Some of these issues are worked through in the writings of Jean Bodin and Giovanni Botero; the former known for his discussions of sovereignty and the latter for the notion of reason of state. But Bodin’s work is complicated by looking at the French and Latin versions of his writings, and Botero’s writings on the city and the world also need to be interrogated. The chapter concludes with a reading of the role of property in and struggles over land in Shakespeare’s King Lear. (pages 242 - 278)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0010
[Peace of Westphalia, Gottfried Leibniz, Andreas Knichen, Johannes Althusius, Samuel Pufendorf, Thomas Hobbes, John Locke, Robert Filmer, territory, sovereignty]
This chapter begins with a detailed discussion of some unjustly neglected thinkers of the early seventeenth century whose work was integral to thinking through the political and geographical legacy of the Reformation. These include Richard Hooker, Andreas Knichen, and Johannes Althusius. The next part of the chapter offers a reading of the political and geographical implications of the scientific revolution, with special focus on Descartes, Spinoza and the Newton/Leibniz dispute. Hobbes, Filmer and Locke are then discussed in terms of the relation between politics and land (or at times territory) in their work. The colonial context is particularly crucial to understanding Locke. It suggests that Gottfried Leibniz is the most important political thinker of territory of this period. Leibniz, like Theodor Reinking, Bogislaw Philipp von Chemnitz, and Samuel Pufendorf, is trying to make sense of the fractured political geographies of the Holy Roman Empire, especially in the wake of the Peace of Westphalia. In distinguishing between the majesty of the Emperor and the territorial supremacy of the princes, Leibniz provides a strikingly modern definition. (pages 279 - 321)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Stuart Elden
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226041285.003.0011
[Jean-Jacques Rousseau, political technology, territory, the state, cartography, land surveying, statistics]
The book’s conclusion discusses state practices and techniques of cartography, surveying and statistics and looks at examples from many particular histories of states and their territories. It therefore outlines ways in which territory came to be understood and practiced as a political technology: it comprises techniques for measuring land and controlling terrain, and we must therefore think measure and control—the technical and the legal—alongside the economic and strategic. This political technology is one of the means by which we can understand the emergence and development of the modern state. (pages 322 - 330)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...