Social Security Policy in a Changing Environment
edited by Jeffrey R. Brown, Jeffrey B. Liebman and David A. Wise
University of Chicago Press, 2009
Cloth: 978-0-226-07648-5 | Electronic: 978-0-226-07650-8
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

Social Security Policy in a Changing Environment analyzes the changing economic and demographic environment in which social insurance programs that benefit elderly households will operate.  It also explores how these ongoing trends will affect future beneficiaries, under both the current social security program and potential reform options.    In this volume, an esteemed group of economists probes the challenge posed to Social Security by an aging population.  The researchers examine trends in private sector retirement saving and health care costs, as well as the uncertain nature of future demographic, economic, and social trends—including marriage and divorce rates and female participation in the labor force. Recognizing the ambiguity of the environment in which the Social Security system must operate and evolve, this landmark book explores factors that policymakers must consider in designing policies that are resilient enough to survive in an economically and demographically uncertain society.
 
 

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Jeffrey R. Brown is the William G. Karnes Professor in the Department of Finance and director of the Center for Business and Public Policy in the College of Business at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. He also serves as associate director of the NBER Retirement Research Center.

Jeffrey B. Liebman is Malcolm Wiener Professor of Public Policy at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, and a research associate of the NBER.

David A. Wise is the John F. Stambaugh Professor of Political Economy at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University, and director of the programs on aging and health care at the NBER.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Acknowledgments

- Jeffrey R. Brown, Jeffrey Liebman, David A. Wise
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0001
[National Bureau of Economic Research, NBER, funding, Social Security, savings, financial burden]
This book compiles selected studies conducted through the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) Center for Retirement Research. This center was created in 2003 with funding from the U.S. Social Security Administration and is structured to provide analysis that can inform Social Security policy. While some of the center's research focuses directly on Social Security reform, other research aims to inform Social Security policy by analyzing the changing economic environment in which future Social Security beneficiaries will live. An empirical evidence on how the default provisions of retirement saving plans impact savings behavior along multiple dimensions has been obtained. The financial footing of the Social Security system depends importantly on the longevity of program participants. In the past few decades, longevity in the United States has increased substantially, adding to the financial burden on the Social Security program. (pages 1 - 18)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

I. Innovative Approaches to Social Security Reform

- Gopi Shah Goda, John B. Shoven, Sita Nataraj Slavov
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0002
[Social Security, labor market, good fortunes, labor force, tax rates, workforce]
The U.S. labor market has proved to be very flexible in absorbing new workers as evidenced by its ability to accommodate large numbers of workers as women entered the labor force in the past few decades, and the economy has benefited greatly as a result of the larger workforce. There are a number of features of Social Security that distort incentives toward increased retirement length by imposing high implicit tax rates on longer careers and working at older ages. By eliminating the disincentives against working longer careers, the good fortunes of increasing life expectancy and favorable health status can be capitalized on the good fortunes by paving the way for more capable individuals to stay in the labor force. (pages 21 - 38)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Alan J. Auerbach, Ronald Lee
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0003
[pay-as-you-go, PAYGO, pension, Lee-Carter mortality model, stochastic simulation, system design]
This chapter explores a new approach to Social Security reform that is known as “Notional Defined Contribution” or “Nonfinancial Defined Contribution” (NDC). This chapter uses a stochastic macroeconomic model for forecasting and simulating the long-term finances of NDC-type public pension programs in the context of demographic and economic trends in the United States. While NDC plans are seen as having various potential advantages over traditional pay-as-you-go (PAYGO) systems, the focus of this chapter is on their financial stability over the long term. Around the world, PAYGO public pension programs are facing serious long-term fiscal problems due primarily to actual and projected population aging and most appear unsustainable as currently structured. The stochastic population model is based on a Lee-Carter mortality model and a somewhat similar fertility model. The feasible internal rate of return for a PAYGO system with stable population structure equals the rate of growth of the population plus the rate of growth of output per worker. Evidently, stochastic simulation of the system's finances can reveal aspects of its performance that are not otherwise obvious and can assist in improving system design. This promises to be a valuable use for stochastic simulation models of pension systems. (pages 43 - 68)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- John Geanakoplos, Stephen P. Zeldes
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0004
[defined benefit, DB, defined contribution, DC, Social Security, transition cost, personal account]
This chapter develops yet another approach to Social Security reform. This reform plan is designed to preserve the core objectives of the current Social Security system and, at the same time, gain the benefits of personal accounts. In recent years, the United States has been engaged in a heated debate about whether to replace part of the current, defined benefit (DB) Social Security system with a system of defined contribution (DC) personal accounts. In the current system, the benefits received by Social Security contributors are based on a concave function of lifetime earnings, providing smaller increments in benefits with each additional dollar of lifetime earnings. The importance of making the Social Security system self-balancing by incorporating a market-based aggregate self-correction mechanism is emphasized. The resulting estimates of the “maximum transition cost” measure of system obligations are significantly lower than those of the Social Security Administration, due to the incorporation of market risk into the discounting of future benefits. This chapter demonstrates that it is possible to convert Social Security into a system of personal accounts with irrevocable ownership of market priced assets, while at the same time redistributing benefits based on lifetime income and sharing macroeconomic gains across generations. (pages 73 - 121)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

II. Retirement Plan Choice

- Jeffrey R. Brown, Scott J. Weisbenner
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0005
[defined contribution, DC, personal retirement account, PRA, SURS, contribution plan]
This chapter analyzes the decisions made by a group of 50,000 workers who currently have a choice between a defined benefit (DB) and a defined contribution (DC) pension system. This study is based on the experience of employees in the State Universities Retirement System (SURS) of Illinois, where workers make a one-time, lifetime, irrevocable choice among three retirement plans: a traditional formula-based DB plan; a “portable DB plan,” which is slightly less generous than the traditional DB program if one retires from the system, but more generous if the worker takes an early lump-sum distribution; and a completely self-managed DC plan. Individuals who fail to make an active choice within the first six months of employment are automatically defaulted into the traditional DB plan. In recent years, numerous proposals have been forwarded to fully or partially replace the defined benefits provided by the U.S. Social Security system with personal retirement accounts (PRAs). The SURS system looms large as part of a participant's lifetime financial plan. (pages 131 - 161)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- John Beshears, James J. Choi, David Laibson, Brigitte C. Madrian
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0006
[savings, asset allocation, defaults, public policy, saving plans]
This chapter demonstrates the tremendous influence that defaults exert on realized savings outcomes at every stage of the savings life cycle, such as savings plan participation, contributions, asset allocation, rollovers, and decumulation. In a defined contribution savings environment, savings plans—whether they are employer-sponsored, government-sponsored, or privately sponsored—are only a useful tool to the extent that employees actually participate. Defaults can so easily sway such a significant economic outcome has important implications for understanding the psychology of economic decision making. But it also has important implications for the role of public policy toward saving. Defaults are not neutral—they can either facilitate or hinder better savings outcomes. Current public policies toward saving include examples of both. (pages 167 - 195)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

III. Reducing Financial Market Risk in Personal Retirement Accounts

- Martin Feldstein
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0007
[personal retirement plan, PRA, Social Security, simulations, risk reduction]
This chapter presents a new market-based approach to reducing the risk of investment-based Social Security that could be tailored to individual risk preferences. With this new form of risk reduction, substituting an investment-based personal retirement account (PRA) for the traditional pure PAYGO plan could achieve both a significantly higher expected retirement income and a very high probability that the investment-based annuity would be at least as large as the PAYGO benefit. Simulations are used to derive the probability distributions of retirement incomes relative to the “benchmark” benefits specified in current law. The calculations of the expected utility imply that these risk reduction techniques can raise the expected utility relative to plans with no guarantee. The ability to do so depends on the individual's risk aversion level. (pages 201 - 218)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Andrew Biggs, Clark Burdick, Kent Smetters
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0008
[benefit guarantees, cost, personal accounts, account holders, risk neutral guarantee]
This chapter demonstrates how a model for calculating the expected cost of a benefit guarantee can easily be modified to present the market price of personal account guarantees as a supplement to expected cost valuations. Personal accounts invested in equities will tend to increase average retirement benefits for workers choosing to participate. In proposals that allow for portfolio choice, it could be expected that inclusion of a benefit guarantee would alter the average portfolio allocation of account holders. Once an appropriate model is constructed to calculate the expected cost of a guarantee, a change of a single parameter of that model enables the analyst to calculate the risk neutral guarantee cost as well. From a practical perspective, the risk neutral guarantee costs allows for greater information to be provided to policymakers with relatively little additional research cost. (pages 229 - 249)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- James M. Poterba, Joshua Rauh, Steven F. Venti, David A. Wise
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0009
[Social Security, PRA, personal retirement account, retirement, No Lose allocation strategy]
This chapter explores the implications for asset accumulation of different investment strategies. In a Social Security system with a personal retirement account (PRA) component, retirement savers would have to decide how to allocate their PRA portfolios across a broad range of asset classes and financial products. Asset allocation decisions have important consequences for retirement wealth accumulation because they affect the expenses of investing as well as the risk of low returns. The goal of this study is to assess the relative risk associated with alternative asset allocation strategies in PRAs, though it also offers insight on the consequences of different asset allocation rules in 401(k)-type plans. (pages 255 - 292)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Andrew A. Samwick
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0010
[risk, progressivity, Social Security, PRA, cost, earnings]
This chapter illustrates the link between progressivity and risk using a stylized framework based on simulations of earnings trajectories and portfolio returns. The model used in the analysis focuses on a cohort of workers who should expect to have their traditional benefits reduced at some point when the Social Security system is restored to solvency. Direct restrictions on equity holding in PRAs are likely to prove unpopular, particularly among those whose opportunities are most broadened by the chance to invest their mandatory contributions in equities. Extending the current framework to allow for optimal, age-dependent portfolio allocations and for saving in accounts other than the PRAs would provide better estimates of the extent to which greater progressivity can protect low earners from investment risk and of the size of the welfare costs paid by higher earners for providing this protection. (pages 299 - 327)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

IV. Demographics, Asset Flows, and Macroeconomic Markets

- James M. Poterba, Steven F. Venti, David A. Wise
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0011
[defined benefit, DB, assets, retirement saving plans, 401(k) plans]
This chapter examines the effect of population aging on the demand for financial assets in retirement saving plans, particularly defined benefit (DB) plans, in the United States. Focusing on DB assets alone suggests that an aging population, in conjunction with a shift away from DB plans, will lead to a decline in the real value of pension assets averaged across all retirees in future cohorts. The findings underscore the need for further analysis of the factors that determine the diffusion of 401(k) plans across corporations, especially small companies with low-wage workers, as well as the contribution behavior and withdrawal behavior of 401(k) participants. The growing role of 401(k)-type plans in the retirement landscape suggests that understanding asset accumulation and draw-down in these plans is a critical component of any analysis of the effect of demographic change on financial markets. (pages 333 - 379)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Alexander Ludwig, Dirk Krüger, Axel Börsch-Supan
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0012
[Social Security, factor prices, capital, wages, retirement age, newborns]
This chapter evaluates the welfare consequences of the demographic transition per se and not just the alternative Social Security reform scenarios, as well as in the analysis of the distributional consequences of changing factor prices due to population aging. It is reported that that the rate of return to capital can be expected to decrease by about 80–90 basis points until 2050, with a corresponding increase of wages if PAYGO Social Security systems are reformed such that contribution rates are held constant. It is also shown that increasing the mandatory retirement age by five years is shown to mitigate substantially these losses and to significantly increase the welfare gains of newborns. The welfare gains for newborns are actually larger than what is computed because in addition, these newborns are expected to live longer than the current generation. (pages 385 - 414)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

V. Mortality Projections

- David M. Cutler, Edward L. Glaeser, Allison B. Rosen
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226076508.003.0013
[health, performance systems, medication, medical risk, pay-for-performance systems]
This chapter compares the risk factor profile of the population in the early 1970s with that of the population in the early 2000s and considers the implications of recent trends for future reductions in mortality. Understanding changes in population health is a key input into public and private decision making. People who live longer have more years of life to enjoy, but also need to prepare for more older years, through increased saving and possibly delayed retirement. Reduced smoking, better control of medical risk factors such as hypertension and cholesterol, and better education among the older population have been more important for mortality than the substantial increase in obesity. The idea behind pay-for-performance systems is to reward physicians (or insurance companies) for successful efforts to increase utilization and possibly adherence. Such efforts might involve having nurse outreach, automatic medication refills, or more convenient office hours to monitor side effects. Patients can receive electronic reminders about medication goals, information, and automated decision tools can help with dosing and medication switches. (pages 423 - 442)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Contributors

Author Index

Subject Index