Seeing the Light The Social Logic of Personal Discovery
by Thomas DeGloma
University of Chicago Press, 2014
Cloth: 978-0-226-17574-4 | Paper: 978-0-226-17588-1 | Electronic: 978-0-226-17591-1
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The chorus of the Christian hymn “Amazing Grace” reads, “I once was lost, but now am found, / Was blind but now I see.” Composed by a minister who formerly worked as a slave trader, the song expresses his experience of divine intervention that ultimately caused him to see the error of his ways. This theme of personal awakening is a feature of countless stories throughout history, where the “lost” and the “blind” are saved from darkness and despair by suddenly seeing the light.
 
In Seeing the Light, Thomas DeGloma explores such accounts of personal awakening, in stories that range from the discovery of a religious truth to remembering a childhood trauma to embracing a new sexual orientation. He reveals a common social pattern: When people discover a life-changing truth, they typically ally with a new community. Individuals then use these autobiographical stories to shape their stances on highly controversial issues such as childhood abuse, war and patriotism, political ideology, human sexuality, and religion. Thus, while such stories are seemingly very personal, they also have a distinctly social nature. Tracing a wide variety of narratives through nearly three thousand years of history, Seeing the Light uncovers the common threads of such stories and reveals the crucial, little-recognized social logic of personal discovery.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Thomas DeGloma is assistant professor of sociology at Hunter College, City University of New York.

REVIEWS

“This is one of the best books I have read in a long time. Eschewing simplistic approaches, DeGloma brings a full arsenal of tools from cultural sociology, ritual theory, moral philosophy, and semiotics to develop a rich account of awakening narratives. For anyone interested in autobiographical accounts and the roles they play in social life, Seeing the Light is the book to read.” 
— Robert Wuthnow, Princeton University

“Seeing the Light is a fascinating study of a class of public stories that Thomas DeGloma calls awakening narratives—autobiographical accounts of religious conversion, political transformation, identity alteration, and the like. While some of these types have been studied in isolation, DeGloma shows how such stories, recounting a fundamental change of mind and heart and at first glance seemingly unrelated, not only share a common narrative structure but play formally similar roles in society. Lucidly written, tightly-organized, and richly illustrated, Seeing the Light is a remarkable achievement.”
— Joseph E. Davis, University of Virginia

“Individual epiphanies that awaken the self to a new world seem unique and ineffable. Yet DeGloma shows us how our narratives of awakening are patterned and generic as we recount them in autobiographical communities. Seeing the Light sheds its own masterful light on autobiography and autobiographical narrative. Anyone interested in the dynamic nature of the relation of self and society should read this book.”
— Robin Wagner-Pacifici, The New School for Social Research

"Stories of personal transformation are all around us. Seeing the Light excavates the timeless logic of their deep meaning structures. At the same time DeGloma shows them to be socially grounded in specific communities of interpretation, solidarity and contention. As such this important book suggests new and much needed paths for connecting cultural sociology to the study of the self."
— Philip Smith, Yale University

"More and more people want to know about stories and narratives. In this elegant book, Thomas DeGloma inspects one major and widespread genre: the awareness story. Drawing on a rich vein of writing, he inspects its foundations, forms and formulas suggesting its deep logic and defining characteristics. All future scholars of the diverse array of awareness stories will have to take this book as a benchmark."
— Ken Plummer, University of Essex

“Seeing the Light is well written and makes a compelling case for sociologists with a wide range of interests to pay attention to awakening narratives and autobiographical work more generally. For scholars already working in the areas of narrative identity and narrative analysis, the book contributes a careful analysis of awakening narratives and the awakening story formula as particular (and particularly important) types of narratives. More broadly, the particular types of awakening narratives and autobiographical communities discussed throughout the book provide relevant insights for the study of religion, trauma and mental health, sexuality, political ideology, social movements, and more.”
— American Journal of Sociology

TABLE OF CONTENTS

List of Illustrations

Acknowledgments

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0001
[autobiographical work, formal sociology, story formula, social type, autobiographical community, autobiographical field, social pattern analysis, cultural codes, emotion codes]
This chapter opens by calling attention to the social prevalence and cultural significance of awakening narratives. It frames the sociological approach to awakenings by outlining three dimensions of autobiographical work -- the self-reflexive, the dialogical, and the performative. Introducing a formal, cultural and cognitive approach to narrative analysis, this chapter discusses the awakening story formula, the semiotic structure of awakening narratives, and the awakener as a social type of storyteller. More, this chapter outlines a theory of autobiographical communities and autobiographical fields, showing how individuals who tell awakening stories embrace the cognitive norms of one community while rejecting those of others, thereby establishing a standpoint in a complex cultural arena. This chapter then describes how combining the methods of social pattern analysis and structural hermeneutics illuminates the way individuals express sociomental norms and draw on powerful cultural and emotion codes when telling stories about discovering "truth." Whatever their particular concern, be it psychological, political, sexual, scientific, or otherwise, such individuals use their life stories to articulate moral and political tensions in the world. (pages 1 - 33)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Three Dimensions of Autobiographical Work

The Awakening-Story Formula

The Semiotic Structure of Awakening Stories

The Awakener as a Social Type of Storyteller

Autobiographical Communities and Autobiographical Fields

Methods and Data

Outline of the Book

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0002
[Axial Age, Zarathustra, allegory of the cave, Siddhārtha Gautama, Paul the Apostle, the Enlightenment, false consciousness, psychoanalysis, new age, new social movements]
When individuals tell awakening stories, they weigh in on cultural disputes over truth and meaning that emerged during various historical eras and evolved through time. This chapter sketches a cultural history of the awakening narrative formula, showing how awakening narratives proliferated over time with the rise of various discursive communities. It discusses several cases that span different contexts, belief systems, and historical periods -- from the Axial Age to the late modern era -- in order to show how awakening stories emerged in various historical eras to mark the prominent cultural and moral tensions of those eras. These cases variously express philosophical, religious, political, scientific, psychological, and sexual worldviews and span different levels of analysis. These include the story of Zarathustra, Plato’s allegory of the cave, the Buddhist story of Siddh?rtha Gautama, the Christian story of Paul the Apostle, the Western Enlightenment narrative, the Marxist account of false and class consciousness, and Freud’s theory of psychoanalysis. Finally, this chapter discusses the proliferation of awakening stories that accompanied the rise of identity politics and new social movements, including New Age movements, in the 1970’s and 80’s. (pages 34 - 63)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Zarathustra

Plato’s Allegory of the Cave

Foundational Religious Awakenings

Foundational Political Awakenings

Freud and the Psychoanalytic Case Study

Late Modern Awakenings

Conclusion

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0003
[autobiographical memory, collective memory, mnemonic authority, mnemonic revision, future projection, memory work]
This chapter addresses the central significance of memory in the stories we tell about discovering truth and meaning. It shows how individuals use a patterned awakening formula to redefine important experiences, events, perceptions, and relationships of the past. Such mnemonic revisions imply future projections; they carry major implications for the storyteller’s future attitudes, beliefs, relationships, and actions. Bridging levels of analysis central to social memory studies, this chapter explores the ways individuals use autobiographical memory to ally themselves with an autobiographical community, assert mnemonic authority, and weigh in on cultural disputes concerning the definition of morally and politically salient issues and situations. It discusses the use autobiographical memory to shape collective memory -- to influence how others remember some socially relevant event or phenomenon. It also analyzes the use autobiographical memory to shape the cultural milieu for personal recollection -- to model how others should remember and account for particular experiences, relationships, and issues in their own lives. Centrally, this chapter argues that a cultural and cognitive sociology of autobiographical narrative offers new insights into the social dynamics of personal storytelling, collective memory, and commemoration. (pages 64 - 95)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Formulaic Mnemonic Revisions

Autobiographical Memory and Cultural Contention

Shaping the Collective Mnemonic Record

Shaping the Cultural Milieu for Personal Memory

Conclusion

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0004
[liminality, vocabulary of liminality, liminal persona, rites of passage, autobiographical time, cognitive boundaries, sociomental express elevator, sociomental staircase, emotion, embodiment]
This chapter shows how individuals who claim radical changes of mind must account for a liminal awakening experience, a transformative episode that separates their past commitment to “falsehood” from their current grasp of some “truth.” Just as such storytellers use autobiographical time to split falsehood and truth, this chapter also explores how they navigate the passage between such epistemic phases, adopting liminal personae and thereby dramatizing the moral complexities involved with crossing the cultural and cognitive boundaries that separate contentious autobiographical communities in the autobiographical field. This chapter identifies and elaborates two ideal-typical vocabularies of liminality: the sociomental express elevator and the sociomental staircase. It explores the relationship between autobiographical time, agency, authority, embodiment, emotion, and transformation in awakening narratives. Guided by the theories of Arnold Van Gennep, Victor Turner, Kenneth Burke, and Erving Goffman, this chapter shows how individuals who tell awakening stories use various dramaturgical conventions and employ props, characters, and settings to convey their sociomental discoveries and transformations. (pages 96 - 126)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Sociomental Express Elevators

Sociomental Staircases

Combining Elevators and Staircases

Conclusion

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0005
[identity, temporally dived self, self-interaction, plot, temporality, performance of self, self-character schemes, lifestyle, embodiment, emotion]
This chapter focuses on the ways individuals who tell stories about discovering truth in their lives portray and perform a conflicted, temporally divided self. It explores the ways individuals account for the otherwise contradictory dynamic between two radically different identities in their lives. Developing a narrative theory of identity that reconciles the themes of self-interaction, social context, plot and temporality, the performance of self, and a new concept of self-character schemes, this chapter considers how people who tell awakening stories mobilize depictions of lifestyle, emotionality, manner, taste, perception, value, and embodiment as they distinguish between different conceptions of the self in order to classify the world into morally and epistemologically contentious camps. If, as George Herbert Mead has argued, the self is a product of our social relationships, this chapter considers what it means for our self-concept when our past and present communities of reference are in conflict. In particular, this chapter considers the cognitive and cultural implications of such a temporally divided self. (pages 127 - 149)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Portraying the Temporally Divided Self

Conclusion

- Thomas DeGloma
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226175911.003.0006
[cultural tensions, identity, story formula, social memory, time, social epistemology, drama, speech act]
This chapter considers how individuals who tell awakening stories work to resolve cultural contradictions with their stories while simultaneously reinforcing social divisions and exacerbating cultural conflict. Bringing together several themes that were introduced in prior chapters, this chapter then proposes seven interrelated principles for a sociological -- and specifically cultural and cognitive -- approach to autobiographical narrative more generally. These include the following notions: autobiographical narrative is an expression of socially situated and relational identity; individuals commonly draw on historically durable and generic story formulas to articulate stories about their lives; autobiographical narrative is a form of social memory; autobiographical narrative is a form of social time; autobiographical narrative is a form of social knowledge and ought to be a subject matter of a social epistemology; autobiographical narrative is a form of social drama; and autobiographical narratives are speech acts that are directed at multiple audiences. This chapter argues that these seven interrelated principles are central to understanding the link between autobiographical narrative and the broader social and cultural forces that impact our lives. (pages 150 - 157)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Notes

References

Index