The Power to Die Slavery and Suicide in British North America
by Terri L. Snyder
University of Chicago Press, 2015
Cloth: 978-0-226-28056-1 | Paper: 978-0-226-85457-1 | Electronic: 978-0-226-28073-8
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The history of slavery in early America is a history of suicide. On ships crossing the Atlantic, enslaved men and women refused to eat or leaped into the ocean. They strangled or hanged themselves. They tore open their own throats. In America, they jumped into rivers or out of windows, or even ran into burning buildings. Faced with the reality of enslavement, countless Africans chose death instead.

In The Power to Die, Terri L. Snyder excavates the history of slave suicide, returning it to its central place in early American history. How did people—traders, plantation owners, and, most importantly, enslaved men and women themselves—view and understand these deaths, and how did they affect understandings of the institution of slavery then and now? Snyder draws on ships’ logs, surgeons' journals, judicial and legislative records, newspaper accounts, abolitionist propaganda and slave narratives, and many other sources to build a grim picture of slavery’s toll and detail the ways in which suicide exposed the contradictions of slavery, serving as a powerful indictment that resonated throughout the Anglo-Atlantic world and continues to speak to historians today.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Terri L. Snyder is professor of American studies at California State University, Fullerton, and the author of Brabbling Women: Disorderly Speech and the Law in Early Virginia. She lives in Pasadena.

REVIEWS

“Snyder attends to her subject with great intelligence, care, and sensitivity. Drawing together an impressive variety of sources, she probes the connection between the public interest in slavery and the forbidden private will of the enslaved. This excellent study of mortuary politics confirms that the power to die can be as historically consequential as the power to hold, punish, and kill.”
— Vincent Brown, author of The Reaper’s Garden: Death and Power in the World of Atlantic Slavery

“In this moving and provocative work, Snyder compels us to rethink slavery and suicide and, in the process, greatly expands our comprehension of both phenomena. Snyder’s beautifully written and thoughtful study makes important and unique contributions to the histories of slavery, early America, and medicine. Snyder argues that our current understanding of suicide is profoundly shaped by twentieth century notions of illness, stress, depression, and hopelessness and offers us instead a deeply historicized exploration of suicide and slavery.”
— Jennifer L. Morgan, author of Laboring Women: Gender and Reproduction in New World Slavery

“The Power to Die is an important, innovative, and exceedingly well-researched book. Snyder has done some breathtaking archival work and the sheer variety of sources is astounding— drawing on newspapers, antislavery propaganda, ship log books, plantation diaries, account books, and slave narratives, to name a few. This book will be of great interest to many different scholars, including those who work on slavery and early America, but also those eager to know more about law, gender, technology, and early American print culture.”
— Hilary J. Moss, author of Schooling Citizens: The African American Struggle for Education in Antebellum America

“The Power to Die is the first book-length study of the subject of slave suicide. Drawing upon a robust and diverse body of sources, Snyder powerfully argues that it exposed significant rifts and tensions in early modern American society. Ambitious in scope and original in framing, her analysis is careful, trenchant, and insightful. Snyder’s ingenious analysis exposes the ways in which slave suicide reflected the duality of slaves as both people and property.”
— David Silkenat, author of Moments of Despair: Suicide, Divorce, and Debt in Civil War Era North Carolina

“Snyder’s well-written exploration of the cultural and legal meanings of slave suicide in British North America offers a unique examination of an individual act with political, religious, legal, and cultural ramifications. From addressing the estimated 5 to 10 percent of slaves who committed suicide during the infamous Middle Passage to interpreting slave suicide as an act of desperation and part of the growing abolitionist message in the nineteenth century, Snyder uses a wide variety of sources to understand her subject. . . . A far-reaching, compelling, and relevant monograph. Highly recommended.”
— Choice

“Often revelatory. . . . As the first monograph devoted to this important subject, The Power to Die serves a valuable, foundational role. It builds upon many shorter, less comprehensive studies; it constructs bridges between several discrete academic subfields; and it imposes its own analytic architecture on a diverse body of difficult sources to conclusively demonstrate that ‘suicide was central to the history and culture of slavery and antislavery efforts in early British America and the United States.’”
— William and Mary Quarterly

TABLE OF CONTENTS

List of Figures

Acknowledgments

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0009
[Anna, Jesse Torrey, Washington, D.C, suicide, slavery, trafficking, female slaves]
Description of the suicide attempt of Anna, an enslaved woman. Confined to an attic in the District of Columbia, she was part of a coffle of slaves destined for Georgia in 1815. She awaited transport with two of her children, but had been separated from her husband. She leapt out the window rather than endure parting with her family and enslavement in the Deep South. Her suicide awakened discord over slavery in the early United States. Hers was one of several reports of slave suicide that inspired an investigation into human trafficking in the District of Columbia. In 1817, her story was chronicled in Jesse Torrey's Portraiture of Domestic Slavery in the United States. Her suicide attempt became an immediate political example for anti-slavery activists, Anna survived to become a local legend and was sought out for interviews well into the 1830s. (pages 1 - 6)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0010
[slavery, suicide, methods, British North America]
The introduction presents the reasons for studying slavery and suicide. It analyzes the competing understandings of suicide in early British North America, contrasting European legal, religious, and social treatments of suicide with those found in surviving evidence from Africa. Introduces five perspectives from which to study slavery and suicide: these include examining 1) the circumstances that fostered slave suicide; 2) the competing interpretations of slave suicide; the legal and cultural ramifications of slave suicide; 4) the cultural and political changes wrought by slave suicide; and 5) the modern memory of slave suicide. The introduction explains the rationale for the geographical focus on British North America, examines the historiography on slavery and suicide, analyzes the concepts of agency and resistance, and explores the methodologies, particularly the problems in using numerical statistics, in studying slave suicide. (pages 7 - 22)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0001
[slavery, suicide, Middle Passage, disarticulation, ethnicity]
Acts of suicide by captive Africans were ubiquitous aboard slave ships crossing from Africa to the Americas. Mariner's observations generated a commercial, working knowledge in the trade about Africans and suicide, one that revealed as much about the enslavers as it did about their human cargoes. This chapter examines the lore accompanied slave ships across the Middle Passage. It also analyzes shipboard suicide by captive Africans from the perspectives of both slaves and enslavers. Africans and Europeans carried competing and changing ideas of good and bad deaths with them through the Middle Passage, and these concepts shaped their views of shipboard suicide. Africans' shipboard suicides reflected specific physical, emotional, and psychological experiences of captivity. African shipboard suicides also shaped the conduct of mariners. For captains, surgeons, and crew, preventing slave suicide was essential to controlling shipboard order. As mariners and traders assessed their human cargoes' propensities for self-destruction, they effectively branded slaves according to ethnicity and temperament, qualities that made them more or less saleable commodities. These descriptions underscored the idea that slave suicide was endemic to certain types of human cargoes, specific ethnicities of Africans, rather than to the system of enslavement itself. (pages 23 - 45)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0002
[seasoning, slavery, suicide, spiritual]
The threat of suicide by enslaved people was particularly acute during the initial years of enslavement, as they were discharged from ships, dispersed to plantations and cities, and confronted new world labor regimes. Planters referred to this early period of acclimation and adjustment as “seasoning.” Once on American ground, routine features of slavery -- labor regimes, anomic isolation, the renewal of separation from shipmates, multiple sales, sexual coercion, corporal punishment, and even the English criminal justice system -- also shaped enslaved peoples’ deaths by suicide. In response, some newly imported enslaved Africans achieved their deaths directly and indirectly. In addition, once in America some Africans continued to believe that death by suicide would return them to their homes, reunite them with their ancestors, or allow them to be reborn into their families. The initial months after disembarkation appear to have intensified that sentiment among enslaved people, evidence of which can be found throughout eighteenth century in British America. If not a good death, self-destruction was an avenue of escaping slavery. (pages 46 - 63)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0003
[masculine, honor, contradictions, race]
Suicide by enslaved people had the potential to expose the contradictions of slavery in colonial British North America. Those contradictions can best be comprehended first by analyzing the competing meanings acts of self-destruction and, second, by situating slave suicide in the comparative context of other accounts of self-inflicted death by early Americans. Some stories of slave suicide accentuated similarities between blacks and whites by appealing to masculine ethics of choosing death before dishonor, a theme that resonated with the Anglo-American elite. Yet, if some accounts of enslaved peoples' suicides reflected a set of reasons for choosing death that were shared across racial lines, others confirmed differences based on race and class. Such appraisals distanced the meanings of slave suicide from those of free Europeans, and sustained the disarticulation of suicide and slavery that had begun in the slave trade. Additionally reports of slave suicide also contained critical estimations of masters, a theme that became more pronounced over the course of the eighteenth century. In these ways as well, stories of enslaved people's suicides presented Anglo-American observers with a host of competing, contradictory, and charged messages and had the potential to unsettle the acceptance of slavery and assumptions about enslaved people. (pages 64 - 81)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0004
[law, forfeiture, outlaw, compensation, petitions]
This chapter examines the legalities of suicide in slavery which reached back into the seventeenth century, originating with lawmakers' efforts to establish control over and property rights in enslaved men and women. Colonial legislators revised English legal concepts of forfeiture, compensation, and outlawry, fusing together the legalities of suicide, slavery, and criminal justice in an original and, on occasion for slaveholders, a remunerative way. This chapter examines the legalities of slavery and suicide in order to gauge the extent and implications of colonial legal innovation and then analyze petitions for compensation made to colonial and state legislatures. These petitions, of course, reflect the point of view of masters, but they also reveal the circumstances under which enslaved people jumped into rivers, dashed their heads against rocks, took poison, and hanged themselves before the state or their owners had the opportunity to execute them. When slaves stood accused of crimes – for instance, murder, insurrection, theft, running away – they sometimes chose the power to die in order to escape state prosecution and execution. (pages 82 - 100)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0005
[Oroonoko, Ballads, Job Ben Solomon, John AnsahSessarakoo, popular]
Accounts of self-destructive slaves were part of the flourishing theme of suicide in early eighteenth-century Anglo-American print and theater. These depictions, often set in British American colonies and based on allegedly true events implicitly explored the paradoxes of slavery. Stories of slave suicide appeared in the venues aimed at middle to upper class readers and theatergoers, a group that included merchants, investors, and absentee owners with interests in slavery. Moreover, these literary fusions -- not exactly fact or fiction, but fiction putatively based on fact -- did not debate suicide, provide fodder for humorous anecdotes, or outwardly condemn slavery. Instead, these stories explored the implications of colonial slavery. In particular, they considered the characteristics of slaves -- rank, passion, beauty, and temperament were prominent themes -- and surveyed the nature of colonial slavery and the character of Anglo-American authority. Tales of slave suicide were a means for surveying the imperial politics of slavery from the safe distance of print. Variously focused on the slave trade, the temperament of Africans, and the nature of English authority, accounts of slave suicide probed the ramifications of slavery in British American plantations. (pages 101 - 120)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0006
[slave narratives, The Dying Negro, anti-slavery activism, gender]
This chapter analyzes the motif of slave suicide in Anglo-America anti-slavery print, beginning with the The Dying Negro (1773) and through slave narratives of the antebellum period. Earliest abolitionists used suicide to attack very specific aspects of slavery: the legal ambiguities slave status in England, the ways in which slave owners existed above the law, or the brutality of the international slave trade. These materials also asserted that slave suicide was a response to specific harms: imminent transport, the Middle Passage, and familial separation led enslaved men and women's to commit despairing acts of self-destruction. In contrast to the earliest anti-slavery activism, later, antebellum abolitionism staked its claim on more radically expansive visions of racial equality as well as demands for slavery's ends, invoking ideas of natural rights although maintaining the earlier emphasis on patriarchal privilege. Suicide, then, came to represent a host of specific injuries caused by slavery. (pages 121 - 156)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0007
[memory, Flying Africans, Charles Chestnutt]
Stories of suicide were part of the history and culture of slavery. After the Civil War, the memory of suicide in slavery was used to indict the institution of slavery and the history of white prejudice, to keep alive the injustices of slavery in the past to fuel the politics of the present historical moment. In these recollections, African Americans asserted authority over national history; remembrance memory was a means for them to interpret the past of slavery on their own terms, although these testimonies were often “highly mediated.” Stories of self-destruction in slavery were central to African American cultural politics that stretched into the twentieth century, long after slavery had ended. By focusing on the past tragedies of suicide, competing and distinct visions of the useable past of slavery were served up as lessons and reminders for the present national moment. (pages 157 - 166)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Terri L. Snyder
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226280738.003.0008
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Abbreviations

Notes

Select Bibliography of Primary Sources

Index