Physics Envy American Poetry and Science in the Cold War and After
by Peter Middleton
University of Chicago Press, 2015
Cloth: 978-0-226-29000-3 | Electronic: 978-0-226-29014-0
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

At the close of the Second World War, modernist poets found themselves in an increasingly scientific world, where natural and social sciences claimed exclusive rights to knowledge of both matter and mind. Following the overthrow of the Newtonian worldview and the recent, shocking displays of the power of the atom, physics led the way, with other disciplines often turning to the methods and discoveries of physics for inspiration.
           
In Physics Envy, Peter Middleton examines the influence of science, particularly physics, on American poetry since World War II. He focuses on such diverse poets as Charles Olson, Muriel Rukeyser, Amiri Baraka, and Rae Armantrout, among others, revealing how the methods and language of contemporary natural and social sciences—and even the discourse of the leading popular science magazine Scientific American—shaped their work. The relationship, at times, extended in the other direction as well: leading physicists such as Robert Oppenheimer, Werner Heisenberg, and Erwin Schrödinger were interested in whether poetry might help them explain the strangeness of the new, quantum world. Physics Envy is a history of science and poetry that shows how ultimately each serves to illuminate the other in its quest for the true nature of things.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Peter Middleton is professor of English at the University of Southampton. He is the author of three books of scholarship, most recently Distant Reading: Performance, Readership, and Consumption in Contemporary Poetry, and a book of poetry, Aftermath; and he is the coeditor of Teaching Modernist Poetry. He lives in Southampton.

REVIEWS

“Focusing mainly on Muriel Rukeyser, Charles Olson, Robert Duncan, George Oppen, Rae Armantrout, Amiri Baraka, and Jackson Mac Low, Middleton  . . . examines these writers' poetry and prose to ask how their goals and aesthetics responded to the cultural primacy of the sciences, especially physics, after WW II. . . . An especially interesting chapter focuses on the magazine Scientific American, founded in 1948, aimed at both scientists and nonspecialist readers, which informed many poets. In addition to poets, Middleton considers reflections on imagination and language by scientists such as J. Robert Oppenheimer and Werner Heisenberg. . . . Recommended.”
— Choice

"Middleton explores insightfully and sensitively how American poets from Rukeyser to Armantrout respond to poetry’s de-privileging as a source of epistemological knowledge; it is genuinely exciting to see prominent scientists such as Oppenheimer and Feynman, as well as an array of mid-twentieth-century social scientists, treated as thinkers who can help us better understand Cold War–era literature. As always, Middleton is an acute analyst, writing lucidly whether treating abstruse concepts in nuclear physics or presenting the ins and outs of experimental verse. Physics Envy is a delight to read."
— Brian M. Reed, author of Nobody's Business: Twenty-First Century Avant-Garde Poetics

"We know a good deal about the cold war era’s investment in science, but we know less about the extent to which poets drew upon the contributions of quantum physics, cybernetics, and relativity theory in forging a new poetics. Peter Middleton makes an excellent case for the generative impact of science on open field poetics, showing how Charles Olson, Muriel Rukeyser, Robert Duncan, and others adapted (and occasionally mis-read) the work of Heisenberg, Weiner, Schrödinger and social scientists like Kurt Lewin. Physics Envy is the definitive treatment of a vital conversation between poetic theory and scientific innovation in the postwar period."
— Michael Davidson, author of Bleed Through: New and Selected Poems

“In light of present institutional and social circumstances, Middleton’s subject is both relevant and appealing. . . . [The] notion of ‘inquiry’ sets Middleton’s book apart from other studies of American poetry’s relationship to atomic age sciences.”
— Contemporary Literature

“[A] fascinating book. Middleton’s Physics Envy begs to be extended and applied to other poets and periods.”
— American Literary History

"An original and valuable contribution to our understanding of the relations between poetry and the sciences in the United States during the mid-twentieth century. Especially of interest are the close readings of articles, whole issues, and advertisements from Scientific American in relation to specific poems and sequences—a fruitful approach, and, given Scientific American’s success and status as the publication presenting the public face of science in North America, an excellent way to reveal the multiplicity and nuance of poetic practice in its engagement with scientific language, values, and discoveries."
— Katy Price, author of Loving Faster Than Light: Romance and Readers in Einstein’s Universe

"This wonderfully crafted book offers a series of incisive and persuasive readings on a broad range of literary theorists, poets, and scientists, and Middleton’s sophisticated style of analysis rewards rereading. Physics Envy offers new ways in which to understand the interactions between American poets and scientific ideas and will be of real interest to scholars working in the fields of Cold War culture, literature, and science."
— Isis

"Published at the dawn of a sea change in American politics that is currently raising justified fears of the delegitimization of both the sciences and the humanities, Physics Envy stands tall as a reminder of the ways in which scientific and artistic inquiries into the relationship between humans and the world make up the very force that articulates what could be understood as a genuinely American field."
— British Society for Literature and Science Reviews

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Acknowledgments

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0001
[poetry, natural sciences, social sciences, knowledge, J. Robert Oppenheimer, physics]
The book begins by arguing that after 1945 the natural and social sciences increasingly claimed that they alone could offer reliable knowledge-producing methods of inquiry into the material and human worlds. Some scientists including J. Robert Oppenheimer talked as if poetry was a primitive form of human communication. Now almost every American was in practice a scientist. The prestige of physics led many disciplines to borrow its methods to achieve their own scientific rigor. Poets had to decide how to respond to the scientization of America. Charles Olson was one of the poets who also became interested in the possibility of using concepts from physics to create a new poetics. The introduction concludes with a summary of the contents of the book. (pages 1 - 14)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

PART I. POETRY AND SCIENCE

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0002
[New American poets, language writers, postwar poets, literary theory, epistemology, modernist poetry, physics envy, Archibald MacLeish, William Carlos Williams]
Postwar New American poets and their successors, the Language Writers, insisted that their poetry was capable of intellectual inquiry. After giving examples of their claims for poetry, the chapter sets out the book’s methodological assumptions. Literary theory has struggled to represent adequately the interrelations between science and poetry because it has not engaged with the epistemological claims of the sciences. Yet science is part of the DNA of modern literary theory. One major theme of the book is how poets attempted to develop new poetic epistemologies. Science envy has been attributed to the early-twentieth-century modernist poets, but the book argues that the picture is more complex in the postwar era. Many disciplines employed methods and concepts from physics, seeing this not as physics envy but as intellectual opportunity. The book then maps out schematically the different kinds of responses made by postwar American poets of all kinds to the sciences. It goes on to show how some of these responses had antecedents among modernist predecessors. Archibald MacLeish’s poem “Einstein” is discussed in detail because of its representative character. The importance of William Carlos Williams and Ezra Pound for later poets is discussed. (pages 17 - 50)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0003
[physicists, semi-phenomenological, quark, science journals, Erwin Schröger, Werner Heisenberg, Robert Creeley, Robert Duncan, J. Robert Oppenheimer]
The chapter shows how postwar poets encountered strong negative or idealized images of poetry in the writings of physicists and other scientists. Physicists sometimes referred to an abstraction of poetry in order to negotiate tricky questions about how to communicate the strangeness and “semi-phenomenological” character of the quantum world. Murray Gell-Mann coins the term “quark” partly because the allusion to Joyce enables him to finesse the questionable actuality of these sub-atomic particles. The chapter discusses the surprising prevalence of articles about poetry in general science journals aimed at professional scientists, and looks in detail at one article on contemporary poetry and science. Many poets read and referred to popular writings by Erwin Schröger and Werner Heisenberg. The chapter explains how their books appealed to poets because they referenced poetry, and talked about its possible future roles in relation to physics. Robert Creeley and Robert Duncan both found uses for the ideas of these physicists in their essays and poems. The chapter concludes with a discussion of how late in his career Oppenheimer reversed his earlier endorsement of Paul Dirac’s dismissal of poetry, by arguing that good scientific communication to the public would have the quality of lyric. (pages 51 - 86)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

PART II. MIDCENTURY

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0004
[Charles Olson, mid-century, nuclear physics, atom, projective verse, field, epistemological]
The chapter begins with a discussion of what Charles Olson called his “joy of science,” arguing that this arose from an interest in how science and poetry might collaborate. In order to understand the complexities of his relations with the sciences, especially physics, the discussion then centers on a thick description of the importance of physics in the literary culture of poetry around 1950 or mid-century, as it is called, to indicate a time span from the late 1940s to the early 50s. Starting from the publication of “Projective Verse” in a small magazine, the chapter shows just how widespread was poetic interest in the sciences at that time. Olson’s interest in a field poetics was stimulated by misleading news that Einstein had produced a unified field theory. The chapter then sketches the main characteristics of the mid-century atom as presented by nuclear physics, and shows how physicists represented their discipline in terms of the unknown and the uncertainty of knowledge. Other disciplines, including Norbert Weiner’s cybernetics, Quine’s holistic critique of logical positivism, and René Wellek and Austin Warren’s literary theory, engaged in an epistemological competition for a share of the epistemic authority invested in physics. (pages 89 - 116)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0005
[Kurt Lewin, conceptual scheme, Muriel Rukeyser, Charles Olson, The Life of Poetry, Projective Verse, Willard Gibbs, Harvard social science, system, field]
By mid-century, social scientists such as Kurt Lewin increasing believed that a better understanding of the mind and society required scientific methods, especially the use of conceptual schemes. Muriel Rukeyser brought her interest in such conceptual schemes to bear on her discussion of science and poetry in The Life of Poetry, a book that anticipated “Projective Verse.” She had already investigated conceptual schemes in her biography of the nineteenth-century physicist Willard Gibbs, whose ideas on scientific method had influenced Harvard social scientists, notably Lawrence Henderson. From these sources, Rukeyser produced her own poetics of system. This theory is criticized for its limitations, and contrasted with Olson’s concept of the field. It is argued that Olson’s experience of Harvard social science led him to write Call Me Ishmael, using a conceptual scheme, and then to develop his field poetics. This poetics has proven very useful because it offers an open-ended approach to locating meaning in the myriad elements of a poem, and because it draws attention to the relation between poetic expression and other kinds of knowledge. (pages 117 - 150)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0006
[Muriel Rukeyser, Charles Olson, conceptual scheme, physics, Robert Duncan, Maximus to Gloucester Letter 27 withheld, Alfred North Whitehead, apprehensions]
This chapter traces the development of Rukeyser and Olson’s thinking about physics over the next two decades, as they gradually jettisoned conceptual schemes based on the system and the field. Their trajectory is contrasted with the shifting interests in science of Robert Duncan. Rukeyser begins with high hopes of editing a major anthology on science and the humanities, but gradually loses confidence in schemas borrowed from physics. After her long poem One Life she largely abandons the use of poetic masks, and writes in The Speed of Darkness that the fundamental unit of the universe is the story not the atom. The chapter then offers close readings of science in Olson’s poems “The Kingfishers,” the unpublished “Maximus Letter #28,” and “Maximus to Gloucester, Letter 27 [withheld].” This last poem is read in detail against its sources in Whitehead’s metaphysics, which provided Olson with a readymade conceptual scheme. The final section explores Duncan’s discursive responses to public knowledge of the sciences, and gives close readings of two poems, “Apprehensions” and “The Fire: Passages 13.” “The Fire” is a poem that Olson could not have written, because it expresses and then examines the poet’s rage at scientists like Oppenheimer. (pages 151 - 194)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

PART III. SCIENTIFIC AMERICANS

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0007
[Rae Armantrout, sociobiology, Jackson Mac Low, Robert Duncan, Osiris and Set, Stanzas for Iris Lezak, Scientific American, inquiry, nuclear]
This chapter discusses how four poets made use, or may have done so, of specific articles from Scientific American, a magazine that deliberately set out to provide the public with sufficient information about scientific developments to contribute to democracy. Sometimes a poet only later acknowledges it as a source, as in the case of Rae Armantrout’s poem “Natural History,” which critiques sociobiology. The chapter speculates whether Frank O’Hara’s famous poem about the sun was written in response to a specific Scientific American article and concludes that the circumstantial evidence is not strong enough. Jackson Mac Low’s poems in Stanzas for Iris Lezak make use of several articles from Scientific American. The chapter argues that his acrostic proceduralism is an original mode of inquiry by which he exposes hidden strata in scientific texts, and exposes norms of poetic communication. Robert Duncan explicitly cites a diagram in an article on human evolution in the Scientific American in his poem “Osiris and Set,” which is shown to be responsive not only to that passage in the article, but also to the general mood of an issue of the magazine full of advertisements for advanced nuclear weaponry. (pages 197 - 220)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Peter Middleton
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226290140.003.0008
[Scientific American, George Oppen, Of Being Numerous, Martin Heidegger, Kevin Lynch, social science, race science, city, Amiri Baraka]
Annual special issues of Scientific American enabled the public to learn about a scientific topic and sometimes to see that scientific knowledge was provisional, the subject of dispute within the profession itself. Gary Snyder’s Turtle Island responds to the divisions about nuclear energy revealed in two special issues on energy and ecology. The chapter offers a detailed close reading of George Oppen’s “Of Being Numerous” in the context of a special issue of Scientific American on the city. Whether or not Oppen read the magazine, he responded to current debates among social scientists about how to solve the problems of the metropolis, especially their use of the calculative rationality that Heidegger deplored. In one article, Kevin Lynch claims that the city is a work of art. Oppen’s poem disagrees, and the chapter shows just how extensively he works to challenge the aesthetic vision of the city as art. The final section of the chapter places Amiri Baraka’s poem “Ka ‘Ba” in the context of the mostly liberal discussions of race science in Scientific American, and also discusses the wider debates about the persistence of eugenicist racial science in other scientific journals. (pages 221 - 254)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

Coda

Notes

Index