Bourgeois Equality How Ideas, Not Capital or Institutions, Enriched the World
by Deirdre Nansen McCloskey
University of Chicago Press, 2016
Cloth: 978-0-226-33399-1 | Paper: 978-0-226-52793-2 | Electronic: 978-0-226-33404-2
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226334042.001.0001

AVAILABLE FROM

University of Chicago Press (paper, ebook)
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

 There’s little doubt that most humans today are better off than their forebears. Stunningly so, the economist and historian Deirdre McCloskey argues in the concluding volume of her trilogy celebrating the oft-derided virtues of the bourgeoisie. The poorest of humanity, McCloskey shows, will soon be joining the comparative riches of Japan and Sweden and Botswana.
 
Why? Most economists—from Adam Smith and Karl Marx to Thomas Piketty—say the Great Enrichment since 1800 came from accumulated capital. McCloskey disagrees, fiercely. “Our riches,” she argues, “were made not by piling brick on brick, bank balance on bank balance, but by piling idea on idea.” Capital was necessary, but so was the presence of oxygen. It was ideas, not matter, that drove “trade-tested betterment.”  Nor were institutions the drivers. The World Bank orthodoxy of “add institutions and stir” doesn’t work, and didn’t. McCloskey builds a powerful case for the initiating role of ideas—ideas for electric motors and free elections, of course, but more deeply the bizarre and liberal ideas of equal liberty and dignity for ordinary folk. Liberalism arose from theological and political revolutions in northwest Europe, yielding a unique respect for betterment and its practitioners, and upending ancient hierarchies. Commoners were encouraged to have a go, and the bourgeoisie took up the Bourgeois Deal, and we were all enriched.
 
Few economists or historians write like McCloskey—her ability to invest the facts of economic history with the urgency of a novel, or of a leading case at law, is unmatched. She summarizes modern economics and modern economic history with verve and lucidity, yet sees through to the really big scientific conclusion. Not matter, but ideas. Big books don’t come any more ambitious, or captivating, than Bourgeois Equality.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Deirdre Nansen McCloskey is an emerita distinguished professor of economics and of history, and professor of English and of communications at the University of Illinois at Chicago. She is the author of sixteen other books, including If You’re So Smart, The Secret Sins of Economics, The Bourgeois Virtues, Bourgeois Dignity, and Crossing: A Memoir, all published by the University of Chicago Press.

REVIEWS

"It has always seemed to me that history is overdetermined, so any attempt to pick out a single cause will be doomed, and yet McCloskey's insistence on the essential role of what she variously calls ideas, ideology, ethics or rhetoric—the social acceptability of bourgeois folk engaging honourably in business—is persuasive. . . . Bourgeois Equality is richly detailed and erudite, and it will join its companion volumes as essential reading on the industrial revolution, as well as a model of the intellectual depth and breadth achievable through the study of economics."
— Diane Coyle, Financial Times

"It took me two months to read this 650-page, small-type book, the third volume in a trilogy. In that time I read several other books, absorbing Bourgeois Equality in small doses on trains, ships, Tubes, sofas and beds. If that sounds like faint praise, it's not. I wanted to savour every sentence of this remarkable feast of prose. It is a giant of a book about a giant of a topic: the ‘great enrichment’ of humanity over the past 300 years. It is so rich in vocabulary, allusion and fact as to be a contender for the great book of the great book of our age. Dump your copy of Thomas Piketty and put Deirdre McCloskey on the bookshelf instead."
— Matt Ridley, The Times, Book of the Week

"A sparkling book. . . . McCloskey makes a convincing case."
— Martin Wolf, Financial Times, Best Books of Early 2016

“McCloskey has spent a long and distinguished career asserting the efficacy of free markets in goods and labour. . . . Unusually versed in philosophy and literature, she has acted as something of a domestic chaplain for the Chicago school of economists, ministering to the spiritual state of Homo economicus. . . . McCloskey is at her best in arguing that economics and ethics are mutually important but largely autonomous spheres of human endeavour.”
— Jeffrey Collins, Times Literary Supplement

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Exordium: The Three Volumes Show That We Are Rich Because of an Ethical and Rhetorical Change

Acknowledgments

First Question: What Is to Be Explained?

Part I. A Great Enrichment Happened, and Will Happen

1. The World Is Pretty Rich, but Once Was Poor

2. For Malthusian and Other Reasons, Very Poor

3. Then Many of Us Shot Up the Blade of a Hockey Stick

4. As Your Own Life Shows

5. The Poor Were Made Much Better Off

6. Inequality Is Not the Problem

7. Despite Doubts from the Left

8. Or from the Right and Middle

9. The Great International Divergence Can Be Overcome

Second Question: Why Not the Conventional Explanations?

Part II. Explanations from Left and Right Have Proven False

10. The Divergence Was Not Caused by Imperialism

11. Poverty Cannot Be Overcome from the Left by Overthrowing “Capitalism”

12. “Accumulate, Accumulate” Is Not What Happened in History

13. But Neither Can Poverty Be Overcome from the Right by Implanting “Institutions”

14. Because Ethics Matters, and Changes, More

15. And the Oomph of Institutional Change Is Far Too Small

16. Most Governmental Institutions Make Us Poorer

Third Question: What, Then, Explains the Enrichment?

Part III. Bourgeois Life Had Been Rhetorically Revalued Britain at the Onset of the Industrial Revolution

17. It Is a Truth Universally Acknowledged That Even Dr. Johnson and Jane Austen Exhibit the Revaluation

18. No Woman but a Blockhead Wrote for Anything but Money

19. Adam Smith Exhibits Bourgeois Theory at Its Ethical Best

20. Smith Was Not a Mr. Max U, but Rather the Last of the Former Virtue Ethicists

21. That Is, He Was No Reductionist, Economistic or Otherwise

22. And He Formulated the Bourgeois Deal

23. Ben Franklin Was Bourgeois, and He Embodied Betterment

24. By 1848 a Bourgeois Ideology Had Wholly Triumphed

Part IV. A Pro-Bourgeois Rhetoric Was Forming in England around 1700

25. The Word “Honest” Shows the Changing Attitude toward the Aristocracy and the Bourgeoisie

26. And So Does the Word “Eerlijk”

27. Defoe, Addison, and Steele Show It, Too

28. The Bourgeois Revaluation Becomes a Commonplace, as in The London Merchant

29. Bourgeois Europe, for Example, Loved Measurement

30. The Change Was in Social Habits of the Lip, Not in Psychology

31. And the Change Was Specifically British

Part V. Yet England Had Recently Lagg ed in Bourgeois Ideology, Compared with the Netherlands

32. Bourgeois Shakespeare Disdained Trade and the Bourgeoisie

33. As Did Elizabethan England Generally

34. Aristocratic England, for Example, Scorned Measurement

35. The Dutch Preached Bourgeois Virtue

36. And the Dutch Bourgeoisie Was Virtuous

37. For Instance, Bourgeois Holland Was Tolerant, and Not for Prudence Only

Part VI. R eformation, Revolt, Revolution, and Reading Increased the Liberty and Dignity of Ordinary Europeans

38. The Causes Were Local, Temporary, and Unpredictable

39. “Democratic” Church Governance Emboldened People

40. The Theology of Happiness Changed circa 1700

41. Printing and Reading and Fragmentation Sustained the Dignity of Commoners

42. Political Ideas Mattered for Equal Liberty and Dignity

43. Ideas Made for a Bourgeois Revaluation

44. The Rhetorical Change Was Necessary, and Maybe Sufficient

Part VII. Nowhere Before on a Large Scale Had Bourgeois or Other Commoners Been Honored

45. Talk Had Been Hostile to Betterment

46. The Hostility Was Ancient

47. Yet Some Christians Anticipated a Respected Bourgeoisie

48. And Betterment, Though Long Disdained, Developed Its Own Vested Interests

49. And Then Turned

50. On the Whole, However, the Bourgeoisies and Their Bettering Projects Have Been Precarious

Part VIII. Words and Ideas Ca used the Modern World

51. Sweet Talk Rules the Economy

52. And Its Rhetoric Can Change Quickly

53. It Was Not a Deep Cultural Change

54. Yes, It Was Ideas, Not Interests or Institutions, That Changed, Suddenly, in Northwestern Europe

55. Elsewhere Ideas about the Bourgeoisie Did Not Change

Fourth Question: What Are the Dangers?

Part IX. The History and Economics Have Been Misunderstood

56. The Change in Ideas Contradicts Many Ideas from the Political Middle, 1890–1980

57. And Many Polanyish Ideas from the Left

58. Yet Polanyi Was Right about Embeddedness

59. Trade-Tested Betterment Is Democratic in Consumption

60. And Liberating in Production

61. And Therefore Bourgeois Rhetoric Was Better for the Poor

Part X. That Is, Rhetoric Made Us, but Ca n Readily Unmake Us

62. After 1848 the Clerisy Converted to Antibetterment

63. The Clerisy Betrayed the Bourgeois Deal, and Approved the Bolshevik and Bismarckian Deals

64. Anticonsumerism and Pro-Bohemianism Were Fruits of the Antibetterment Reaction

65. Despite the Clerisy’s Doubts

66. What Matters Ethically Is Not Equality of Outcome, but the Condition of the Working Class

67. A Change in Rhetoric Made Modernity, and Can Spread It

Notes

Works Cited

Index