Midnight Basketball Race, Sports, and Neoliberal Social Policy
by Douglas Hartmann
University of Chicago Press, 2016
Cloth: 978-0-226-37484-0 | Paper: 978-0-226-37498-7 | Electronic: 978-0-226-37503-8
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

Midnight basketball may not have been invented in Chicago, but the City of Big Shoulders—home of Michael Jordan and the Bulls—is where it first came to national prominence. And it’s also where Douglas Hartmann first began to think seriously about the audacious notion that organizing young men to run around in the wee hours of the night—all trying to throw a leather ball through a metal hoop—could constitute meaningful social policy.
            Organized in the 1980s and ’90s by dozens of American cities, late-night basketball leagues were designed for social intervention, risk reduction, and crime prevention targeted at African American youth and young men. In Midnight Basketball, Hartmann traces the history of the program and the policy transformations of the period, while exploring the racial ideologies, cultural tensions, and institutional realities that shaped the entire field of sports-based social policy. Drawing on extensive fieldwork, the book also brings to life the actual, on-the-ground practices of midnight basketball programs and the young men that the programs intended to serve. In the process, Midnight Basketball offers a more grounded and nuanced understanding of the intricate ways sports, race, and risk intersect and interact in urban America.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Douglas Hartmann is professor of sociology at the University of Minnesota. He is the author of Race, Culture, and the Revolt of the Black Athlete, also published by the University of Chicago Press.
 

REVIEWS

“Hartmann takes readers on a critically self-reflective journey that weaves together nearly two decades of cultural analysis and his own development as a sociologist and public intellectual. Much more than about midnight basketball, this book explains the complex connections between public policy, race, sports, and the dynamics of neoliberalism in recent US history.”
— Jay Coakley, author of Sports in Society: Issues and Controversies

“In Midnight Basketball, Hartmann deftly exposes the ideological import of crime prevention basketball programs popular in the 1980s and 1990s. While offering opportunities for pleasure and comradery, Hartmann’s insightful analysis reveals how these policy interventions offered very little in the way of meaningful educational opportunities or social services. Thus, rather than addressing inequalities that limit life chances these basketball programs sought to police and control poor inner-city black men’s behaviors. Hartmann’s investigation is additionally important in exposing the limitations of similar neoliberal sport based policy initiatives that continue to proliferate globally.”
— Mary G. McDonald, director, Sports, Society, and Technology Program, Georgia Institute of Technology

“In Midnight Basketball Hartmann offers a compelling account of the role of sport in fostering social change. Drawing upon nearly two decades of careful empirical research, and using the political debates that surrounded the late-night basketball leagues that sprung up across America in the late 1980s as his starting point, Hartmann provides a fascinating analysis of the convergence of neoliberal ideas around personal responsibility, concerns about the ‘risk’ posed to wider society by young black men, and the often utopian belief that playing sports can help the disadvantaged overcome their station in life through the acquisition of better morals and a stronger work ethic.  Hartmann’s engaging book is required reading for anyone concerned about the devastating and continuing impact of neoliberal social policies on the lives of America’s inner-city residents, and what sports-based forms of intervention and risk-prevention can and cannot achieve. Midnight Basketball is therefore destined to become an instant classic.”
— Ben Carrington, author of Race, Sport, and Politics: The Sporting Black Diaspora

“Hartmann, in this outstanding work of scholarship, unearths the significance of midnight basketball, not merely as a racially coded sporting activity addressing social intervention, risk management, and crime intervention issues in impoverished urban communities, but also as a subject of neoliberal policy that has effected, and will continue to effect, millions of disadvantaged people in America. Through his thorough analysis of politics, history, race, and culture in sports, Hartmann demonstrates how an interdisciplinary approach can provide unparalleled insights about the deeply-rooted relationship between sports and society in America.”
— Reuben A. Buford May, author of Living Through the Hoop: High School Basketball, Race, and the American Dream

“Hartmann’s methodology is mixed, using fieldwork observations of an early program in Minneapolis, in addition to extensive sociocultural analysis of the policy and politics of the era. He contextualizes the policy along with the political and social engineering platforms that surrounded it. The author’s work highlights the limits of the policy as a self-improvement vehicle, noting that most of his subjects reported simply enjoying the camaraderie and the competition of another organized basketball league. Although his conclusion is relatively simple, Hartmann’s analysis is nuanced, intricate, interdisciplinary, and thought provoking. Recommended.”
— Choice

Midnight Basketball sets out to understand the emergence of this program in the 1980s, the fanfare surrounding it, and its quick demise. . . .In using a singular case study, Hartmann successfully chronicles the interface between sport, race, neoliberal policy, the criminal justice system, and the broader history of sports interventionist policies. . . .Among the many strengths of Midnight Basketball is that it moves beyond the court and the policy, as a window into the 1980s, demonstrating the interconnections between sport, neoliberal, deindustrialization, structural adjustments, and racism. It is as much a story on the devastating consequences of Reagan and the resurgent “new right” and on the prison industrial complex and war on drugs as it is a story on basketball programs “serving” black youth.”
— American Journal of Sociology

TABLE OF CONTENTS

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0001
[sport studies;race;mixed methods;neoliberal;African-American men;critical race theory;social policy]
Chapter one provides an introduction to the phenomenon of midnight basketball and an overview of the origins, research methods, and narrative structure of the book. The project's origins are traced to the bifurcated images of African-American men in late 1980s American culture as either super-predator criminals or super-star athletes. Midnight basketball, it is argued, put the latter in service of the former. The analysis then is based upon multiple forms of data and research methods (archival documentation, interviewing, media and content analysis, ethnographic fieldwork) informed by sport studies and critical race theories and situated in the context of social policy transformations of the neoliberal period. (pages 1 - 15)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0002
[G. Van Standifer;sport policy;crime prevention;post-Civil Rights;risk reduction;racial politics;racial ideologies]
Chapter 2 uses original archival materials situated in the historical context of neoliberalism and developed in dialogue with scholarly literatures on sports history and the sociology of race to trace the origins and explain the popularity of midnight basketball in late 1980s American culture. (pages 16 - 38)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0003
[President George H. W. Bush;Jack Kemp;sport culture;neoliberal;social policy;politics;Thousand Points of Light Initiative]
Chapter 3 deepens and extends the analysis of the historical origins and cultural popularity of midnight basketball. It locates midnight basketball's popularity in at least three contexts: (1) sport's long standing ideals about social intervention and racial progress; (2) post-Civil Rights racial discourse and politics; and (3) the transformations of urban social policy in the neoliberal era. The figures of President George H. W. Bush and his thousand Points of Light initiative along with HUD Secretary Jack Kemp are used to illustrate. It is argued that midnight basketball provided a unique synthesis of liberal and conservative approaches to the perceived problems of crime and violence among "at-risk" youth and urban young men. (pages 39 - 69)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0004
[symbolic politics;deep play;racial coding;cultural politics;neoliberal;social policy]
Chapter 4 puts the early history of midnight basketball in a broader and more explicit political context. Specifically, it argues that these sport-based programs functioned in the media and were used by political leaders to promote a new, neoliberal approach to crime prevention and urban public policy to broad public audiences. These processes and politics are analyzed as examples of the symbolic or cultural politics of sport, highlighting especially sport's unique status as a "deep play" form. Racial coding is also addressed. (pages 70 - 95)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0005
[1994 crime bill;Rush Limbaugh;President Bill Clinton;racial politics;criminal justice policy;racial coding]
Chapter 5 explains the breakdown of the popularity and bipartisan consensus that had originally surrounded midnight basketball in the context of the 1994 crime bill debates. It details the political and cultural roots of this collapse as well as its broader political and public policy consequences. Essentially it portrays midnight basketball as getting caught up in the tensions between conservative and liberal approaches to crime and violence in the neoliberal era--represented mainly by the more punitive visions of Rush Limbaugh and Bob Dole, on the one hand, and Bill Clinton's more prevention-oriented approach on the other. The broader point is the debates over midnight basketball functioned as a racially-coded symbolic proxy for these larger policy divisions and, moreover, that conservatives successfully utilized the racial threat along with the ability to trivialize prevention through its association with sport and play to force changes in the criminal justice policy that eventually was ratified. (pages 96 - 125)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0006
[sport policy;social intervention;globalization;sport as development]
Chapter 6 examines how midnight basketball programs were reformed in the aftermath of the 1994 crime bill debates. It details the consolidation of a more liberal, prevention-oriented coalition in support of sport-based programming as well as the emergence of a new, more mature understanding (or theory) of the role of sport in social intervention and risk prevention. Key elements include: seeing sport as a tool for recruitment and retention; the importance of non-sport programming; collaboration with other social programs, agencies, organizations, and initiatives. The globalization or global diffusion of the midnight basketball idea is also discussed. (pages 126 - 150)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Darren Wheelock
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0007
[ethnography;Minneapolis;sport as development;community-based programs;Minnesota;]
Chapter 7 is the first of two chapters that draw upon ethnographic fieldwork to provide an insider's account of a community-based basketball prevention program in Minneapolis. This chapter details the organizational structure, objectives, implementation, and day-to-day operation of the Minnesota program. It documents deep and unexpected tensions among program administrators and grassroots organizers, the underlying racial politics and cultural tensions, and the challenges of assessment and evaluation . These findings are also used to theorize the ongoing challenges of any sport based intervention initiative in a neoliberal context. (pages 151 - 174)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0008
[ethnographic fieldwork;community-based programs;sport policy;African-American communities]
Chapter 8 continues the ethnographic case study to focus on the meanings of and motivations for basketball-based risk prevention programs from the point of view of program participants and members of the African-American community more generally. One of its central findings is that the young men of color who participate in these leagues have little interest in the social interventionist goals of most program funders and administrators; rather, they are involved for purposes of health, fitness, recreation, and leisure. Community members see midnight basketball as a symbol of more proactive, community-based approaches to crime prevention and public safety. The chapter highlights the features of the urban landscape that help explain these attitudes and draws out the larger implications for race, sport, and public policy in the neoliberal era. (pages 175 - 195)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Douglas Hartmann
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226375038.003.0009
[cultural sociology;sport studies;critical race theory;sport policy;neoliberal;racial coding;colorblindness;theory;social policy]
This final chapter draws out the broader implications of this case study of midnight basketball for sport studies and sport policy, the sociology of race and the African American experience, cultural sociology, and neoliberal social policy. Particular attention is paid to deep play and the cultural politics of sport; theories of sport as intervention and development; critical race theory, racial coding and colorblindness; the centrality of sport as a social force in the contemporary world; and the transformations and limitations of social intervention and criminal justice policy under conditions of neoliberalism. Connections and intersections between and among these themes are also discussed. (pages 196 - 210)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...