Overcoming the Saving Slump How to Increase the Effectiveness of Financial Education and Saving Programs
edited by Annamaria Lusardi
University of Chicago Press, 2009
Cloth: 978-0-226-49709-9 | Electronic: 978-0-226-49710-5
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

The great majority of working Americans are unprepared to face the difficult task of planning for retirement. In fact, the personal savings rate has been holding steady at zero for several years, down from 8 percent in the mid-1980s. Overcoming the Saving Slump explores the many challenges facing workers in the transition from a traditional defined benefit pension system to one that requires more individual responsibility, analyzing the considerable impediments to saving and evaluating financial literacy programs devised by employers and the government.
 
Mapping the changing landscape of pensions and the rise of defined contribution plans, Annamaria Lusardi and others investigate new methods for stimulating saving and promoting financial education drawing on the experience of the United States as well as countries that have privatized their welfare systems, including Sweden and Chile.  This timely volume pinpoints where human resources departments, the financial industry, and government officials have succeeded—or failed—in bridging the way to a new retirement system. As the workforce ages and more pensions disappear each second, Lusardi’s findings will be invaluable for economists and anyone facing retirement.
 

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Annamaria Lusardi is professor of economics at Dartmouth College and a research associate of the NBER. She won the Fidelity Pyramid Prize for her work on improving lifelong financial well-being for Americans.
 
 
 
 

REVIEWS

“Financial literacy is increasingly important in a world where individuals from all economic strata, rather than institutions, are being given a significantly greater role in financial decision making over the life course. Lusardi’s approach is balanced, innovative, and insightful, drawing perspectives from law, economics, marketing, and sociology, as well as American and international experiences in these domains. This book is well written and will be of interest to a wide variety of readers.”
— Gary Engelhardt, Syracuse University

“Rather than simply reporting on the savings slump, Lusardi assembles a remarkable collection of researchers focused on halting this slide. Rather than limiting their attention to a single solution, they explore a wide range of prescriptions from social marketing and financial education, to product design, policy changes, and process innovations. Lusardi and her collaborators exemplify how careful scholarship can inform an important challenge facing our society.”

— Peter Tufano, Harvard Business School

“This book tells you everything you want to know about financial education and how it can be used to improve financial decisions. It draws on different scientific disciplines, uses evidence from many countries, and discusses the main findings and puzzles in the literature. Indispensable for anyone who is interested in better financial decision making.”

— Arie Kapteyn, Director, RAND Labor and Population

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Preface

- Annamaria Lusardi
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0001
[financial education programs, investment products, pension systems, social security systems, United States, saving behavior, saving slump]
This book investigates the financial education programs that are in place, examines available investment products, and looks at the experiences of countries that have privatized the pension systems or experienced changes in the social security systems. It presents suggestions on how to enhance the effectiveness of these programs and products, thereby enabling the United States to make the transition to this new system more smoothly. The book shows that although the problems are many and the challenges daunting, programs can be designed to change saving behavior and overcome the saving slump now facing so many individuals. It also reveals that financial education programs can be effective and that increased literacy does result in better saving habits. Finally, an overview of the chapters included in the book is provided. (pages 1 - 14)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

I. The Shift from Defined Benefit to Defined Contribution Pensions and Financial Regulation

- James M. Poterba, Steven F. Venti, David A. Wise
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0002
[pension landscape, United States, retirement assets, employees, pension plan, Social Security, earnings, financial assets, personal account saving]
This chapter reviews the economic changes that are occurring in the pension landscape in the United States. The total value of assets in retirement accounts has increased since 1980. The proportion of employees covered by at least one pension plan has remained about the same over the past twenty-five years, but the proportion covered by more than one has increased. The investment options available to 401(k) participants are evolving rapidly. The projections suggest that the spread of 401(k) assets will lead in a substantial increase in the retirement assets of households with the lowest Social Security wealth and will result in a doubling or tripling of retirement assets for households in the rest of the Social Security wealth distribution. It can be concluded that the advent of personal account saving is projected to yield very large increases in the financial assets of future retirees across the lifetime earnings spectrum. (pages 17 - 46)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Alan L. Gustman, Thomas L. Steinmeier, Nahid Tabatabai
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0003
[pensions, firm, reporting error, respondents, pension plan type, Watson Wyatt, pension coverage]
This chapter addresses a widespread lack of information about pensions. It seems that discrepancies between respondent and firm reports of plan type are mainly due to errors in respondent data. A number of changes in survey design can help decrease reporting error. The fraction of respondents who do not know their plan type is lower in later years. In addition, the fraction who correctly determine their plan type has no strong trend over time, running about 60 percent in 1983 and about 62 percent in 2004. For the corresponding periods 1992–2004 and 1998–2004, the matches were better. Findings with Watson Wyatt data reveal that underreporting of pension coverage amounts to about 5 percent. The data reports that respondents frequently misreport pension plan type. The evidence then reveals that providing a person with the opportunity to report on the wrong plan type will invite the individual to present erroneous information. (pages 47 - 81)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Howell E. Jackson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0004
[financial regulation, trilateral dilemmas, financial education, financial advice, financial services industry, consumer education, market]
This chapter deals with a dozen examples of trilateral dilemmas in financial regulation, and elbaorates the legal aspects of financial education and advice. Trilateral dilemmas appear in multiple areas of the financial services industry and have generated a surprisingly diverse array of regulatory responses. Defenders of side payments typically assert a general defense, resting on the notion that competitive forces will ensure that the payments are offset in the total prices individuals pay for their financial services and then on more context-specific claims that these payments address some more subtle contracting problems. While blended pricing may in some contexts facilitate price comparison and market constraints on abuses, at other times, the blending of costs may complicate such comparison and insulate firms from market pressures. Finally, a few remarks on the implications of the analysis for consumer education are provided. (pages 82 - 116)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

II. Portfolio Choice, Life-Cycle Funds, and Annuities

- Gary R. Mottola, Stephen P. Utkus
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0005
[contribution plans, yellow portfolios, green portfolios, participant portfolio, investors, investment, 401(k) plan, retirement security]
This chapter explores the data from over 2,000 defined contribution plans and nearly 2.9 million 401(k) participants, and uses a simple stoplight color scheme—green, yellow, and red—to classify participants' portfolio selection. It is proposed that investors could turn funds over to managed accounts. The chapter also discusses investment literacy among 401(k) plan participants, many of whom seem to adopt reasonable levels of equity exposure. Additionally, a meaningful group of participants could enhance expected returns or diversification levels (or both), thus improving their prospects for retirement security. At a gross portfolio construction level, many participants have reasonably healthy portfolios. The analysis of participant portfolio choice shows that nearly 45 percent of participants construct green portfolios based on their overall exposure to a diversified level of equity market risk, while another 25 percent or so construct yellow portfolios with possibly too aggressive or too conservative equity holdings. (pages 119 - 139)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Luis M. Viceira
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0006
[life-cycle funds, human capital, investment, pension plans, mutual fund industry, money market fund, income]
This chapter describes how human capital is equivalent to an implicit investment in bonds for an investor who knows his income in advance with perfect certainty, and argues that properly designed life-cycle funds are better default investment choices than money market funds in defined contribution (DC) pension plans. Life-cycle mutual funds are one of the fastest growing segments in the mutual fund industry. The long-standing practice of sponsors of DC pension plans choosing a money market fund as the default option for plan participants might not be appropriate if the goal is to choose a safe investment. The issuance of inflation-indexed bonds by the Treasury has a significant impact on welfare. Life-cycle funds are inexpensive to manage, and most mutual fund companies do not charge fees on top of the fees they already charge to the underlying funds. (pages 140 - 177)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Jeffrey R. Brown
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0007
[annuities, financial-planning process, economic theory, behavioral biases, retirees, Pension Protection Act, annuitization]
This chapter investigates the role of annuities in the financial-planning process, including both the normative judgment about what role annuities “should” play (as guided by economic theory), as well as empirical evidence about the role that they actually do play. It describes several working hypotheses about behavioral biases that may affect annuity demand. The economic literature presents a strong theoretical foundation for the normative conclusion that annuities ought to be of substantial value to retirees. Simulation work reveals that under a specific process for inflation, a moderately risk-averse consumer would find nominal annuities less attractive than inflation-indexed annuities. The Pension Protection Act took significant steps to encourage the use of default options in the accumulation phase of 401(k) plans. It is noted that the economics and psychology of the annuitization decision remain a very fruitful area for additional research. (pages 178 - 206)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

III. Improving Financial Education and Saving Programs

- Annamaria Lusardi
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0008
[social marketing approach, planning aid, employees, retirement pensions, psychology, economics, saving]
This chapter uses a social marketing approach to develop a planning aid to help new employees at a not-for-profit institution open and contribute to supplementary retirement pensions. It demonstrates that it is important to incorporate concepts of marketing and psychology into economics to both understand and exploit differences in individual behavior. A sharp increase in supplementary retirement accounts is observed after the implementation of the program: the election rate more than tripled in a thirty-day period and doubled in a sixty-day period. The survey also highlights three key barriers and shows how they posed greater saving difficulties for young female and older male employees. The role of insufficient income is recognized. The planning aid points that very low amounts are needed to get started and open an account. (pages 209 - 236)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Robert L. Clark, Madeleine Ambrosio
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0009
[financial education program, Teachers Insurance, College Retirement Equities, financial education seminars, retirement income goals, retirement saving behavior, financial literacy]
This chapter, which describes a well-crafted financial education program implemented by Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association-College Retirement Equities Fund, also assesses the effect of financial education seminars on retirement income goals and retirement saving behavior. The results show that participants in financial education seminars respond to the knowledge and information gained by altering their retirement goals and changing their saving behavior. In response to the seminars, the proportion of participants who changed either of their retirement goals was relatively small. Women are more likely to change goals and behavior after the seminar. Female respondents had much lower account balances in their retirement plans than men. Financial education can cause workers to reconsider their retirement goals and alter their saving behavior. The lack of financial literacy has resulted in movements to automate the retirement saving process. (pages 237 - 256)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lewis Mandell
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0010
[high school, financial management, personal finance, financial literacy, education, parents, stock market game]
This chapter argues that high school students are sorely in need of financial knowledge. Students who took courses in financial management or personal finance did not do any better on financial literacy tests than students who did not take any such course. The chapter finds that financially literate high school seniors are disproportionately white, male, and the children of well-educated parents. Financial knowledge is linked to self-beneficial financial practices. A strong and monotonic relationship between financial literacy scores and parents' education is also observed. Differences in financial literacy seem to be more closely connected to race than to any other demographic variable. There is no evidence that common methods of parental involvement result in a significant improvement to the financial literacy of high school seniors. Those who have played a stock market game in class are 2 percentage points more likely to be financially literate. (pages 257 - 279)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Michael Sherraden, Ray Boshara
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0011
[financial education, monthly net deposits, saving, incentives, individual development accounts, policy development, financial services]
This chapter argues that financial education proves to be effective when several hours and sessions of financial education are offered. One to ten hours of education is positively linked with average monthly net deposits, but there is no discernable relationship after ten hours. Thus, the payoff in financial education may be only in the first ten hours. Incentives in an economic sense may not be the most important factor in increasing saving. Saving outcomes result from the interaction of individual and institutional characteristics. Research on individual development accounts had impacts on policy development. Positive effects of financial education may plateau at some point, while other factors may continue to be influential. Regarding practical application, financial education should not be a stand-alone, but should be embedded in other systems and financial services that can improve successful delivery, especially to those who may need it most. (pages 280 - 298)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

IV. Learning from the United States and Other Countries

- Olivia S. Mitchell, Petra E. Todd, David Bravo
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0012
[pension system, financial illiteracy, pension market, Chilean system, pension switching, Chile, cost savings]
This chapter investigates consumer knowledge about the pension system to determine whether financial illiteracy might account for the persistence of market frictions in the pension marketplace. It shows that only 69 percent of participants in the Chilean system indicate that they receive an annual statement summarizing past contributions and projecting future benefit amounts, while every participant is sent a statement. The chapter demonstrates that participant pension switching patterns did change after the reform of the pension market in Chile. The Chilean system did not regulate fund-to-fund switching. The average number of switches declined after 1997 by 0.12 per annum. Older people tend to have more accumulated in their pension funds, so switching would generally have greater implications for them in terms of potential cost savings. Furthermore, the change in regulatory rules on the marketing of Administradoras de fondos de Pensiones substantially suppresses the overall number of participant switches. (pages 301 - 323)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Annika Sundén
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0013
[information, education, Swedish pension reform, Premium Pension, Orange Envelope, National Social Insurance]
This chapter describes Swedish pension reform and the vital role that information and education have played both in its implementation and on an ongoing basis. Relying on self-reports of participants, it documents that half of participants rate their knowledge of pensions as poor. The Premium Pension constitutes a relatively small portion of the new system, and participation is mandatory. The Orange Envelope is the cornerstone of communication to participants about the pension system. The results reveal that among those who opened the envelope, about 70 percent looked at the benefit projection during the first years the envelope was sent out. The fact that participants in general overestimate the role of the Premium Pension could contribute to the overall anxiety. The challenge for the National Social Insurance Agency is to consider alternative ways of communicating with participants so that they have the tools they need to plan for retirement. (pages 324 - 344)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Barbara A. Smith, Fiona Stewart
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226497105.003.0014
[financial literacy, OECD, behavioral economics, financial education programs, pension, retirement]
This chapter describes the findings of financial literacy surveys in selected Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries and relevant studies in behavioral economics, examining their implications for the design and implementation of financial education programs. The evaluations of financial education programs are specifically addressed. Surveys across OECD countries reveal low levels of financial literacy across the board and of pension-related financial literacy specifically. The chapter also shows that individuals are not saving enough for retirement. The experience of the OECD's Financial Education Project has shown that insights into improving financial education programs can be observed in the responses to financial literacy surveys and in the research based on behavioral economics. The provision of financial education can benefit from the findings of both financial literacy surveys and behavioral economics research. (pages 345 - 368)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

List of Contributors

Author Index

Subject Index