Animal Intimacies
Interspecies Relatedness in India's Central Himalayas
by Radhika Govindrajan
University of Chicago Press, 2018
Cloth: 978-0-226-55984-1 | Paper: 978-0-226-55998-8 | Electronic: 978-0-226-56004-5
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS
ABOUT THIS BOOK
What does it mean to live and die in relation to other animals? Animal Intimacies posits this central question alongside the intimate—and intense—moments of care, kinship, violence, politics, indifference, and desire that occur between human and non-human animals.
Built on extensive ethnographic fieldwork in the mountain villages of India’s Central Himalayas, Radhika Govindrajan’s book explores the number of ways that human and animal interact to cultivate relationships as interconnected, related beings. Whether it is through the study of the affect and ethics of ritual animal sacrifice, analysis of the right-wing political project of cow-protection, or examination of villagers’ talk about bears who abduct women and have sex with them, Govindrajan illustrates that multispecies relatedness relies on both difference and ineffable affinity between animals. Animal Intimacies breaks substantial new ground in animal studies, and Govindrajan’s detailed portrait of the social, political and religious life of the region will be of interest to cultural anthropologists and scholars of South Asia as well.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Radhika Govindrajan is assistant professor of anthropology at the University of Washington.
REVIEWS
“Recommended. . .Animal Intimacies provides a fascinating ethnographic study on the social and emotional entanglements of humans and animals in the Kumaon region of the Himalayan state of Uttarakhand. . .Govindrajan’s ethnography reveals that the agency of animal subjects has significantly shaped the social relations, everyday ethical practices, and religious worldviews of the Pahari peoples of Uttarakhand. This text will appeal widely to students interested in human-animal relations and critical applications of posthumanist theories.”
— Choice
“Animal Intimacies vividly conveys the intense entanglement of interspecies relations in Kumaon, a Himalayan region in the state of Uttarakhand in northern India. . . . The result is a highly readable and vital contribution to the discipline that illuminates the key theoretical debates in multispecies ethnography.”
— American Ethnologist
“The antagonist hovering over Radhika Govindrajan's Animal Intimacies is not anthropocentrists, but rather those who kill and police humans in the animal's name. This attention to the political landscape, where violence articulates itself as from a place of love, is what makes her book so timely and important. Her close attention to the social, historical, and physical landscape of her fieldsite, Kumaon, which is part of India's state of Uttarakhand in the central Himalayas, and her ability to narrate the liveliness of these landscapes is what makes this book beautiful.”
— Asian Ethnology
“A compelling book. In bringing to light the relatedness of human and non-human lives, Govindrajan illustrates the richness of such interactions. . . . The richness of the book means that it will be of interest to readers in the field of human-animal studies. It should also appeal to readers more generally as an example of how lived experiences reflect wider social, political and historical patterns.”
— Contemporary South Asia
"A meticulously researched, thoughtfully argued, imaginatively organized, and beautifully written ethnographic monograph . . . Animal Intimacies is well on its way to becoming a classic text in anthropology, environmental studies, feminist science studies, animal studies, and South Asian studies."
— American Anthropologist
“Animal Intimacies is written in a beautiful style, and the scholarship is exemplary: both rigorous and creative. Govindrajan's exceptional ethnography demonstrates the range of relationships people in the central Himalayas of India have with animals—relationships that can be described, ultimately, as ones of everyday, entangled intimacy. By showing us the textures of these intimacies, Govindrajan demonstrates that animals are not mere objects in the lives and reflections of humans, but are thinking, feeling subjects themselves, playing equal parts in human-animal cohabitation.”
— Naisargi N. Dave, University of Toronto
“Written in a lively style combining reflexive reportage with anthropological analysis, Animal Intimacies vividly portrays the everyday life and social concerns of villagers in the hill state of Uttarakhand through their interactions with household domesticates and encounters with forest animals. Its chapter-by-chapter engagement with a succession of distinct interspecies relations makes for a memorable and innovative ethnography. Govindrajan's richly detailed account of human lives led with animals succeeds in addressing many contemporary issues confronting people in India’s hill-states, while also making a valuable contribution to the anthropology of human-animal relations.”
— Piers Locke, University of Canterbury
"Govindrajan’s scholarship brings attention to the more-than-human relationships that exist in everyday life in Kumaon, and contributes to feminist scholarship on kinship and relatedness. Consistent with the orientation of multispecies ethnography, this work treats animals as subjects with agency and emotion, while adding a critical dimension to its engagement with particular, individual animals, instead of only engaging with them as part of a collective or abstract category of animal."
— Pacific Affairs
"Radhika Govindrajan's Animal Intimacies contributes to a growing body of literature in the social sciences and humanities on human-animal relations. Govindrajan, an anthropologist, draws on fieldwork experiences with villagers and the animals with which they share their lives in the state of Uttarakhand in the Central Himalayas. . . The book's greatest strengths lie in the author's attention to embodied effective care practices between humans and other species and the close attention given to animals as complex and active subjects."
— Springer
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Introduction
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0001
[nonhuman;animals;connection;history;relatedness;Uttaraland;interspecies]
This introduction explains important subjects covered within the rest of the book. Primarily, this section of the book works to introduce and discuss the topic of relatedness. More specifically, the author is interested in exploring how knots of connection produce a sense of relatedness between human and nonhuman animals. The introduction also discusses the reasoning behind the term "relatedness" and the birth of the author's interest in the topic through fieldwork. Additionally, the introduction offers information on the author's fieldwork, such as history, location, methods.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
2/ The Goat Who Died for Family: Sacrificial Ethics and Kinship
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0002
[sacrifice;patriarchy and gender;kinship;ethics;care]
What is the nature of sacrificial connection between the one who sacrifices, the one who is sacrificed, and the one who accepts the sacrifice? Does sacrifice leave an imprint on everyday relationships that extends beyond the moment of killing? This chapter addresses these questions through an examination of increasingly controversial practices of ritual animal sacrifice, primarily of goats. The chapter argues that sacrificial relationships between villagers and sacrificial animals are characterized by practices of care, attention, and reciprocity that emerge through everyday, gendered forms of labor involved in raising animals who are eventually sacrificed. The affective intimacy that people feel for the sacrificial animals they raise compels them to offer ordinary and everyday gestures of love, care, and remorse that open up the possibility of ethical behavior in the interstices of violence.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
3/ The Cow Herself Has Changed: Hindu Nationalism, Cow Protection, and Bovine Materiality
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0003
[cow-protection;Hindu nationalism;materiality;ordinary ethics;popular Hinduism]
This chapter examines the effects of recent attempts by right-wing Hindu nationalists to forge, through legislative action as well as vigilante violence, a Hindu community and nation unified by the symbol of the mother cow. The chapter describes how villagers in the mountains viewed such attempts to impose kinship between them and cows at large as an act of coercion. However, such coercive framings of kinship did not go unchallenged; villagers responded to them by imagining alternate forms of relatedness that emphasized a common mountain identity over transcendental Hinduness as the grounds of connection between themselves and their cows. The chapter argues that these alternate forms of relatedness were based in the fact that the distinctive characteristics and tendencies of individual cows were incommensurate with the homogeneous metaphor of the mother cow.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
4/ Outsider Monkey, Insider Monkey: On the Politics of Exclusion and Belonging
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0004
[human-monkey conflict;invasive species;agrarian crisis;identity politics;land politics]
This chapter describes how, over the last decade, hundreds of monkeys captured in Delhi and small towns in Uttarakhand have been released into forests across this region to keep them out of contact with people. However, these monkeys are resolutely urban creatures accustomed to living with humans, and soon make their way to the nearest village in search of people and resources. The chapter recounts how the sharp rise in instances of monkey-human conflict has become an urgent social and political issue in Uttarakhand over the last decade. These anxieties about marauding monkeys who are not from the mountains speak volumes about the contemporary politics of belonging in this region. As mountain villagers are dispossessed of their land by outsiders from the plains and face growing unemployment, they relate their status to that of mountain monkeys who are, they argue, similarly driven off their homes by interlopers. What sets these conversations in the Central Himalayas apart from anxieties about invasive species elsewhere in the world, the chapter argues, is a recognition of these outsider monkeys as distinctive individuals within a species, with their own tendencies and desires that sets them apart from local, mountain monkeys.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
5/ Pig Gone Wild: Colonialism, Conservation, and the Otherwild
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0005
[conservation;wildness;caste;animality;domestication]
This chapter follows the story of an experimental pig who escaped from the IVRI, a livestock research institution established by the colonial state, in the 1960s and is said to have lived out the rest of her life in the adjoining forest. Many villagers believe that the runaway pig is an ancestor of the numerous wild boar who roam the forests in this region today. As such, they argue that contemporary conservation practices ignore the ways in which the entanglement of people's lives with wild pigs is the outcome of the distinctive history of an individual animal who linked people, animals, and institutions in unexpected ways. The chapter examines the ways in which the runaway pig's history of escape and subsequent rewilding reconfigures, unsettles, and exceeds the ways in which categories such as the "wild" and the "animal" buttress intersecting projects of colonial, caste, and species difference and power in the region.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
6/ The Bear Who Loved a Woman: The Intersection of Queer Desires
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0006
[bestiality;animal folklore;agency and resistance;queer desire;gender and patriarchy]
This chapter examines a genre of narratives about black bears who are believed to abduct and have sex with women. The transgressive desires celebrated by women in their accounts of these interspecies sexual encounters call into question not just patriarchal but also anthropocentric hierarchies in which the boundary between humans and nonhumans is drawn on the terrain of desire. What makes this talk about bear-human sex so compelling is the fact that women come to know and relate to these animals differently than men on account of the gendered division of labor involved in creating and sustaining interspecies relationships. The chapter argues that these narratives are attempts to imagine and enact alternate ways of dwelling and connecting in a world where one exists only in relation to a variety of human and nonhuman others.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Epilogue: Kukur aur bagh
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226560045.003.0007
[anthropocentrism;love;ethics;interspecies violence;Anthropocene]
This chapter uses the entanglements between dogs, leopards, and humans in the mountains as a point of entry into broader discussions on the nature of relatedness, love, ethics, and anthropocentrism.
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...