REVIEWS
“A stunning rebuke of conventional assumptions that describe our economic system as a robot-like machine. In this deeply intelligent and personally engaging book, Julie Nelson emphasizes the tremendous influence of ethics and emotions on economic outcomes. She challenges both the Left and the Right to think more creatively about the relationship between love and money. Everyone who studies care—or cares about social science—should read this book.”--Nancy Folbre, author of The Invisible Heart: Economics and Family Values
— Nancy Folbre
“Economics, as it is often taught today, portrays us as homo economicus—someone who doesn’t vote in presidential elections, doesn’t return lost wallets, and doesn’t leave tips when dining out of town. Julie Nelson reminds us that most people aren’t really like that. She helps point the way to a richer, more descriptive way of thinking about economic life.”--Robert H. Frank, author of Luxury Fever: Money and Happiness in an Era of Excess
— Robert H. Frank
“Julie Nelson cares. She cares enough about her home discipline, economics, to demand that it jettison the crippling assumption that the economy is a clockwork machine. She cares enough about people to insist that we recognize the full range of our economically valuable activities, from the unpaid provision of personal care to the ethical management of corporations. In this sparkling, passionate, personal book Nelson shows how to humanize economics without abandoning its commitment to rigorous description and explanation.”--Viviana A. Zelizer, author of The Purchase of Intimacy
— Vivianna Zelizer
"Clarity and brevity are her book's greatest strengths--almost unheard-of virtues when economics is the subject. . . . It's good to read about business and not feel dirty."
— John Allemang, Globe and Mail
"Nelson is insightful and makes good arguments to show why neoclassical machine metaphors do not hold for economics in reality. She passionately argues for reconnecting economics with ethics. . . . Her book is exceedingly accessible, clearly organized and well-written. She examines much within a slim 127 pages of main text, and Economics for Humans will stimulate all readers--knowledgeable in economics or not."
— Michelle Wenderlich, Intergenerational Justice Review
"This is a great, fun and interesting read, appropriate for college classrooms as well as a thoughtful gift for erudite friends and family. No prior experience in economics is necessary, and perhaps we would do well to ensure its incorporation in the standard economics education. The (human) world could only benefit from better economic science, after all."
— Elissa Braunstein, Eastern Economic Journal
""[Nelson's] market theories are marked and shaped by deliberate focus on marginalized people...Nelson's Economics for Humans calls for a reimagining of the market, replacing the long-standing 'machine' metaphor with the more personal 'beating heart.'...This book is also an excellent introduction to economics in general."
— Political Theology
"Economics for Humans is intended for a popular audience, and I highly recommend it to students and scholars in many fields, to professionals in the media (including political pundits), and to policy makers....[Nelson] offers not only critique, but vision. Social economists have long thought it possible to integrate the study of the economy with ethics and values, and it is unfortunate that the mainstream has not. Nelson's third way, a more pragmatic view of the economy, allows for policies to sustain the environment, to provide for paid family and medical leave, to prevent economic concentration and rely on more progressive taxation, to encourage social and corporate responsibility, for the benefit of real-world economics and the human race."
— Review of Social Economy
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments
Introduction - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0001
[economics, commerce, ethics, economic values, economic life]
Economics and commerce have traditionally been male-dominated realms, while women were traditionally assigned all the tasks of personal care for children and the ill and elderly within families. This book uses the term ethics as shorthand for both concern with moral decision making and concern with interpersonal, caring relationships. It reports the issue from the side of those who prioritize economics and downplay ethics. It looks at the issue from the side of those who prioritize ethics and condemn (or seek to isolate) what they think of as “economic values.” Moreover, some of the many distorted or simply untrue beliefs about the facts of economic life that arise from the mechanical notion are investigated. An overview of the chapters included in this book is given. (pages 1 - 8)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Tending the Body - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0002
[academic economics, historical roots, taxation, probusiness folks, capitalism, provisioning]
This chapter reviews the history of economics from its early concern with bodily provisioning. It tries to demonstrate that the metaphor of the mechanistic, amoral, clockwork economy has particular historical roots, and so to call into question the impression that it is a directly revealed truth. Economics came to be about provisioning and perhaps, secondarily, the taxation that provided the support for the ruling class. Then, it explains how the probusiness folks are likely to perceive their critics. The studies in academic economics are elaborated upon as well. Businesspeople often defend capitalism because they highly value provisioning, employment creation, self-reliance, and innovation. Some economists are now starting to believe the idea that a well-functioning market system might be something more than a machine driven by self-interest. Some are beginning to think that perhaps an economy needs to pay attention to ethical norms and social ties and create well-designed human institutions. (pages 9 - 26)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Tending the Soul - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0003
[sociology, philosophy, market critics, market-critic prescriptions, capitalist economy, separate spheres]
This chapter outlines the history of “critical” views in sociology and philosophy that developed in the early twentieth century. This history reveals that the view of market critics is based on the same eighteenth-century Smithian metaphor as the probusiness view. The critics of markets, corporations, or capitalism defend what they see as important dimensions of human life against what they call “economic” or “market” values. The market-critic prescriptions all agree that the capitalist economy is a machine. Advocates of a “separate spheres” prescription can find intellectual ammunition for their position in the work of this influential thinker. It is believed that the prescribed solutions lack when held up to criteria of realism and effectiveness. Sometimes these solutions could cause real damage. (pages 27 - 40)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Bringing Body and Soul Together - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0004
[social sciences, economics, ethics, metaphorical image, machine, Adam Smith, beating heart]
This chapter tries to illustrate that the cause of the failure of the social sciences to integrate adequately economics and ethics lies in their failure to question the metaphorical image of the economy as a machine. It elaborates how historical and psychological factors have given the metaphor unusual power. It also suggests that a vitalized metaphor that unites the provisioning and the ethical dimensions of economic life could be much more useful. Metaphors are basic to science. Adam Smith theorized a fabulous machine of self-interest-motivated production and exchange. The image of the economy as a beating heart brings together body and soul, and points toward action regarding the heartaches of poverty, hunger, injustice, empty consumerism, and ecological destruction. The economic life must be vital, caring, and responsible. “Business ethics” and “the economics of care” are not just options but requirements. (pages 41 - 62)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Love and Money? - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0005
[individual motivations, interpersonal relations, love, money, philosophy, social sciences, economics, selfishness]
This chapter investigates the issues of individual motivations and interpersonal relations. It also examines in more detail at the problems caused by the ungrounded ethics-only ideology. People who want to argue that money drives out care and concern can turn to parts of philosophy and the social sciences for apparent support. It is not money itself that “drives out” caring feelings, but rather the social meaning given to the particular movement of money. The relation of economics, money, and selfishness is reviewed. Even in the most obviously “economic” situations, people do not act out of solely financial interest. Even when money is playing a large role in economic behavior, this need not mean that a person is greedy. It has shown that love and money are not at odds within the context of individual motivations and small-scale interpersonal relations. (pages 63 - 86)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Business and Ethics? - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0006
[organizational profit making, ethical behavior, profit maximization, factual issues, for-profit businesses, corporations, government-run programs]
This chapter reviews the factual issues that arise at an organizational level. It argues that ethical behavior is neither intrinsically at odds with organizational profit making nor guaranteed by nonprofit goals. It specifically presents the definition of profits and factual issues related to business. The issue of how motivations are converted into action within organizations is explained. Moreover, the facts showing that the profit maximization is forced on corporations by law and by market pressures are evaluated. The view of businesses as social organizations goes so deeply against the grain of much popular thinking that further objections must be addressed. The for-profit businesses, as well as the nonprofits and government-run programs have to meet a budget. All sorts of organizations require an active attention to ethics and oversight from concerned outside groups. (pages 87 - 114)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Keeping Body and Soul Together - Julie A. Nelson
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226572055.003.0007
[body, soul, money, ethics, business management, care, economic machine, ethical decision making]
This chapter draws conclusions for the actions as citizens, workers, parents, employers, and shareholders. Bringing—and keeping—body and soul together is critically important for two hugely important areas of life. An aversion to thinking about money when the topic of discussion is care has resulted to a crisis of resources in the caring sectors of the economy. On the other hand, an aversion to thinking about ethics when the topic is business has led to a crisis of responsibility in commercial life. It is believed that it will be people on the ground, working in business management or doing the work of care, who will be most helpful in breaking down the petrified eighteenth-century image of the economic machine. Additionally, it is recognized that the health of living, vital economies depends on the ethical decision making and the willingness to support relationships of care and respect. (pages 115 - 128)
This chapter is available at:
https://academic.oup.com/chica...
Notes
Index