Quantum Legacies Dispatches from an Uncertain World
by David Kaiser, foreword by Alan Lightman
University of Chicago Press, 2024
Cloth: 978-0-226-69805-2 | Paper: 978-0-226-81999-0 | Electronic: 978-0-226-69819-9
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.001.0001

AVAILABLE FROM

University of Chicago Press (paper, ebook)
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

A series of engaging essays that explore iconic moments of discovery and debate in physicists’ ongoing quest to understand the quantum world.

The ideas at the root of quantum theory remain stubbornly, famously bizarre: a solid world reduced to puffs of probability; particles that tunnel through walls; cats suspended in zombielike states, neither alive nor dead; and twinned particles that share entangled fates. For more than a century, physicists have grappled with these conceptual uncertainties while enmeshed in the larger uncertainties of the social and political worlds around them, a time pocked by the rise of fascism, cataclysmic world wars, and a new nuclear age.
 
In Quantum Legacies, David Kaiser introduces readers to iconic episodes in physicists’ still-unfolding quest to understand space, time, and matter at their most fundamental. In a series of vibrant essays, Kaiser takes us inside moments of discovery and debate among the great minds of the era—Albert Einstein, Erwin Schrödinger, Stephen Hawking, and many more who have indelibly shaped our understanding of nature—as they have tried to make sense of a messy world.
 
Ranging across space and time, the episodes span the heady 1920s, the dark days of the 1930s, the turbulence of the Cold War, and the peculiar political realities that followed. In those eras as in our own, researchers’ ambition has often been to transcend the vagaries of here and now, to contribute lasting insights into how the world works that might reach beyond a given researcher’s limited view. In Quantum Legacies, Kaiser unveils the difficult and unsteady work required to forge some shared understanding between individuals and across generations, and in doing so, he illuminates the deep ties between scientific exploration and the human condition.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

David Kaiser is the Germeshausen Professor of the History of Science and professor of physics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. He is the author of several books, including How the Hippies Saved Physics: Science, Counterculture, and the Quantum Revival, and is coeditor of Groovy Science: Knowledge, Innovation, and American Counterculture, also published by the University of Chicago Press. His work has appeared in the New York Times and New Yorker and he is a frequent guest on NPR and in PBS NOVA documentaries.

REVIEWS

“A masterpiece of historical analysis. . . . Skillfully written and a pleasure to read.”
— Nature

"A work of coherence, accessibility, and rhetorical power not generally found in [these] volumes. . . . Kaiser has woven together a unique, compelling, and kaleidoscopic portrait of the quantum revolution and its implications. He doesn’t hide from the messiness of science but embraces the challenge of understanding its underlying human and social conditions."
— José G. Perillán, Physics Today

"Quantum Legacies does not disappoint. . . . It is a breath of fresh air to see physics writing like this: lucid and friendly, sober and thoughtful, and willing to trust the reader’s engagement and intelligence rather than demanding the former and underestimating the latter. . . .  Superb popular science. . . .  It is hard for me to imagine any physicist who wouldn’t enjoy the fine cloth from which it is cut, nor the pleasing effect it makes."
— Philip Ball, Physics World

“Engrossing. . . . Leave[s] us with a richer picture of physics as a lived activity.”
— Los Angeles Review of Books

"Most history books written for the wider public favor a narrower understanding of science. David Kaiser's work is a welcomed exception. . . . [He] gives a witty and insightful overview of the development of modern physics. . . . An engrossing read that will give specialists and nonspecialists alike a deeper understanding of how phenom­­ena as diverse as geopolitics and eastern mysticism have shaped physics in the past century."
— Science

"An ambitious collection of essays that merges [Kaiser's] two scholarly identities. . . . A wide-ranging anthology."
— Melinda Baldwin, Physics Today

"From Einstein to Heisenberg, Schrödinger to Hawking, Kaiser humanises the people and by extension their ideas, all the while making connections between the inner world of the academic quantum theory community and the outer world of global events. This sociopolitical standpoint is a key factor in making the technical science relevant to the non-expert reader. . . . In this collection of highly entertaining essays, he finds the perfect line between scientific scholarship and telling a good story."
— Engineering & Technology

"All together it paints a very compelling picture of how strategic decisions at the public policy level shaped the way physicists have gone about studying the universe. . . . It’s a good story well told."
— Forbes

"Captivating. . . . You can really get the sense of the quantum mechanical impact on various and disparate fields ranging from cosmology to the early foundations of quantum mechanics, the history of quantum mechanics, all the way up through popular culture, weaving its way through how physics pedagogy and even scientific STEM pedagogy is taught to this very day. . . . It's exhaustively researched and referenced. . . . I want people to buy every single copy."
— Brian Keating, Into the Impossible

"The book paints intimate portraits of some incredible luminaries . . . . Kaiser is an incredible ambassador for physics and its history."
— Matthew Jordan, New Books in Science, Technology, and Society

"Fantastically readable. Anybody interested in either science or history on a professional or a popular level should read it. It's a fantastic introduction to the way you can think about science in all sorts of different interdisciplinary, humanistic ways. It's really a huge amount of fun."
— Matthew Stanley, What the If?

"It's [Kaiser's] careful analysis of physics's sociological aspects that makes Quantum Legacies a delightful read. . . . This is the kind of material that you won't find in other books on the history and philosophy of physics."
— Ash Jogalekar, The Curious Wavefunction

"This interesting anthology on selected topics from the rich history of quantum mechanics, especially during its glory days, will engross any reader who has even a modest acquaintance with quantum theory."
— Choice, 2020 Outstanding Academic Title

"Full of striking statistics, commentary, and lovely analogies and metaphors. . . . These are engaging, though-provoking, fun-to-read essays that are compact enough that one can get through several in an evening. They will make you consider familiar physical concepts in new ways. All readers will come away richer in their knowledge of the people and circumstances behind how physics arrived at where it is. You will enjoy this book."
— American Journal of Physics

"The book not only gives an insight into the development of quantum theory and the lives of the scientists involved, it also explores the complexities of funding, political and sociological considerations, and the influence of the Cold War. . . . [It] provides useful background for physics educators and deserves a place in school science libraries."
— Physics Education

"Kaiser—writing in prose that sometimes soars, often intrigues, and always informs—gives us here a remarkable set of vignettes about major developments in physics and cosmology of the past century. His vignettes beautifully integrate science with human history and with insightful descriptions of outsized personalities. This book will be enjoyable and enlightening for a diverse readership: from complete novices in science, to students of science and history, and to professional scientists and historians."
— Kip Thorne, Richard P. Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics, California Institute of Technology, and 2017 Nobel Laureate in Physics

"Physicists are people! They have insecurities, love lives, monetary concerns, and political opinions, all while striving to uncover the fundamental workings of reality. Kaiser spins engaging tales that both explain fascinating aspects of physics in a lucid way and illuminate the human beings who worked to discover them."
— Sean Carroll, author of Something Deeply Hidden

"Have you ever wondered why Schrödinger chose such a morbid illustration of quantum physics as a half-dead cat? Want to know how an alleged Soviet spy escaped capture and went on to shake up particle physics? Can you guess what propelled The Tao of Physics to bestseller status? If questions like these spark your curiosity, this book is for you. I can imagine no better guide for an insider’s tour of twentieth-century physics than Kaiser. These witty vignettes beautifully illustrate what Kaiser calls the 'doubleness' of scientific research, its ability to bequeath enduring insights while reflecting the quirks and foibles of historical circumstances."
— Deborah R. Coen, author of Climate in Motion

"Explaining physics is easier than explaining physicists. In Quantum Legacies, Kaiser succeeds at both."
— George Dyson, author of Turing’s Cathedral

"What is extraordinary about Kaiser as a writer (and what makes his essays so much fun to read) is not only his ability to animate the range of personalities in these pages, from Einstein to Heisenberg, Schrödinger to Hawking, but also the way he brings the same humanizing impulse to their mind-bending ideas. His talent for uncovering connections between otherworldly ideas and the social and political worlds in which they take shape makes him a simply spellbinding guide to the mysteries of the universe."
— Nell Freudenberger, author of Lost and Wanted

"Kaiser is a master writer, and this is some of his finest work. An extraordinary combination of technical science, rich history, and telling anecdote, Quantum Legacies is cutting-edge scholarship rendered in a style equal to any popular science writing. When a non-academic asks me ‘what is the history of science?’ I will give them this book."
— Matthew Stanley, author of Einstein’s War: How Relativity Triumphed amid the Vicious Nationalism of World War I

"Friendships and rivalries, the demands of war, the limits of technology . . . these are among the rich universe of forces that conflict and conspire to bring us what we usually gloss over as the inevitable march of scientific progress. Kaiser’s book provides a wonderful glimpse behind the curtain into the messier—but far more human—truth of the matter. Beautifully written and extraordinarily well researched, the book makes a profound point about the sociopolitical nature of science that all readers—from physics buffs and historians to students and laypeople—need to hear."
— Amanda Gefter, author of Trespassing on Einstein’s Lawn

"An insightful and fascinating collection of important insights from the history of physics, which makes possible new perspectives and sheds light on surprising aspects of familiar topics."
— Physik Journal (translated from German)

TABLE OF CONTENTS


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0001
[scientific research;history of science;quantum theory]
This chapter introduces a main theme for the book, which focuses on a kind of doubleness of scientific research. In Einstein’s day much as in the present, researchers have aspired to create and test ideas that might transcend their immediate time and place; the goal has been to contribute lasting insights into how the world works that might reach beyond a given researcher’s limited view. Yet every scientist remains unavoidably embedded in a particular time and place, and those particularities can shape scientific research in many ways, from accidents of individual biography to changes in scientific institutions to larger shifts in politics and international relations.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0002
[Paul Dirac;quantum mechanics;scientific biography]
Many physicists contributed to the creation of quantum mechanics early in the twentieth century. This chapter examines some of the contributions by British physicist Paul Dirac, who refined many of the central ideas and invented most of the techniques that physicists still use to make calculations with the strange theory. Dirac’s meteoric rise in the field came despite his private struggles: a cold and authoritarian father, a grasping mother, and a beloved older brother who committed suicide just as Dirac began to focus on quantum theory. Dirac’s famous reticence and strict economy of expression shaped how generations of physicists have discussed the quantum world.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0003
[Erwin Schrödinger;Schrödinger's cat;superposition;quantum theory]
Among the strangest facets of quantum theory is the concept of “superposition,” which is often described in terms of Erwin Schrödinger’s famous fable about a cat that is neither alive nor dead. “Schrödinger’s cat” has become a standard-bearer for a host of puzzles in quantum physics, and is often described in a tone more zany than somber. Yet the setting in which Schrödinger conceived his parable was crucial for the form that it took. In the face of a looming world war, genocide, and the dismantling of German intellectual life, Schrödinger’s thoughts about quantum theory became intermingled with themes of poison, life-threatening uncertainty, and death.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0004
[neutrino;Bruno Pontecorvo;espionage;nuclear weapons;superposition]
Tiny elementary particles called “neutrinos” are fundamental to the construction of the universe. They are tremendously abundant, outnumbering atoms by about a billion to one. They play critical roles in dramatic physical processes, like the reactions that cause massive stars to explode as supernova, and their properties provide clues about the laws that govern particle physics. Although the particles might appear to be rather abstract and removed from everyday affairs, the ways that physicists learned about them were deeply enmeshed with new features of the nuclear age. The first efforts to detect the particles imagined setting up detectors beneath exploding nuclear bombs, while one of the physicists who contributed key insights into the particles’ strange behavior, Bruno Pontecorvo, secretly emigrated to the Soviet Union in 1950, triggering a panic in the United States and Great Britain about possible atomic espionage. More recently, the author and several colleagues used data from experiments on certain properties of neutrinos to test one of the central tenets of quantum theory, namely, that quantum objects can exist in a superposition state, much as in the story of Schrödinger’s cat, and that such superpositions can persist as the particles travel hundreds of miles.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0005
[quantum entanglement;Albert Einstein;John Bell;Cosmic Bell experiment]
Among the many concerns that Albert Einstein and Erwin Schrödinger shared about quantum mechanics, one of their most significant centered on what Schrödinger dubbed “entanglement.” In certain situations, the equations of quantum theory implied that the behavior of one subatomic particle would be bound up with another’s, even if the second particle was arbitrarily far away. Einstein famously dismissed the idea as “spooky action at a distance,” but proponents of quantum theory insisted that such phenomena could really occur in nature. In the 1960s physicist John Bell introduced a new type of test on pairs of particles that could distinguish between predictions of quantum theory and ideas more like Einstein’s and Schrödinger’s. This chapter describes Bell’s main idea and describes recent “Cosmic Bell” experiments, developed and conducted by the author and collaborators, which use some of the oldest light in the cosmos to address one of the most stubborn “loopholes” in previous experimental tests of Bell’s idea. Strange as the idea of quantum entanglement may seem, the latest experiments provide dramatic evidence that —despite Einstein’s objections —entanglement is real.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0006
[Second World War;Manhattan Project;nuclear weapons;education;military draft]
The Second World War involved an unprecedented mobilization of scientists and engineers, and proved to be a turning point in the relationship between science, technology, and the state. The drama with which the war ended, marked by the use of nuclear weapons against the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, cemented the association of the Second World War as “the physicists’ war.” Yet the term originally had nothing to do with secret efforts like the Manhattan Project, and had been introduced as early as November 1941. The term originally referred to a massive, urgent educational mission: to teach elementary physics to as many soldiers as possible, since the modern battlefield required rudimentary knowledge of optics and acoustics, radio and circuits —all classic parts of the physics curriculum, far removed from esoteric topics like nuclear fission. Only after the new nuclear weapons had been used, in August 1945, did the association of the term “physicists’ war” shift from blackboards to bombs. It then became emblematic of an urgent postwar policy of training many more professional physicists, to be available for future military projects.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0007
[John von Neumann;electronic computer;Institute for Advanced Study;nuclear weapons]
John von Neumann led an effort soon after the end of the Second World War to design improved electronic computers that could execute stored programs. Although ideas for such machines dated back to the 1930s and prototypes had been built by other groups, von Neumann’s ambitious team aimed to build a larger, more advanced, and more robust design at the Institute for Advanced Study in Princeton, New Jersey. Funded largely by contracts from the Atomic Energy Commission, the postwar successor to the Manhattan Project, von Neumann’s team directed their efforts primarily toward simulating designs for new types of nuclear weapons; to provide cover for the classified projects, they also worked on weather prediction and simulations of biological evolution. The large engineering effort, and the focus on military applications, contrasted with the Institute’s traditional focus on solitary scholars poring over dense tomes. By the late 1950s, other research centers, also mostly funded by defense agencies, had made progress on replicas of von Neumann’s design, helping to usher in the new computer age.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0008
[Cold War;education;scientific manpower]
During the early years of the Cold War, many educators and policymakers in the United States grew concerned about Soviet advances in training young physicists, and feared that the technical workforce of scientists and engineers within the United States was insufficient to meet the new defense needs. Widespread fears that the Soviet Union had surpassed the United States in training large cadres of physical scientists drove a massive escalation in American efforts to train more specialists. Catalyzed by new federal fellowships and related spending, graduate enrollments in US physics departments grew at a faster rate than in any other field. Yet the runaway growth proved unsustainable, and by the early 1970s, funding, enrollments, and job opportunities for young physicists in the United States had collapsed. This chapter examines a series of reports from the 1950s and early 1960s on Soviet efforts to train scientists and engineers. It focuses on the ways in which the patterns identified in the reports were taken out of context and subjected to hype, which in turn helped to drive new policies and funding patterns within the United States, ultimately yielding a speculative bubble in physics enrollments.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0009
[quantum mechanics;J. Robert Oppenheimer;David Bohm;Leonard Schiff;textbooks]
During the 1930s, leading physicists in the United States who were among the first to begin teaching quantum mechanics tended to emphasize philosophical challenges and open questions regarding how best to make sense of the equations. Soon after the war, however, as more physics departments across the country began to offer courses in quantum mechanics, the style of instruction began to shift. Few instructors during the 1950s lingered over how best to interpret the uncertainty principle or the place of probabilities in the quantum-mechanical formalism. The pedagogical shift was driven, in large measure, by rapid changes in enrollments: as physicists’ classrooms bulged as never before after the Second World War, more and more instructors chose to focus their classroom material on calculation rather than interpretation. Yet the balance began to shift again in the 1970s, after physics enrollments crashed.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0010
[Fritjof Capra;New Age;Eastern mysticism;quantum theory;textbooks]
In 1975 physicist Fritjof Capra published a curious little book entitledThe Tao of Physics, in which he argued that modern physics had recaptured the age-old wisdom of Eastern mystics. The book became a break-out publishing sensation; for a generation of countercultural seekers, the book promised a union of Western science and New Age enthusiasms. Yet Capra had begun working on his book as a more traditional textbook on quantum physics, and only later incorporated material about Eastern spiritual traditions, inspired by his extracurricular reading while a postdoc in Santa Cruz, California. What had begun as a textbook and became a bestselling popular book was eventually picked up for classroom use, after all, by physicists who were eager to try to attract students back to physics classrooms, and for whom few other pedagogical materials on certain topics, such as the interpretation of quantum mechanics, had yet been published.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0011
[particle accelerators;Superconducting Supercollider;Large Hadron Collider;CERN;Cold War]
Soon after the end of the Second World War, the United States government had invested heavily in new facilities and instrumentation for high-energy physics, underwriting the construction of ever-larger particle accelerators. Although the instruments had little connection to military projects, government officials often justified the expense in terms of military preparedness: building the new facilities would enable large numbers of physicists and their students to remain well-trained and at the ready, should the Cold War ever turn hot. When political realities changed, driven first by detente between the United States and Soviet Union, and later by the collapse of the Soviet Union altogether, the arguments to fund such massive scientific projects no longer seemed convincing, and budgets fell sharply. One of the more dramatic of these reversals led to the cancellation of the Superconducting Supercollider in 1993, after several billion dollars had already been spent to begin construction. Meanwhile, the multinational collaboration in Europe, which has supported the huge CERN laboratory, proved more adaptable to the political calculations of a post-Soviet world.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0012
[particle physics;nuclear forces;quarks;symmetry]
During the 1970s and 1980s, several physicists pieced together what is now known as the “Standard Model” of particle physics. The Standard Model describes the forces and interactions among all the known sub-atomic particles, from quarks and electrons to their most exotic cousins, which are detected only in carefully controlled experiments. Predictions from the Standard Model have provided an exquisite match to measurements in high-precision experiments for decades. For all its successes, however, physicists agree that the Standard Model is not complete: it is riddled with what appear to be arbitrary constants, and leaves out the effects of gravity altogether, which, on cosmic scales, is by far the most important force of all. Efforts to construct the Standard Model, and to find some more complete extension, have tended to focus on mathematical symmetries, leading to a counterintuitive account of why ordinary objects have mass.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0013
[Higgs boson;particle physics;Peter Higgs;Large Hadron Collider]
For nearly half a century, particle physicists sought experimental evidence that might confirm the existence of a hypothetical particle, which had been dubbed the “Higgs boson.” During the mid-1960s, physicist Peter Higgs and several others recognized that if a certain type of new elementary particle existed in nature, and interacted in specific ways with other forms of matter, then those interactions might explain the origin of mass. The strategy to find evidence of Higgs particles seemed straightforward enough: smash other sub-atomic particles like protons together at such high speeds that Higgs particles (along with many other types of matter) would coagulate from the residual energy of the collision. Because the Higgs particle was expected to decay very quickly, evidence for the particle would have to come by shifting through the decay products, to distinguish signs of a long-since-vanished Higgs particle amid all the other particles that stream away from the collision region in a particle accelerator. In July 2012, two large groups of experimentalists announced that their teams had each accumulated sufficiently large numbers of examples of such fleeting interactions to conclude with confidence that the Higgs boson at last had been detected.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0014
[particle cosmology;Jeffrey Goldstone;Peter Higgs;Carl Brans;Robert Dicke;Mach's principle;symmetry breaking]
Particle cosmology, a subfield of physics that investigates the smallest units of matter and their role in determining the shape and fate of the entire universe, is a flourishing field these days, with growing numbers of researchers and state-of-the-art telescopes on the ground and in space. The field’s dramatic success is all the more striking given that it barely existed forty years ago. As this chapter discusses, the field emerged from a period of crisis in physics, when sharp budget cuts and changing curricular priorities helped to push certain questions to the research frontier, even as other research programs faltered. These dynamics can be traced by following developments in the specialties of gravitational physics and particle physics, as researchers in each camp sought to understand why it is that objects have mass.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0015
[Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence;nuclear weapons;Cold War;Drake equation;SETI]
The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence (SETI) began in the late 1950s. From the start, scientists have made arguments about what to expect of alien civilizations by extrapolating from human examples. Since Earth-bound scientists had recently learned about the frequencies of certain naturally occurring processes in atoms and molecules, for example, early SETI researchers assumed that any alien species that might wish to make contact would exploit similar knowledge when selecting frequencies on which to broadcast a signal. As Cold War tensions rose, some SETI specialists imagined alien civilizations as benign elders whose wisdom might counter belligerent impulses on Earth; others feared that the odds of making contact with extraterrestrials would be limited by a seemingly inevitable tendency among advanced civilizations toward all-out nuclear war. Even as SETI researchers dreamed of other worlds, their imaginations were rooted in Cold War realities.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0016
[gravitation;Charles Misner;Kip Thorne;John Wheeler;textbooks;general relativity]
In 1973, three prominent experts on Einstein’s general theory of relativity published a massive textbook entitled Gravitation. Charles Misner, Kip Thorne, and John Wheeler aimed to expand the genre of the scientific textbook, constructing a looping, nonlinear structure for the book and incorporating additional material in special boxed sections. Though the authors had clearly conceived of their project as a textbook aimed at PhD students from the start, the publishers had difficulty categorizing the book, first considering it a reference monograph for libraries, then marketing it as a popular book for nonspecialists. Remarkably, growing numbers of readers who had little formal training in physics purchased the graduate-level book, finding inspiration in its unusual design and often lyrical descriptions of warping spacetime.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0017
[cosmology;big bang;Cold War;creationism;intelligent design]
Soon after completing his new theory of gravity, Albert Einstein began to apply his framework to models of the universe as a whole. To Einstein’s mind, a universe that had no beginning in time and which would persist forever, more or less unchanged, seemed most compelling. Yet other physicists quickly found that Einstein’s own equations suggested different cosmic fates: universes that began some finite time ago and changed dramatically over time. Einstein and some of his colleagues cautioned that such “big bang” cosmologies fit too neatly with the Biblical account in the book of Genesis, and that scientists should exercise special caution lest theological preferences color their scientific judgment. Research on the big bang changed quite a bit after the Second World War, when a new generation began to incorporate knowledge about nuclear interactions—drawing in part on data and experience from the wartime Manhattan Project—to study physical processes that might have unfolded early in cosmic history, under conditions radically different than those of the present day. Soon after the end of the Cold War, physicists’ cosmic theorizing collided with resurgent creationism, exposing a new rift in who has authority to pronounce upon cosmic evolution.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0018
[cosmology;supernovae;cosmic microwave background radiation;Hubble telescope;Roger Penrose]
For most of the twentieth century, physicists, astronomers, and cosmologists had little reliable data with which to refine their models of the cosmos. Cosmology became a high-precision science only recently, with the advent of satellite-borne detectors and sophisticated arrays of ground-based telescopes. Yet the surfeit of new data has hardly turned the field into a boring exercise in accounting. New and highly speculative ideas, springing from efforts to unite quantum theory with general relativity, have inspired bizarre-sounding scenarios that stretch well beyond the big bang model. Even proponents of the latest theoretical flights, however, now aim to extract features of their models to compare with data-rich observations.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0019
[gravitational waves;LIGO;Kip Thorne;Rainer Weiss;science funding]
Early in the morning of September 14, 2015, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory (LIGO) detected waves from a faraway cosmic collision: about a billion years earlier, two black holes had collided, roiling the surrounding spacetime and sending gravitational waves streaming out in every direction at the speed of light. The LIGO discovery was a long time in the making, in human terms as well as astronomical ones. Albert Einstein had first predicted such waves early in the twentieth century, though Einstein himself and most of the world’s experts on gravitation spent decades debating whether gravitational waves could actually exist. During the 1960s and early 1970s, various physicists proposed competing experimental methods to try to measure such hypothetical waves, at a time when few experts paid much attention to the subject. After a long struggle, proponents of the LIGO scheme convinced government funders to invest in their experiment. Long before the detection of gravitational waves, that investment had begun to pay off, spawning hundreds of dissertations and helping to train large numbers of dedicated young scientists and engineers.


DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226698199.003.0020
[Stephen Hawking;black holes;singularity;quantum gravity]
Physicist Stephen Hawking toiled for decades to find some way to combine quantum theory with general relativity, aiming to unite the physics of the large and small. In the process he derived the notion that black holes should glow, a process now known as “Hawking radiation.” He also became a celebrity scientist and bestselling author, nearly as well known as Albert Einstein. His dramatic struggles with a degenerative disease, which ultimately left him wheelchair-bound and unable to speak without a computerized voice synthesizer, added to his aura as an otherworldly genius, literally lost in thought. His insights into physics at the extremes and his own remarkable tenacity helped to inspire generations of people to ask big questions about the universe.