Creating Mental Illness
by Allan V. Horwitz
University of Chicago Press, 2001
Cloth: 978-0-226-35381-4 | Paper: 978-0-226-35382-1 | Electronic: 978-0-226-76589-1
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226765891.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

In this surprising book, Allan V. Horwitz argues that our current conceptions of mental illness as a disease fit only a small number of serious psychological conditions and that most conditions currently regarded as mental illness are cultural constructions, normal reactions to stressful social circumstances, or simply forms of deviant behavior.

"Thought-provoking and important. . .Drawing on and consolidating the ideas of a range of authors, Horwitz challenges the existing use of the term mental illness and the psychiatric ideas and practices on which this usage is based. . . . Horwitz enters this controversial territory with confidence, conviction, and clarity."—Joan Busfield, American Journal of Sociology

"Horwitz properly identifies the financial incentives that urge therapists and drug companies to proliferate psychiatric diagnostic categories. He correctly identifies the stranglehold that psychiatric diagnosis has on research funding in mental health. Above all, he provides a sorely needed counterpoint to the most strident advocates of disease-model psychiatry."—Mark Sullivan, Journal of the American Medical Association

"Horwitz makes at least two major contributions to our understanding of mental disorders. First, he eloquently draws on evidence from the biological and social sciences to create a balanced, integrative approach to the study of mental disorders. Second, in accomplishing the first contribution, he provides a fascinating history of the study and treatment of mental disorders. . . from early asylum work to the rise of modern biological psychiatry."—Debra Umberson, Quarterly Review of Biology

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Allan V. Horwitz is a professor in the Department of Sociology and Institute for Health, Health Care Policy, and Aging Research at Rutgers University.

REVIEWS

“[Horwitz] properly identifies the financial incentives that urge therapists and drug companies to proliferate psychiatric diagnostic categories. He correctly identifies the stranglehold that psychiatric diagnosis has on research funding in mental health. Above all, he provides a sorely needed counterpoint to the most strident advocates of disease-model psychiatry.”
— Mark Sullivan, Journal of the American Medical Association

"This is a must-read book. . . . The content is superb. It is filled with insights into the social, historical, and economic forces responsible for the overmedicalization of human unhappiness and distress."
— George Graham, Metapsychology

"A cogent and thought-provoking book. It deserves to be read widely and thoroughly, and not only by the already converted. In an ideal world it would be compulsory reading for mental health professionals in training."
— Nick Haslam, Transcultural Psychiatry

“Horwitz analyzes the social history of the dynamic, diagnostic, and social constructionist frameworks with enormous historical detail. He crafts fascinating arguments regarding how each framework was conceptualized, sold, measured, and the social impact that it left in its wake. . . . A fascinating, meticulously researched social history that will appeal to a wide range of academic audiences.”
— Diane Hamilton, Nursing History Review

“Horwitz makes at least two major contributions to our understanding of mental disorders. First, he eloquently draws on evidence from the biological and social sciences to create a balanced, integrative approach to the study of mental disorders. Second, in accomplishing the first contribution, he provides fascinating history of the study and treatment of mental disorders . . . from early asylum work to the rise of modern biological psychiatry.”
— Debra Umberson, Quarterly Review of Biology

“A fascinating and scholarly critique of our classification of mental disorders.”
— Lynn E. O’Connor, Human Nature Review

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Preface

Introduction: The Proliferation of Mental Illnesses

One: A Concept of Mental Disorder

Two: The Expansion of Mental Illnesses in Dynamic Psychiatry

Three: The Emergence of Diagnostic Psychiatry

Four: The Extension of Mental Illnesses into the Community

Five: The Structuring of Mental Disorders

Six: The Biological Foundations of Diagnostic Psychiatry

Seven: Social Causes of Distress

Eight: Diagnostic Psychiatry and Therapy

Conclusion: Mental Illnesses as Social Constructions

Notes

References

Index