Making Constituencies Representation as Mobilization in Mass Democracy
by Lisa Jane Disch
University of Chicago Press, 2021
Cloth: 978-0-226-80433-0 | Paper: 978-0-226-80450-7 | Electronic: 978-0-226-80447-7
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.001.0001
ABOUT THIS BOOKAUTHOR BIOGRAPHYREVIEWSTABLE OF CONTENTS

ABOUT THIS BOOK

Public division is not new; in fact, it is the lifeblood of politics, and political representatives have constructed divisions throughout history to mobilize constituencies.

Since the turn of the twenty-first century, the idea of a divided United States has become commonplace. In the wake of the 2020 election, some commentators warned that the American public was the most divided it has been since the Civil War. Political scientists, political theorists, and public intellectuals have suggested that uninformed, misinformed, and disinformed voters are at the root of this division. Some are simply unwilling to accept facts or science, which makes them easy targets for elite manipulation. It also creates a grass-roots political culture that discourages cross-partisan collaboration in Washington.
 
Yet, manipulation of voters is not as grave a threat to democracy in America as many scholars and pundits make it out to be. The greater threat comes from a picture that partisans use to rally their supporters: that of an America sorted into opposing camps so deeply rooted that they cannot be shaken loose and remade. Making Constituencies proposes a new theory of representation as mobilization to argue that divisions like these are not inherent in society, but created, and political representatives of all kinds forge and deploy them to cultivate constituencies.

AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY

Lisa Jane Disch is professor of political science at the University of Michigan. She has published four books. Most recently, she coedited The Oxford Handbook of Feminist Theory and The Constructivist Turn in Political Representation.

REVIEWS


"Making Constituencies is about questions that are both timeless and very recent. Disch’s concern for who comes first, the representative or the represented, is at least as old as the French Revolution. As she states towards the end of the book, 1789 is a watershed for the history of representative democracy and for theorists reflecting on the possibilities and limits of representation as a tool of modern politics... In arguing that competence ought not to be the measure against which to evaluate the health of contemporary democratic politics, Disch convincingly deflates common concerns for voters’ manipulation and the elitist and pessimistic attitudes that come with them."
— The Review of Politics

TABLE OF CONTENTS

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0001
[responsiveness;mobilization;constructivism;political representation;citizen competence;plurality;sorting]
Few of us believe that today’s democracies conform to the classic model of interest representation or live up to the standard of responsiveness it sets. However, even if it does not describe how our system of representation works in practice, many of us use the term responsiveness to describe how we believe it should work. Here, I untangle how this catchword, responsiveness, describes neither how democratic representation should work, how it does work, nor how it lets us down. On the contrary, the model of interest-first representation and the belief in responsiveness as its measure of success create expectations about citizen competence and stoke fears of manipulation that set mass democracy up to fail.Rather than debate whether voters can be trusted with democracy, this book aims to dislodge the hold of the competence model over democratic debate. I argue that voter incompetence and susceptibility to manipulation are not as grave a threat to democracy in America as many scholars and pundits make them out to be. The greater threat comes from a picture that partisans use to rally their supporters: that of an America sorted into opposing camps so deeply rooted that they cannot be shaken loose and remade. (pages 1 - 17)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0002
[mobilization;constituency effects;civic effects;targeting;political representation]
I turn first to mobilization, a term of art in every subfield of political science, which I reclaim from its commonplace uses. Mobilization as I use the term casts off this most basic intuition of both pluralist and participatory theories of democracy: that groups form around shared interests to demand laws and policies that serve those interests. I argue in this chapter that mobilization creates constituencies. I support this claim by drawing on the work of policy-feedback scholarship which I argue has demonstrated—at least in the field of social-welfare policy—that groups are typically not initiators of public policy but constituency effects of acts of political representation. (pages 18 - 33)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0003
[constituency paradox;bedrock norm;Hanna Pitkin;constructivist turn;Jane Mansbridge;Michael Saward]
Chapter 2 introduces the term constituency paradox to reevaluate interest representation, the predominant empirical model of democratic representation, which imagines that people form and fix their preferences prior to engaging with political institutions and political campaigns. So long as preferences satisfy this bedrock norm, researchers can safely rely on responsiveness as an indicator that political representation is working as it should. Research into preference formation runs counter to this model. Rather than form preferences prior to acts of representation, people shape their interests and demands in response to political communication that occurs over the course of the representative process. This is the constituency paradox: political representation, if it is to be democratic, must posit as a starting place constituencies and interests that take shape by its means. This chapter traces the effects of that paradox on prominent theorists of political representation, beginning with Hanna Pitkin, whose work set the template for a pedagogical model of democratic representation that incites concerns about manipulation. (pages 34 - 50)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0004
[political competence;Katherine Cramer;Suzanne Mettler;constituency effects;democratic competence;realism]
In chapter 3, I take up influential works by self-proclaimed realist social scientists and journalist-ethnographers of white grievance that paint a dark picture of the political competence of mass electorates. Aiming to change the terms of this competence debate, I draw on work by Katherine Cramer and Suzanne Mettler to reframe incompetence as not a failure of citizens but a constituency effect, both of elite political communications and of public policy expressly structured by legislators to hide the role that government plays in funding significant benefit programs. Those who give up on mass electorates in the name of realism pit democracy and realism against one another in a zero-sum choice. (pages 51 - 70)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0005
[democratic realism;Elmer Eric Schattschneider;political competence;democratic competence;conflict system]
Building on previous chapter, Iaim to change the terms of the competence debate, first by offering a rival empirical account and then by challenging the tendency to equate realism with pessimism about mass electorates.Chapter 4 enlists the work of E. E. Schattschneider to present a rival realism that refuses this choice of realism or democracy by shifting the critical focus from human behavior to the organizational biases that condition it. In this way, I argue that democratic realism calls critics to worry less about manipulation than about sorting. (pages 71 - 89)
This chapter is available at:
    University Press Scholarship Online

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0006
[Robert Goodin;manipulation;sorting;mass democracy]
I devote chapter 5 to the problem of manipulation, which—in contrast to the competence problem, used as a weapon by democratic skeptics— captivates critics who style themselves advocates for mass democracy. Reading the work of political philosopher Robert Goodin in conjunction with contemporary empirical studies of presidential polling and issue framing, I argue that manipulation as it is commonly understood poses little threat to democracy. Sure, politicians lie, and propaganda does its best to drown out fact. Goodin argues that such strategic speech is neither so long-lasting in its effects nor so monopolized by the powerful that it cannot be countered. He anticipates contemporary empirical scholarship by redirecting attention away from the epistemic quality of individuals’ beliefs and onto the systematic conditions that affect the formation of public opinion and political judgment. Goodin’s work suggests that a sorted political context, which minimizes people’s exposure and openness to competitive political discourse, does more damage to democracy than manipulation. (pages 90 - 106)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0007
[Claude Lefort;pluralism;plurality]
Chapter6 (and the one that follows)provides the theoretical justification for the intuition that links the arguments of these various chapters together: that democratic political representation urgently requires plurality as its enabling condition. In this chapter, I build the architecture for this claim fromthe political theory of Claude Lefort, who was the first to name indeterminacy—the irreducibility of political divisions to (putatively) given social differences—as the democratic legacy of the French Revolution. (pages 107 - 121)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0008
[Ernesto Laclau;Chantal Mouffe;pluralism;plurality;Hegemony and Socialist Strategy]
Chapter 7 features the work of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe, the first political theorists to make a constructivist turn in the name of democratic political representation. In Hegemony and Socialist Strategy, they defend a constructivist account of representation that prioritizes a concern with preserving plurality over a preoccupation with detecting and disarming manipulation. Their classic work provides an important resource for theorists of democracy today who are pressed to respond to critics aligning constructivism with elitism, and defining “manipulation” as a central threat to democracy in mass societies. (pages 122 - 136)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...

- Lisa Jane Disch
DOI: 10.7208/chicago/9780226804477.003.0009
[democratic realism;plurality;representative democracy;political representation;constituency]
The concluding chapter maintains what has been argued throughout the book: that manipulation poses a less significant threat to democracy than sorting.This claim, implausible as it must sound to those who remain preoccupied by citizen competence, makes sense from a radical democratic vantage point. Radical democracy counts plurality as the enabling condition of representative democracy, when representation is understood in constructivist terms as a constituency-making practice.This conception of pluralitymeans that political constituencies ought not to be deducible or predictable or containable by given calculations of interest. Where plurality exists, acts of political representation articulate interests, make subjects, and create unprecedented alliances. In the US, unprecedented alliancesare not mangled versions of the American Dream but products of exclusions and entitlements that are built into its basic premises. My realism counsels me that the democrat’s job is not to denounce any of democracy’s creatures but to take part in mobilizing counterforces against the ones I oppose. (pages 137 - 140)
This chapter is available at:
    https://academic.oup.com/chica...