"A Close, Dazzling Look at Michelangelo’s painting"
— Hyperallergic
"This second volume of Steinberg's selected essays treats readers to the late scholar’s masterly prose and scholarship, this time focusing on Michelangelo’s paintings. Schwartz is an expert, and her editing of these 11 essays is judicious. . . . With excellent production values and nicely illustrated throughout, this book continues to whet one’s appetite for future volumes. . . . Highly recommended.
— CHOICE
"It is gratifying to see the text now supported by the sort of photographs it deserves. The editor Sheila Schwartz, Steinberg’s longtime assistant and now curator of his literary legacy, also augments the text with evidence that Steinberg continued to accumulate for the rest of his life. No less importantly, Schwartz’s collection, the second in a series of five planned volumes of Steinberg’s essays, enables one to see that Steinberg’s account of the Pauline Chapel was embedded in a larger and continuously shifting account of Michelangelo’s painting. . . . The flourishing scholarly interest in [Steinberg's] legacy starts from a conviction that he is a model worth following. Beyond the encomia that appeared after Steinberg’s death in 2011, his findings and method continue to be discussed by students of art, philosophy, and aesthetics."
— Storia della Critica d’Arte, Annuario della S.I.S.C.A.
“Sheila Schwartz, an art historian who worked closely with Steinberg, has edited these essays with a discernment that’s matched by the elegance of the volumes, which are among the most beautifully produced art books of recent years.”
— New York Review of Books
"Steinburg prompts us to think about and see Michelangelo in new ways and enriches our understanding of him—a poetic artist and an artistic poet—and of Renaissance art and life. This book is as accomplished and scholarly as it is gorgeous."
— Renaissance and Reformation