"Hochstadt argues persuasively that assumptions about migration patterns are at the core of important interpretive concepts in modern history such as urbanization, industrialization, and proletarianization. . . . The book must be read from cover to cover to mine the wealth of details, wide-ranging analyses, and extraordinary scholarship that are at the heart of this impressive sociodemographic study."
--Jean Quataert, American Historical Review, October 2001
— Jean Quataert, American Historical Review
"His work will require a fundamental rethinking of German social history and should ultimately result in a more complex categorization that can capture the slow demographic and social transformation from peasant to urban worker. This work will become a classic in the field of mobility studies."
--D. J. Dietrich, Boston College, Choice, January 2000
— D. J. Dietrich, Boston College, Choice
". . . an excellent piece of scholarship . . . which, inter alia, pioneers the study of outmigration, establishes the temporary nature of most migration, limits the contribution of migration to urban growth and highlights the extent of mobility in the agricultural sector."
--John Perkins, University of New South Wales, German History, Volume 18, No. 4 (2000)
— John Perkins, University of New South Wales, German History
"Hochstadt marshals impressive evidence to support his claim. . . vigorous and stimulating in his defense of the importance of the migration in social history. . . .Hochstadt has written a valuable work that should be read and pondered both by specialists in the history of Germany and of migration."
--William H. Hubbard, German Politics and Society, Volume 19, No. 2
— William H. Hubbard, German Politics and Society
"[Hochstadt] contributes to the ongoing revision of the pervasively held image that pre-industrial, peasant societies were sedentary, static, hidebound--in a word, Karl Marx's 'potatoes in a sack.' At every turn, Hochstadt challenges conventional wisdom. . . . This is an important work of scholarship that should be of value to anyone concerned with the nature of either 'mobility' or 'modernity.'"
--John Torpey, University of British Columbia , Journal of Interdisciplinary History, Autumn 2000
— John Torpey, University of British Columbia, Journal of Interdisciplinary History
"Hochstadt has written what will long remain the definitive work on German urban migration and population turnover. . . . His work has important implications for scholars far beyond this narrow genre, indeed, for social history in general."
--Walter D. Kamphoefner, Journal of Social History, Summer 2001
— Walter D. Kamphoefner, Journal of Social History