“O’Sullivan reminds us that the Beatles were already taken seriously, not by media but by fans. … Sibbie O’Sullivan didn’t scream, but the power of her writing stems from how seriously she takes the people who may have.…Beyond the initial joy of public sexuality, O’Sullivan centers the fan as someone who, though she has no claim to the public, experiences life just as much as the artist and who makes sense of that life with the tools furnished by public art.”
—M. Delmonico Connelly, Full Stop
"An intimate, fun, charming, witty and, mostly, quick read. [O'Sullivan] beautifully emblazons her fandom, wearing it with pride. Her description of being a fan is one that is relatable and reminds one that moments of meaning made from life events [...] are indelible. My Private Lennon will undoubtedly encourage the embracing of fandom and inspire many to contribute their stories to cultural history, and to share their personal Jesus, John, or their private whomever." —Allison Bumstead, Journal of Beatles Studies
“Given how much support women and girls provided the Beatles before they became cultural icons, it’s astounding how absent female voices have been from Beatles history even fifty-plus years later. My Private Lennon fills that gap and will inspire other female voices to be heard.” —Caryn Rose, author of B-Sides and Broken Hearts