The Art of the Network: Strategic Interaction and Patronage in Renaissance Florence
by Paul D. McLean series edited by Julia Adams and George Steinmetz
Duke University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-8223-4100-0 | Paper: 978-0-8223-4117-8 | eISBN: 978-0-8223-9036-7 Library of Congress Classification DG735.6.M39 2007 Dewey Decimal Classification 945.51
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Writing letters to powerful people to win their favor and garner rewards such as political office, tax relief, and recommendations was an institution in Renaissance Florence; the practice was an important tool for those seeking social mobility, security, and recognition by others. In this detailed study of political and social patronage in fifteenth-century Florence, Paul D. McLean shows that patronage was much more than a pursuit of specific rewards. It was also a pursuit of relationships and of a self defined in relation to others. To become independent in Renaissance Florence, one first had to become connected. With The Art of the Network, McLean fills a gap in sociological scholarship by tracing the historical antecedents of networking and examining the concept of self that accompanies it. His analysis of patronage opens into a critique of contemporary theories about social networks and social capital, and an exploration of the sociological meaning of “culture.”
McLean scrutinized thousands of letters to and from Renaissance Florentines. He describes the social protocols the letters reveal, paying particular attention to the means by which Florentines crafted credible presentations of themselves. The letters, McLean contends, testify to the development not only of new forms of self-presentation but also of a new kind of self to be presented: an emergent, “modern” conception of self as an autonomous agent. They also bring to the fore the importance that their writers attached to concepts of honor, and the ways that they perceived themselves in relation to the Florentine state.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Paul D. McLean is Associate Professor of Sociology at Rutgers University.
REVIEWS
“The Art of the Network is a magnificent contribution to the social history of Renaissance Florence and the sociological study of how networks manifest themselves in complex societies. Paul D. McLean addresses with gusto such fundamental issues as the nature of social capital, the preservation of self, and the development of the ‘individual’ in European history. This will be a controversial book for all the right reasons.”—William J. Connell, Seton Hall University, editor of Society and Individual in Renaissance Florence
“Paul D. McLean weaves slants from Bourdieu and Swidler and Goffman together into his own trenchant vision of networking as identity process. You get analytic power along with rich historical understanding wrung from recalcitrant handwriting and ambiguous pronouncements in hundreds of letters across two centuries. Yet McLean is also witty and playful. His brief conclusion is an account of agency and culture so lucid as to be transposable to studies of your own.”—Harrison C. White, Columbia University, author of Identity and Control: A Structural Theory of Social Action
“The Art of the Network is more than a tour de force of textual analysis and historical explanation. McLean has written a significant work of sociological theory that makes new contributions to ongoing debates on the nature of social identity and the relationship between agency and structure. . . . This innovative book, as exemplar and prescription, deserves serious attention from cultural and historical sociologists as well as from theorists.”
-- Richard Lachmann American Journal of Sociology
“By providing a lucid and plausible account of how interaction is constituted by cultural work, he does a great service for those who wish to be analytical about culture in social networks. McLean’s rich description of rhetorical devices with which interactions are expressed provides a useful taxonomy for further explanatory analysis of culture and interaction.”
-- Hrag Balian Canadian Journal of Sociology
“McLean’s study of the material and the process is the most systematic study ever undertaken, and for patronage letter junkies like myself it makes compulsive reading. . . . Historians can lean much from this book.”
-- Dale Kent American Historical Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
List of Tables and Figures ix
Preface xi
1. The Principles of Networking as a Social Process 1
2. The Rhetoric and Design of Florentine Letter Writing 35
3. The Socially Contested Concept of Honor 59
4. What Gets Said When in Patronage Letters 90
5. The Dynamics of Office Seeking 121
6. Friends of Friends: Raccomandazione as Rhetoric and as Constitutive Principle 150
7. Patronage and the Stalled Transformation of the State 170
8. “Servants and Slaves in Everything and for Everything”: Renaissance Networking and the Emergent Modern Self? 193
Conclusion: Culture and the Network 224
Notes 231
Bibliography 255
Index 279
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
The Art of the Network: Strategic Interaction and Patronage in Renaissance Florence
by Paul D. McLean series edited by Julia Adams and George Steinmetz
Duke University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-8223-4100-0 Paper: 978-0-8223-4117-8 eISBN: 978-0-8223-9036-7
Writing letters to powerful people to win their favor and garner rewards such as political office, tax relief, and recommendations was an institution in Renaissance Florence; the practice was an important tool for those seeking social mobility, security, and recognition by others. In this detailed study of political and social patronage in fifteenth-century Florence, Paul D. McLean shows that patronage was much more than a pursuit of specific rewards. It was also a pursuit of relationships and of a self defined in relation to others. To become independent in Renaissance Florence, one first had to become connected. With The Art of the Network, McLean fills a gap in sociological scholarship by tracing the historical antecedents of networking and examining the concept of self that accompanies it. His analysis of patronage opens into a critique of contemporary theories about social networks and social capital, and an exploration of the sociological meaning of “culture.”
McLean scrutinized thousands of letters to and from Renaissance Florentines. He describes the social protocols the letters reveal, paying particular attention to the means by which Florentines crafted credible presentations of themselves. The letters, McLean contends, testify to the development not only of new forms of self-presentation but also of a new kind of self to be presented: an emergent, “modern” conception of self as an autonomous agent. They also bring to the fore the importance that their writers attached to concepts of honor, and the ways that they perceived themselves in relation to the Florentine state.
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Paul D. McLean is Associate Professor of Sociology at Rutgers University.
REVIEWS
“The Art of the Network is a magnificent contribution to the social history of Renaissance Florence and the sociological study of how networks manifest themselves in complex societies. Paul D. McLean addresses with gusto such fundamental issues as the nature of social capital, the preservation of self, and the development of the ‘individual’ in European history. This will be a controversial book for all the right reasons.”—William J. Connell, Seton Hall University, editor of Society and Individual in Renaissance Florence
“Paul D. McLean weaves slants from Bourdieu and Swidler and Goffman together into his own trenchant vision of networking as identity process. You get analytic power along with rich historical understanding wrung from recalcitrant handwriting and ambiguous pronouncements in hundreds of letters across two centuries. Yet McLean is also witty and playful. His brief conclusion is an account of agency and culture so lucid as to be transposable to studies of your own.”—Harrison C. White, Columbia University, author of Identity and Control: A Structural Theory of Social Action
“The Art of the Network is more than a tour de force of textual analysis and historical explanation. McLean has written a significant work of sociological theory that makes new contributions to ongoing debates on the nature of social identity and the relationship between agency and structure. . . . This innovative book, as exemplar and prescription, deserves serious attention from cultural and historical sociologists as well as from theorists.”
-- Richard Lachmann American Journal of Sociology
“By providing a lucid and plausible account of how interaction is constituted by cultural work, he does a great service for those who wish to be analytical about culture in social networks. McLean’s rich description of rhetorical devices with which interactions are expressed provides a useful taxonomy for further explanatory analysis of culture and interaction.”
-- Hrag Balian Canadian Journal of Sociology
“McLean’s study of the material and the process is the most systematic study ever undertaken, and for patronage letter junkies like myself it makes compulsive reading. . . . Historians can lean much from this book.”
-- Dale Kent American Historical Review
TABLE OF CONTENTS
List of Tables and Figures ix
Preface xi
1. The Principles of Networking as a Social Process 1
2. The Rhetoric and Design of Florentine Letter Writing 35
3. The Socially Contested Concept of Honor 59
4. What Gets Said When in Patronage Letters 90
5. The Dynamics of Office Seeking 121
6. Friends of Friends: Raccomandazione as Rhetoric and as Constitutive Principle 150
7. Patronage and the Stalled Transformation of the State 170
8. “Servants and Slaves in Everything and for Everything”: Renaissance Networking and the Emergent Modern Self? 193
Conclusion: Culture and the Network 224
Notes 231
Bibliography 255
Index 279
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE