Hermann Beck's study of the authoritarian welfare state in Prussia in the generation before 1870 is an interesting combination of intellectual, social, and political history. The book is well-researched, strategically utilizing some documents from the old German Central Archive in Merseburg but based primarily on the wealth of published primary sources that historians of nineteenth-century Germany must master.
— American Historical Review
Beck's approach of looking for connections between intellectual models and practical politics offers an interesting perspective. His analysis allows an ideoogical-critical view of the Prussian bureaucracy to be honed, and its actions to be seen as the expression of a conservative spirit.
— Bulleting of the German Historical Institute (London)
Beck has made a significant contribution to our knowledge of pre-Bismarckian social policy. The work will be of interest to historians of social policy and statebuilding, as well as to students of German political thought.
— Journal of Social History
Yet another book on the Prussian bureaucracy? Yet, and a well-researched and well-written one raising new questions and using sources inadequately explored. [An] extended introduction on pauperism and the social question in Prussia between 1815 and 1870 . . . deserves to be read for its own sake . . . .
— Central European History