Racism, Xenophobia, and Distribution: Multi-Issue Politics in Advanced Democracies
by John E. Roemer, Woojin Lee and Karine Van der Straeten
Harvard University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-674-02495-3 Library of Congress Classification HB523.R623 2007 Dewey Decimal Classification 305.80015195
ABOUT THIS BOOK | REVIEWS | TOC
ABOUT THIS BOOK
From the Republican Party's "Southern Strategy" in the U.S. to the rise of Le Pen's National Front in France, conservative politicians in the last thirty years have capitalized on voters' resentment of ethnic minorities to win votes and undermine government aid to the poor. In this book, the authors construct a theoretical model to calculate the effect of voters' attitudes about race and immigration on political parties' stances on income distribution.
Drawing on empirical data from the U.S., Britain, Denmark, and France, they use their model to show how parties choose their platforms and compete for votes. They find that the Right is able to push fiscal policies that hurt working and middle class citizens by attracting voters who may be liberal on economic issues but who hold conservative views on race or immigration. The authors estimate that if all voters held non-racist views, liberal and conservative parties alike would have proposed levels of redistribution 10 to 20 percent higher than they did. Combining historical analysis and empirical rigor with major theoretical advances, the book yields fascinating insights into how politicians exploit social issues to advance their economic agenda.
REVIEWS
This book presents an enormously original and important line of thought, partly for its topical importance, but as much for its development and exposition of important new theoretical tools that have a very wide range of application to problems not yet imagined. The extended consideration of the impact of the ‘ethnic dimension’ will permit readers to assess the new methods in a concrete context.
-- John Ferejohn, Stanford University
In Racism, Xenophobia, and Distribution, the authors demonstrate how attitudes toward racial and ethnic minorities in modern democracies can have a measurable and significant impact on the nature of competition between Left and Right, on equilibrium political coalitions, and redistributive policies. This is an important contribution to the field of political economy, both methodologically and substantively. There exist few econometric studies in political economy that are based on equilibrium models of the type used by the authors. Even fewer exist with the sophistication and depth of analysis found in this book.
-- Tasos Kalandrakis, University of Rochester
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Political cqui]ibrium: Theory and Application 14
21 The Data 14
SCharacterization of PUNE as a System of Equations 17
2.3 The Probability-of-Victorv Function 2:
2.1 Factional Bargaining Powers 22
2.5 The Three-Party Model
2.6 First Application: The Logarithmic Utility Function
.7 Sccond Application: The Euclidean Utility Function
2.8 Conclusion
3 History of Racial Politics in the United States 41
31 Ihntroducrion 4
3,2 Race and American Exceptionalism 44
3 3 issue Evolution 46
3.4 The Dixiecrats 9
3, CThe Presidential Election of 1964 and its Aftermath _6
.6 lihe Reagan Democrats 6l
3.7 Race, Class, and Welfare Reform in the 1990s 64
38 Conclusion 66
4 United States: Quantitative Analysis 68
4.J Introduction 68
4.2 Recovering Voter Racism from Survey Data 69
43 Estimation of the Model's Parameters 92
4.4 Numerical Solution of the Log Utility Model 113
4.5 The Euclidean Function Approach 123
4.6 Conclusion 127
5 History of Racism and Xenophobia min e United Kingdom 130
5.1 Introduction 130
5.2 Immigration in Britain 135
5.3 An Issue of"High Potential" 138
5.4 From Powel to Thatcher: Challenging the Consensus 148
5.5 The Rise of Thatcher and the Breakdown of the
Consensus of Silence 753
5.6 Immigration in the 1990s and Beyond 159
5.7 Conclusion 164
6 United Kingdom: Quantitative Analysis 166
61 Inntroduction 166
62 Minorities, Race, and Class Politics in the UK 168
6.3 Estimation of Parameters 273
6.4 The PBE and ASE: Computation i80
6.5 Conclusion 190
7 mmigration: A Challenge to Tolerant Denmark 719
7.1 Introduction 191
7.2 The Early Years: Guest iWorkers and Their Famniies 19
"73 The Eighties: The Emergence of Refugees 195
"74 The Nineties: Xenophobia Emerges, Front and Center 97
7.5 No Longer Marginal: The Far Right and the Election of 2001 202
8 Denmark: Quantitative Analysis 205
8. Parties and Issues 205
8.2 Estimation of the Models Parameters 7I0
8.3 Political Equilibrium: Observation and Prediction 26
8.4 The Policy-Bundle and Antisolidarity Effects: Computation 23
85 Conclusion 235
9 irImmigration and the Political institutionalization of Xenophobia
in France 237
9.1 Introduction 237
9.2 immgration in France: A Brief Sketch 238
.- The Politicization of Immigration 243
94 The Rise of Le Pen 246
935 The Mainstreaming of Xenophobia -1
9.0 The 1988 Presidential Election 250
9. Xenophobia Remains in the Headlines 22
9.8 Conventional Politics Return as a New Cleavage Is Born 25
9.9 Conciusion 263
10 Francle Quiantitative Analysis 265
10.1 Parties and Voter Opinion 265
112 Political Equilibrium with Three Parties 268
10.3 Estimation of Mode Parameters 273
10.4 Political Equilibrium: Observation and Prediction 289
i0. 5 The Policy-Bundle and Antisolidarity Effects: Computation 30
1 . Conclusion j3
Il.1 The Rise of the New Right Movement 3-0
11.2 Recapitulation 1 08
i1.3 The Log Uility Function Approach 312
L1.4 The Euclidean Utility Function Approach 3' 4
11.3 Limitations ,31
S116 Final Remark 320
Racism, Xenophobia, and Distribution: Multi-Issue Politics in Advanced Democracies
by John E. Roemer, Woojin Lee and Karine Van der Straeten
Harvard University Press, 2007 Cloth: 978-0-674-02495-3
From the Republican Party's "Southern Strategy" in the U.S. to the rise of Le Pen's National Front in France, conservative politicians in the last thirty years have capitalized on voters' resentment of ethnic minorities to win votes and undermine government aid to the poor. In this book, the authors construct a theoretical model to calculate the effect of voters' attitudes about race and immigration on political parties' stances on income distribution.
Drawing on empirical data from the U.S., Britain, Denmark, and France, they use their model to show how parties choose their platforms and compete for votes. They find that the Right is able to push fiscal policies that hurt working and middle class citizens by attracting voters who may be liberal on economic issues but who hold conservative views on race or immigration. The authors estimate that if all voters held non-racist views, liberal and conservative parties alike would have proposed levels of redistribution 10 to 20 percent higher than they did. Combining historical analysis and empirical rigor with major theoretical advances, the book yields fascinating insights into how politicians exploit social issues to advance their economic agenda.
REVIEWS
This book presents an enormously original and important line of thought, partly for its topical importance, but as much for its development and exposition of important new theoretical tools that have a very wide range of application to problems not yet imagined. The extended consideration of the impact of the ‘ethnic dimension’ will permit readers to assess the new methods in a concrete context.
-- John Ferejohn, Stanford University
In Racism, Xenophobia, and Distribution, the authors demonstrate how attitudes toward racial and ethnic minorities in modern democracies can have a measurable and significant impact on the nature of competition between Left and Right, on equilibrium political coalitions, and redistributive policies. This is an important contribution to the field of political economy, both methodologically and substantively. There exist few econometric studies in political economy that are based on equilibrium models of the type used by the authors. Even fewer exist with the sophistication and depth of analysis found in this book.
-- Tasos Kalandrakis, University of Rochester
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Political cqui]ibrium: Theory and Application 14
21 The Data 14
SCharacterization of PUNE as a System of Equations 17
2.3 The Probability-of-Victorv Function 2:
2.1 Factional Bargaining Powers 22
2.5 The Three-Party Model
2.6 First Application: The Logarithmic Utility Function
.7 Sccond Application: The Euclidean Utility Function
2.8 Conclusion
3 History of Racial Politics in the United States 41
31 Ihntroducrion 4
3,2 Race and American Exceptionalism 44
3 3 issue Evolution 46
3.4 The Dixiecrats 9
3, CThe Presidential Election of 1964 and its Aftermath _6
.6 lihe Reagan Democrats 6l
3.7 Race, Class, and Welfare Reform in the 1990s 64
38 Conclusion 66
4 United States: Quantitative Analysis 68
4.J Introduction 68
4.2 Recovering Voter Racism from Survey Data 69
43 Estimation of the Model's Parameters 92
4.4 Numerical Solution of the Log Utility Model 113
4.5 The Euclidean Function Approach 123
4.6 Conclusion 127
5 History of Racism and Xenophobia min e United Kingdom 130
5.1 Introduction 130
5.2 Immigration in Britain 135
5.3 An Issue of"High Potential" 138
5.4 From Powel to Thatcher: Challenging the Consensus 148
5.5 The Rise of Thatcher and the Breakdown of the
Consensus of Silence 753
5.6 Immigration in the 1990s and Beyond 159
5.7 Conclusion 164
6 United Kingdom: Quantitative Analysis 166
61 Inntroduction 166
62 Minorities, Race, and Class Politics in the UK 168
6.3 Estimation of Parameters 273
6.4 The PBE and ASE: Computation i80
6.5 Conclusion 190
7 mmigration: A Challenge to Tolerant Denmark 719
7.1 Introduction 191
7.2 The Early Years: Guest iWorkers and Their Famniies 19
"73 The Eighties: The Emergence of Refugees 195
"74 The Nineties: Xenophobia Emerges, Front and Center 97
7.5 No Longer Marginal: The Far Right and the Election of 2001 202
8 Denmark: Quantitative Analysis 205
8. Parties and Issues 205
8.2 Estimation of the Models Parameters 7I0
8.3 Political Equilibrium: Observation and Prediction 26
8.4 The Policy-Bundle and Antisolidarity Effects: Computation 23
85 Conclusion 235
9 irImmigration and the Political institutionalization of Xenophobia
in France 237
9.1 Introduction 237
9.2 immgration in France: A Brief Sketch 238
.- The Politicization of Immigration 243
94 The Rise of Le Pen 246
935 The Mainstreaming of Xenophobia -1
9.0 The 1988 Presidential Election 250
9. Xenophobia Remains in the Headlines 22
9.8 Conventional Politics Return as a New Cleavage Is Born 25
9.9 Conciusion 263
10 Francle Quiantitative Analysis 265
10.1 Parties and Voter Opinion 265
112 Political Equilibrium with Three Parties 268
10.3 Estimation of Mode Parameters 273
10.4 Political Equilibrium: Observation and Prediction 289
i0. 5 The Policy-Bundle and Antisolidarity Effects: Computation 30
1 . Conclusion j3
Il.1 The Rise of the New Right Movement 3-0
11.2 Recapitulation 1 08
i1.3 The Log Uility Function Approach 312
L1.4 The Euclidean Utility Function Approach 3' 4
11.3 Limitations ,31
S116 Final Remark 320