Shakesqueer: A Queer Companion to the Complete Works of Shakespeare
edited by Madhavi Menon series edited by Michèle Aina Barale, Jonathan Goldberg, Michael Moon and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick
Duke University Press, 2011 Paper: 978-0-8223-4845-0 | eISBN: 978-0-8223-9333-7 | Cloth: 978-0-8223-4833-7 Library of Congress Classification PR2976.S346 2011 Dewey Decimal Classification 822.33
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
ABOUT THIS BOOK
Shakesqueer puts the most exciting queer theorists in conversation with the complete works of William Shakespeare. Exploring what is odd, eccentric, and unexpected in the Bard’s plays and poems, these theorists highlight not only the many ways that Shakespeare can be queered but also the many ways that Shakespeare can enrich queer theory. This innovative anthology reveals an early modern playwright insistently returning to questions of language, identity, and temporality, themes central to contemporary queer theory. Since many of the contributors do not study early modern literature, Shakesqueer takes queer theory back and brings Shakespeare forward, challenging the chronological confinement of queer theory to the last two hundred years. The book also challenges conceptual certainties that have narrowly equated queerness with homosexuality. Chasing all manner of stray desires through every one of Shakespeare’s plays and poems, the contributors cross temporal, animal, theoretical, and sexual boundaries with abandon. Claiming adherence to no one school of thought, the essays consider The Winter’s Tale alongside network TV, Hamlet in relation to the death drive, King John as a history of queer theory, and Much Ado About Nothing in tune with a Sondheim musical. Together they expand the reach of queerness and queer critique across chronologies, methodologies, and bodies.
Contributors. Matt Bell, Amanda Berry, Daniel Boyarin, Judith Brown, Steven Bruhm, Peter Coviello, Julie Crawford, Drew Daniel, Mario DiGangi, Lee Edelman, Jason Edwards, Aranye Fradenburg, Carla Freccero, Daniel Juan Gil, Jonathan Goldberg, Jody Greene, Stephen Guy-Bray, Ellis Hanson, Sharon Holland, Cary Howie, Lynne Huffer, Barbara Johnson, Hector Kollias, James Kuzner , Arthur L. Little Jr., Philip Lorenz, Heather Love, Jeffrey Masten, Robert McRuer , Madhavi Menon, Michael Moon, Paul Morrison, Andrew Nicholls, Kevin Ohi, Patrick R. O’Malley, Ann Pellegrini, Richard Rambuss, Valerie Rohy, Bethany Schneider, Kathryn Schwarz, Laurie Shannon, Ashley T. Shelden, Alan Sinfield, Bruce Smith, Karl Steel, Kathryn Bond Stockton, Amy Villarejo, Julian Yates
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Madhavi Menon is Associate Professor of Literature at American University. She is the author of Unhistorical Shakespeare: Queer Theory in Shakespearean Literature and Film and Wanton Words: Rhetoric and Sexuality in English Renaissance Drama.
REVIEWS
“The adventurous essays in Shakesqueer demonstrate that queer theory does indeed need Shakespeare, if only to defy rumors of its own demise: the essays show what is vital about a queer studies that might have been thought by this point too domesticated or reified or ‘fixed’ to be intellectually vibrant.”—Carolyn Dinshaw, author of Getting Medieval: Sexualities and Communities, Pre- and Postmodern
“What happens when queer theory gets into bed with Shakespeare? A play in forty-eight acts, this spirited group production never ceases to entertain and surprise with its queer cast of characters: virgins, eunuchs, and lechers; queens, kings, and pageboys; tyrants, assassins, and killjoys; lions, tigers, and bears—oh my! Full of toil and trouble, wit and wisdom, Shakesqueer succeeds where few other edited collections do: it puts the play back in playwright, and the fun back in theory.”—Diana Fuss, Princeton University
“In the end, this book is a big, glorious mess, full of playful juxtapositions and frightening possibilities. It is thrilling. Theatre scholars, queer theorists, actors, directors, and dramaturges will all find something useful and interesting.”
-- Michael Cramer Sixteenth Century Journal
“When studying endless Shakespeare plays on English Literature courses, we always had a hunch there were some exceptionally queer goings on beyond some same sex sonnets and this collection of essays proves us right. Earl on earl analysis sits beside complex queer theories on the bard.”
-- Gay Times
“Few works of literary criticism deserve the descriptor ‘monumental,’ but this one does. . . . The book is both readable and witty. It is also important, for it drives the final nail into the coffin of 20th-century Shakespearean studies. . . . No hierarchies survive this book. Every play and poem receives a fresh new reading. . . . Essential. All readers.”
-- M. J. Emery Choice
“If you're looking for clues to Romeo and Mercutio's secret romance in the new academic volume Shakesqueer : A Queer Companion to the Complete Works of Shakespeare, edited by Madhavi Menon (Duke), you're barking up the wrong yew tree. American University professor Menon and her queer-theorist contributors find queerness in Shakespeare in that term's most all-encompassing meaning of oddball, unusual, or non-normative. But when you come to think of it, fairy queen Titania falling in love with an ass named Bottom is pretty queer, in all senses of the word.”
-- Roberto Friedman Bay Area Reporter
“It is rare to see a volume that does so much, and does it with such consistent wit, thoughtfulness, and creativity. . . . In putting together this volume, Menon has done scholars from all fields and periods an immense service. Shakesqueer gives us a very queer new reading ‘’companion’’ — friend, helpmeet, comrade-in-arms — that makes us exquisitely aware of the need for the perverse and disruptive critical practice its essays so pleasurably model.”
-- Melissa E. Sanchez Renaissance Quarterly
“There’s something for every queer scholar and Bard-lover in the anthology; from bears in Henry VIII to eunuchs in Antony and Cleopatra, from the death drive in Hamlet to precariously heterosexual marriages in All’s Well that Ends Well, the contributing authors chart Shakespeare’s varied engagements with queerness, putting pressure on assumptions that Shakespeare has nothing to offer to contemporary queer theory. . . . The assorted essays assert that Shakespeare has as much to offer queer theory as queer theory can contribute to understanding and deconstructing the Bard’s texts. This book belongs on every bookish queer’s shelf, right where the leather-bound Complete Works of William Shakespeare butts up against Butler and Foucault.”
-- Kestryl Cael Lowrey Lambda Literary Review
“This fascinating collection of essays explores the queer elements within all of Shakespeare’s works. With contributions from scholars of both queer studies and Shakespeare, the volume represents a joining of the two fields rarely attempted before.”
-- Charles Green Gay & Lesbian Review
“[Shakesqueer] manages to put the fun back into academic research. Shakesqueer is a highly entertaining collection of essays, which all focus on the strange, the unusual, that is, the queer element in the Shakespearean oeuvre.”
-- Veronika Schandl European Journal of English Studies
"For 'insider experts'—those who are Shakespeareans, queer theorists, or both (always, already, at once)—Shakesqueer provides a garden of delights between its covers. . . . Shakesqueer extends, enriches, and strengthens the vocabulary of Shakespeare criticism in concert with queer theory."
-- Stephen F. Evans Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Teaching
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction. Queer Shakes / Madhavi Menon 1
All is True (Henry VIII) The Unbearable Sex of Henry VIII / Steven Bruhm 28
All's Well That Ends Well Is Marriage Always Already Heterosexual? / Julie Crawford 39
Antony and Cleopatra Aught an Eunuch Has / Ellis Hanson 48
As You Like It Fortune's Turn / Valerie Rohy 55
Cardenio "Absonant Desire": The Question of Cardenio / Philip Lorenz 62
The Comedy of Errors In Praise of Error / Lynne Huffer 72
Coriolanus "Tell Me Not Wherein I Seem Unnatural": Queer Meditations on Coriolanus in the Time of War / Jason Edwards 80
Cymbeline desire vomit emptiness: Cymbeline's Marriage Time / Amanda Berry 89
Hamlet Hamlet's Wounded Name / Lee Edelman 97
Henry IV, Part 1 When Harry Met Harry / Matt Bell 106
Henry IV, Part 2 The Deep Structure of Sexuality: War and Masochism in Henry IV, Part 2 / Daniel Juan Gil 114
King Henry V Scrambling Harry and Sampling Hal / Drew Daniel 121
Henry VI, Part 1 "Wounded Alpha Bad Boy Soldier" / Mario Digangi 130
Henry VI, Part 2 The Gayest Play Ever / Stephen Guy-Bray 139
Henry VI, Part 3 Stay / Cary Howie 146
Julius Caeser Thus, Always: Julius Caesar and Abraham Lincoln / Bethany Schneider 152
King John Queer Futility: Or, The Life and Death of King John / Kathryn Schwarz 163
King Lear Lear's Queer Cosmos / Laurie Shannon 171
A Lover's Complaint Learning How to Love (Again) / Ashley T. Shelden 179
Love's Labour's Lost The L Words / Madhavi Menon 187
Love's Labour's Won Doctorin' the Bard: A Contemporary Appropriation of Love's Labour's Won / Hector Kollias 194
Macbeth Milk / Heather Love 201
Measure for Measure Same-Saint Desire / Paul Morrison 209
The Merchant of Venice The Rites of Queer Marriage in The Merchant of Venice / Arthur L. Little Jr. 216
The Merry Wives of Windsor What Do Women Want? / Jonathan Goldberg 225
A Midsummer Night's Dream Shakespeare's Ass Play / Richard Rambuss 234
Much Ado About Nothing Closing Ranks, Keeping Company: Marriage Plots and the Will to be Single in Much Ado About Nothing / Ann Pellegrini 245
Othello Othello's Penis: Or, Islam in the Closet / Daniel Boyarin 254
Pericles "Curious Pleasures": Pericles beyond the Civility of Union / Patrick O'Malley 263
The Phoenix and the Turtle Number There in Love Was Slain / Karl Steel 271
The Rape of Lucree Desire My Pilot Is / Peter Coviello 278
Richard II Pretty Richard / Judith Brown 286
Richard III Fuck the Disabled: The Prequel / Robert McRuer 294
Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet Love Death / Carla Freccero 302
Sir Thomas More More or Less Queer / Jeffrey Masten 309
The Sonnets Momma's Boy / Aranye Fradenburg 319
Speech Therapy / Barbara Johnson 328
More Life: Shakespeare's Sonnet Machines / Julian Yates 333
The Taming of the Shrew Latin Lovers in The Taming of the Shrew / Bruce Smith 343
The Tempest Forgetting The Tempest / Kevin Ohi 351
Timon of Athens Skepticism, Sovereignty, Sodomy / James Kuzner 361
Titus Andronicus A Child's Garden of Atrocities / Michael Moon 369
Troilus and Cressida The Leather Men and the Lovely Boy: Reading Positions in Troilus and Cressida / Alan Sinfeild 376
Twelfth Night Is There an Audience for My Play? / Sharon Holland 385
The Two Gentlemen of Verona Pageboy, or The Two Gentlemen of Verona: The Movie / Amy Villajero 394
The Two Noble Kinsmen Philadelphia, or War / Jody Greene 404
Venus and Adonis421 Venus and Adonis Freeze / Andrew Nicholls 414
The Winter's Tale Lost, or "Exit, Pursued by a Bear": Causing Queer Children on Shakespeare's TV / Kathryn Bond Stockton 421
References 429
Further Reading 449
Contributors 467
Index 477
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
Shakesqueer: A Queer Companion to the Complete Works of Shakespeare
edited by Madhavi Menon series edited by Michèle Aina Barale, Jonathan Goldberg, Michael Moon and Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick
Duke University Press, 2011 Paper: 978-0-8223-4845-0 eISBN: 978-0-8223-9333-7 Cloth: 978-0-8223-4833-7
Shakesqueer puts the most exciting queer theorists in conversation with the complete works of William Shakespeare. Exploring what is odd, eccentric, and unexpected in the Bard’s plays and poems, these theorists highlight not only the many ways that Shakespeare can be queered but also the many ways that Shakespeare can enrich queer theory. This innovative anthology reveals an early modern playwright insistently returning to questions of language, identity, and temporality, themes central to contemporary queer theory. Since many of the contributors do not study early modern literature, Shakesqueer takes queer theory back and brings Shakespeare forward, challenging the chronological confinement of queer theory to the last two hundred years. The book also challenges conceptual certainties that have narrowly equated queerness with homosexuality. Chasing all manner of stray desires through every one of Shakespeare’s plays and poems, the contributors cross temporal, animal, theoretical, and sexual boundaries with abandon. Claiming adherence to no one school of thought, the essays consider The Winter’s Tale alongside network TV, Hamlet in relation to the death drive, King John as a history of queer theory, and Much Ado About Nothing in tune with a Sondheim musical. Together they expand the reach of queerness and queer critique across chronologies, methodologies, and bodies.
Contributors. Matt Bell, Amanda Berry, Daniel Boyarin, Judith Brown, Steven Bruhm, Peter Coviello, Julie Crawford, Drew Daniel, Mario DiGangi, Lee Edelman, Jason Edwards, Aranye Fradenburg, Carla Freccero, Daniel Juan Gil, Jonathan Goldberg, Jody Greene, Stephen Guy-Bray, Ellis Hanson, Sharon Holland, Cary Howie, Lynne Huffer, Barbara Johnson, Hector Kollias, James Kuzner , Arthur L. Little Jr., Philip Lorenz, Heather Love, Jeffrey Masten, Robert McRuer , Madhavi Menon, Michael Moon, Paul Morrison, Andrew Nicholls, Kevin Ohi, Patrick R. O’Malley, Ann Pellegrini, Richard Rambuss, Valerie Rohy, Bethany Schneider, Kathryn Schwarz, Laurie Shannon, Ashley T. Shelden, Alan Sinfield, Bruce Smith, Karl Steel, Kathryn Bond Stockton, Amy Villarejo, Julian Yates
AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY
Madhavi Menon is Associate Professor of Literature at American University. She is the author of Unhistorical Shakespeare: Queer Theory in Shakespearean Literature and Film and Wanton Words: Rhetoric and Sexuality in English Renaissance Drama.
REVIEWS
“The adventurous essays in Shakesqueer demonstrate that queer theory does indeed need Shakespeare, if only to defy rumors of its own demise: the essays show what is vital about a queer studies that might have been thought by this point too domesticated or reified or ‘fixed’ to be intellectually vibrant.”—Carolyn Dinshaw, author of Getting Medieval: Sexualities and Communities, Pre- and Postmodern
“What happens when queer theory gets into bed with Shakespeare? A play in forty-eight acts, this spirited group production never ceases to entertain and surprise with its queer cast of characters: virgins, eunuchs, and lechers; queens, kings, and pageboys; tyrants, assassins, and killjoys; lions, tigers, and bears—oh my! Full of toil and trouble, wit and wisdom, Shakesqueer succeeds where few other edited collections do: it puts the play back in playwright, and the fun back in theory.”—Diana Fuss, Princeton University
“In the end, this book is a big, glorious mess, full of playful juxtapositions and frightening possibilities. It is thrilling. Theatre scholars, queer theorists, actors, directors, and dramaturges will all find something useful and interesting.”
-- Michael Cramer Sixteenth Century Journal
“When studying endless Shakespeare plays on English Literature courses, we always had a hunch there were some exceptionally queer goings on beyond some same sex sonnets and this collection of essays proves us right. Earl on earl analysis sits beside complex queer theories on the bard.”
-- Gay Times
“Few works of literary criticism deserve the descriptor ‘monumental,’ but this one does. . . . The book is both readable and witty. It is also important, for it drives the final nail into the coffin of 20th-century Shakespearean studies. . . . No hierarchies survive this book. Every play and poem receives a fresh new reading. . . . Essential. All readers.”
-- M. J. Emery Choice
“If you're looking for clues to Romeo and Mercutio's secret romance in the new academic volume Shakesqueer : A Queer Companion to the Complete Works of Shakespeare, edited by Madhavi Menon (Duke), you're barking up the wrong yew tree. American University professor Menon and her queer-theorist contributors find queerness in Shakespeare in that term's most all-encompassing meaning of oddball, unusual, or non-normative. But when you come to think of it, fairy queen Titania falling in love with an ass named Bottom is pretty queer, in all senses of the word.”
-- Roberto Friedman Bay Area Reporter
“It is rare to see a volume that does so much, and does it with such consistent wit, thoughtfulness, and creativity. . . . In putting together this volume, Menon has done scholars from all fields and periods an immense service. Shakesqueer gives us a very queer new reading ‘’companion’’ — friend, helpmeet, comrade-in-arms — that makes us exquisitely aware of the need for the perverse and disruptive critical practice its essays so pleasurably model.”
-- Melissa E. Sanchez Renaissance Quarterly
“There’s something for every queer scholar and Bard-lover in the anthology; from bears in Henry VIII to eunuchs in Antony and Cleopatra, from the death drive in Hamlet to precariously heterosexual marriages in All’s Well that Ends Well, the contributing authors chart Shakespeare’s varied engagements with queerness, putting pressure on assumptions that Shakespeare has nothing to offer to contemporary queer theory. . . . The assorted essays assert that Shakespeare has as much to offer queer theory as queer theory can contribute to understanding and deconstructing the Bard’s texts. This book belongs on every bookish queer’s shelf, right where the leather-bound Complete Works of William Shakespeare butts up against Butler and Foucault.”
-- Kestryl Cael Lowrey Lambda Literary Review
“This fascinating collection of essays explores the queer elements within all of Shakespeare’s works. With contributions from scholars of both queer studies and Shakespeare, the volume represents a joining of the two fields rarely attempted before.”
-- Charles Green Gay & Lesbian Review
“[Shakesqueer] manages to put the fun back into academic research. Shakesqueer is a highly entertaining collection of essays, which all focus on the strange, the unusual, that is, the queer element in the Shakespearean oeuvre.”
-- Veronika Schandl European Journal of English Studies
"For 'insider experts'—those who are Shakespeareans, queer theorists, or both (always, already, at once)—Shakesqueer provides a garden of delights between its covers. . . . Shakesqueer extends, enriches, and strengthens the vocabulary of Shakespeare criticism in concert with queer theory."
-- Stephen F. Evans Studies in Medieval and Renaissance Teaching
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments ix
Introduction. Queer Shakes / Madhavi Menon 1
All is True (Henry VIII) The Unbearable Sex of Henry VIII / Steven Bruhm 28
All's Well That Ends Well Is Marriage Always Already Heterosexual? / Julie Crawford 39
Antony and Cleopatra Aught an Eunuch Has / Ellis Hanson 48
As You Like It Fortune's Turn / Valerie Rohy 55
Cardenio "Absonant Desire": The Question of Cardenio / Philip Lorenz 62
The Comedy of Errors In Praise of Error / Lynne Huffer 72
Coriolanus "Tell Me Not Wherein I Seem Unnatural": Queer Meditations on Coriolanus in the Time of War / Jason Edwards 80
Cymbeline desire vomit emptiness: Cymbeline's Marriage Time / Amanda Berry 89
Hamlet Hamlet's Wounded Name / Lee Edelman 97
Henry IV, Part 1 When Harry Met Harry / Matt Bell 106
Henry IV, Part 2 The Deep Structure of Sexuality: War and Masochism in Henry IV, Part 2 / Daniel Juan Gil 114
King Henry V Scrambling Harry and Sampling Hal / Drew Daniel 121
Henry VI, Part 1 "Wounded Alpha Bad Boy Soldier" / Mario Digangi 130
Henry VI, Part 2 The Gayest Play Ever / Stephen Guy-Bray 139
Henry VI, Part 3 Stay / Cary Howie 146
Julius Caeser Thus, Always: Julius Caesar and Abraham Lincoln / Bethany Schneider 152
King John Queer Futility: Or, The Life and Death of King John / Kathryn Schwarz 163
King Lear Lear's Queer Cosmos / Laurie Shannon 171
A Lover's Complaint Learning How to Love (Again) / Ashley T. Shelden 179
Love's Labour's Lost The L Words / Madhavi Menon 187
Love's Labour's Won Doctorin' the Bard: A Contemporary Appropriation of Love's Labour's Won / Hector Kollias 194
Macbeth Milk / Heather Love 201
Measure for Measure Same-Saint Desire / Paul Morrison 209
The Merchant of Venice The Rites of Queer Marriage in The Merchant of Venice / Arthur L. Little Jr. 216
The Merry Wives of Windsor What Do Women Want? / Jonathan Goldberg 225
A Midsummer Night's Dream Shakespeare's Ass Play / Richard Rambuss 234
Much Ado About Nothing Closing Ranks, Keeping Company: Marriage Plots and the Will to be Single in Much Ado About Nothing / Ann Pellegrini 245
Othello Othello's Penis: Or, Islam in the Closet / Daniel Boyarin 254
Pericles "Curious Pleasures": Pericles beyond the Civility of Union / Patrick O'Malley 263
The Phoenix and the Turtle Number There in Love Was Slain / Karl Steel 271
The Rape of Lucree Desire My Pilot Is / Peter Coviello 278
Richard II Pretty Richard / Judith Brown 286
Richard III Fuck the Disabled: The Prequel / Robert McRuer 294
Romeo and Juliet Romeo and Juliet Love Death / Carla Freccero 302
Sir Thomas More More or Less Queer / Jeffrey Masten 309
The Sonnets Momma's Boy / Aranye Fradenburg 319
Speech Therapy / Barbara Johnson 328
More Life: Shakespeare's Sonnet Machines / Julian Yates 333
The Taming of the Shrew Latin Lovers in The Taming of the Shrew / Bruce Smith 343
The Tempest Forgetting The Tempest / Kevin Ohi 351
Timon of Athens Skepticism, Sovereignty, Sodomy / James Kuzner 361
Titus Andronicus A Child's Garden of Atrocities / Michael Moon 369
Troilus and Cressida The Leather Men and the Lovely Boy: Reading Positions in Troilus and Cressida / Alan Sinfeild 376
Twelfth Night Is There an Audience for My Play? / Sharon Holland 385
The Two Gentlemen of Verona Pageboy, or The Two Gentlemen of Verona: The Movie / Amy Villajero 394
The Two Noble Kinsmen Philadelphia, or War / Jody Greene 404
Venus and Adonis421 Venus and Adonis Freeze / Andrew Nicholls 414
The Winter's Tale Lost, or "Exit, Pursued by a Bear": Causing Queer Children on Shakespeare's TV / Kathryn Bond Stockton 421
References 429
Further Reading 449
Contributors 467
Index 477
REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE
If you are a student who cannot use this book in printed form, BiblioVault may be able to supply you
with an electronic file for alternative access.
Please have the accessibility coordinator at your school fill out this form.
It can take 2-3 weeks for requests to be filled.
ABOUT THIS BOOK | AUTHOR BIOGRAPHY | REVIEWS | TOC | REQUEST ACCESSIBLE FILE